gas-150x150-7822474Governor Andrew Cuomo’s decision to ban high-volume hydraulic fracturing in New York State is a huge blow to the fragile and declining economy of the Southern Tier.

The eight-county region bordering Pennsylvania, including the Binghamton and Elmira metropolitan areas, sits squarely atop the natural gas-rich Marcellus Shale formation, which underlies much of upstate New York as well as Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia. Earlier this month, the U.S. Energy Administration boosted by 50 percent its estimate of recoverable gas in the Marcellus Shale—beneath which lies the potentially even more lucrative Utica Shale.

As of 2010, the state’s own environmental impact statement projected that under an “average development scenario,” regulations clearing the way for high-volume hydraulic fracturing operations in upstate New York would result in the direct creation of 17,634 construction jobs and 7,161 production jobs, indirectly promoting creation of more than 29,000 jobs in other sectors. If Pennsylvania’s experience is any guide, the average fracking job in New York would pay about $62,000. A 2013 Manhattan Institute study found that, based on experiences in Pennsylvania, incomes could grow by 15 percent over four years in New York counties where fracking went forward.

If the state was allowing shale gas production to go forward, these earlier benefit projections would be suppressed, at least in the near term, by two factors. First, during the Cuomo administration’s long delay in reaching a final decision, dozens of communities have passed their own local tracking bans or moratoriums–although these ordinances are not necessarily permanent.  Second, the worldwide plunge in oil prices is expected to have a negative impact on gas production and investments in the short term (although residential gas prices in the northeast have been rising even as the price of heating oil plunges).

screen-shot-2014-12-17-at-2-57-45-pm-150x150-3835364Still, given the likely economic ripple effects–which would have spread into the Rochester, Syracuse and Utica-Rome areas as well–shale gas production was by far the most promising potential growth engine for a vast swath of upstate New York.

Now what? Cuomo is promising to come up with alternatives, but if the record of the past four years is any guide, these will inevitably involve further state spending–both in the form of direct government “investments,” such as those in Buffalo, and in lost revenues from tax-free zones.

Meanwhile, the chart below summarizes private sector job growth by New York metro area, along with the U.S. average for the past four years. Binghamton and Elmira are the only two New York metro areas to have lost private sector employment during the period. The next two weakest regions have been Utica-Rome and Syracuse—which, based on Ohio’s experience, might also have expected job gains in various sectors from tracking in the Southern Tier.  (Buffalo-Niagara Falls, which Cuomo cites as a success story, has experienced mediocre private job growth of 3.7 percent.)

screen-shot-2014-12-17-at-2-26-59-pm-3177709

The impact of the state Health Department’s anti-fracking decision—based on “uncertainties” rather then firm scientific findings of actual negative health effects—won’t be limited to the landowners who may have collected royalties from gas production or the local residents who might have gained employment from the industry. Manufacturers in other industries also stood to benefit from the development of a nearby source of inexpensive natural gas.

Meanwhile, during a four-year period in which nationwide manufacturing employment has risen by 5.3 percent, the number of manufacturing jobs has dropped 1.5 percent in downstate New York and 4 percent in upstate New York. Since October 2010, Binghamton and Elmira have each lost 19 percent of their manufacturing jobs.

This much is clear: the growth gap won’t be filled by casinos. The governor conceded as much in his public “cabinet meeting” today at which the fracking ban decision was announced, a few hours before a state casino siting board announced its decisions.

Tags:

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Another battery flop zaps NY taxpayers

Plans to lure a Canadian battery company to the Hudson Valley with a slew of government incentives, including job-creation tax credits, loans, and federal subsidies, appear to be a dud. It’s a reminder that when it comes to picking winners in the energy-storage space, taxpayers are often losers. Read More

NYSERDA’s Roadmap to Nowhere  

New York school districts face a multi-billion dollar unfunded mandate to convert to electric school buses. While the transition will cost between $8 and $15 billion above the cost of buying traditional buses, less than $1 billion in state and federal aid is likely to be available to help schools cover the cost. Read More

New Wind Energy Costs Blow the Doors Off Projections

The myth that New York can replace fossil fuel power plants with cheap renewable energy has begun to crumble under renewable developers’ demands for higher prices to offset inflation and supply chain challenges.  Read More

Renewable Solar Comes with Recurring Waste Costs

Within 25 years New York will find itself trying to manage the disposal of five million or more waste solar panels every year. Read More

First Annual CLCPA Report Indicates High Costs, Low Benefits

A major deception on emissions reductions lies at the heart of the New York Department of Public Service’s first annual report on implementation of the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act. Read More

Micron vs. New York Energy Policy 

Computer chip manufacturer Micron has revealed that by the 2040s its Onondaga County factories are going to be sucking up enough electricity to power New Hampshire and Vermont combined. Read More

Offshore Wind Lulls Threaten NY Energy Reliability 

The volatility of wind off the Atlantic coast will challenge New York's ability to keep the lights on according to a recent analysis from the New York State Reliability Corporation. Read More

Unlikely Pair Tries to Blow Open Secret Wind Deal 

Offshore wind developers, citing changing market conditions, are demanding what could be billions of dollars in additional subsidies—but refusing to let the public see how much or explain their reasoning. Read More