>> Taxes and Spending

Issues

>> Research Bulletins


>> Special Reports



>> Health Points
Policy Briefings


Budget "Reform" Moves to Ballot

May 04, 2005

As expected, the state Senate voted today to place on November's statewide ballot a constitutional amendment that would greatly expand the Legislature's budgeting power at the Governor's expense. If enacted, it would represent the most sweeping shift of constitutional authority in New York State since the enactment of the current Executive Budget provisions (Article 4 and Article 7 of the Constitution) more than 75 years ago.

We've had a lot to say about this already -- here, for instance -- and will be saying more in the future.

For the time being, it's sufficient to observe that the amendment (A2) would:

* give legislators a strong new incentive to stall budget action until they pass the start of a new fiscal year, and
* effectively outlaw late budgets solely by dint of creating an automatic and permanent contingency budget, subject to changes the Legislature alone could originate (with added spending still subject to the Governor's veto).

Assuming the Legislature also moves the start of the state fiscal year from April 1 to May 1, as proposed in a separate implementing bill approved by both houses but vetoed Tuesday by Governor George Pataki, the first budget proposed by the next governor would be alive for just 89 days. The entire Executive Budget would then be automatically shoved into the trash if either house of the Legislature doesn't like it -- which, based on past experience, is highly likely.

Oh, and legislators will no longer forfeit pay for failing to pass a budget on time -- because, under this amendment, inaction on the Executive Budget would be tantamount to "final action" as far as the Constitution is concerned.

>> Op-Eds & Articles

Tax Hike May Cause Capital to Take a HikeThis is a link to an External Website
New York Sun April 16, 2008
Start BlazingThis is a link to an External Website
New York Sun March 18, 2008
After the Spitzer StormThis is a link to an External Website
Wall Street Journal March 15, 2008
Paterson's Challenges: Economic WoesThis is a link to an External Website
New York Post March 13, 2008
Eliot's Excellent IdeaThis is a link to an External Website
New York Post January 10, 2008

>> Testimony

E.J. McMahon Testimony: Real Property Taxation
Manhattan Institute for Policy Research April 17, 2007
E.J. McMahon Testimony: Joint Fiscal Committees of the New York State LegislatureThis is a link to an External Website
Manhattan Institute for Policy Research February 15, 2005
New York City Council Subcommittee on Forecasting and Revenue This is a link to an External Website
Manhattan Institute for Policy Research April 01, 2002

>> News & Commentary

Parsing the "Q-Poll" on Taxes
by E.J. McMahon March 24, 2008

>> Special Reports

Taylor Made: The Cost and Consequences of New York's Public-Sector Labor Laws
by Terry O'Neil and E.J. McMahon October 17, 2007
Defusing New York's Pension Bomb
By E.J. McMahon, Director, Empire Center for New York State Policy June 07, 2006
Taxing and Spending in the Empire State: Overview of the 2006-07 Executive Budget
By E.J. McMahon, Director, Empire Center for New York State Policy February 24, 2006

>> Related New York Policy Studies and Reports