Andrew Cuomo and Donald Trump have more in common than boyhood homes in Queens. Like Trump, Cuomo could still face impeachment and an impeachment trial despite a promise to resign as Governor later this month.

Federal Impeachment

The Trump impeachment took place days before President Biden’s scheduled inauguration. The House voted to impeach Trump on January 13, just days before Trump left office, and the Senate acquitted him in February after he had left the White House for Mar-a-Lago. Prior to Trump’s acquittal, every Democrat senator and and six Republican senators voted yes on whether the impeachment of a former President is constitutional.

Nays argued the trial was unconstitutional because the federal Constitution limited impeachment proceedings to current officeholders. Section 4 of Article II states, the President “… shall be removed from office on impeachment for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.” The argument for limiting impeachment focused on removal. Congress could not remove Trump from an office he no longer held.

Yeas pointed to Section 3 of Article I, where an impeachment judgment “shall not extend further than to removal from office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust or profit under the United States.” The argument for impeaching Trump after he left office focused on disqualification. It follows from the language that the Senate has two tasks–to determine whether to remove an officeholder and then to decide whether to disqualify that person from future office.

New York Impeachment

The choices in New York are similar. Under the state Constitution, an impeachment conviction “shall not extend further than to removal from office, or removal from office and disqualification to hold and enjoy any public office of honor, trust, or profit under this state.” The Judiciary Law clarifies that the impeachment court has two choices upon conviction–removal or removal and disqualification.

Can they or can’t they?

It’s obvious that a person who resigns or whose elected term has ended cannot be removed from office. Can that person still stand trial to be disqualified from future office? Congress answered yes last winter. But there, the House impeached Trump before he left office. Here, Cuomo resigned before the Assembly voted on impeachment. Can Cuomo evade impeachment and an impeachment trial by resigning?

Congress answered that question at the federal level in 1876. Secretary of War William Belknap resigned minutes before a House committee was meeting to draw up articles of impeachment. Citing English precedent, the House voted to impeach Belknap, even though he had resigned. The Senate voted to hold an impeachment trial despite Belknap’s resignation. Belknap was acquitted when the guilty votes did not meet the two-thirds required, with many senators in the minority voting “not guilty for want of jurisdiction.”

Despite their loss, the house managers felt they had met the purpose of impeachment by conducting the trial. The decision to impeach a former officeholder “will be a constant warning that impeachable offenses, though not discovered for years, may result in impeachment, conviction, and public disgrace.” They added “To settle this principle, so vitally important in securing the rectitude of the class of officers referred to, is worth infinitely more than all the time, labor, and expense of the protracted trial closed by the verdict of yesterday.”

Nearly a century later, President Richard Nixon resigned after the Judiciary Committee delivered articles of impeachment to the House. The House did not vote on the articles. Instead, it passed a resolution 412-3 acknowledging Nixon’s resignation and accepting the committee’s report.

Nixon resigned more than a year after a Senate select committee began investigating Watergate, through over 50 broadcast days of hearings, and days after the release of audiotape transcripts, including the “smoking gun” tying Nixon to the Watergate cover-up. A presidential resignation was unprecedented in the United States. And history shows the public disgrace of the Watergate scandal irreparably harmed Nixon’s ability to hold any public office again. An impeachment trial had nothing more to accomplish.

Cuomo, on the other hand, resigned while the Judiciary Committee’s investigation remains open. The Attorney General’s report on sexual harassment allegations is one of several areas of inquiry for the committee. The committee’s counsel has 500,000 pages of records relating to nursing home deaths alone. It has thousands more regarding Cuomo’s $5 million book deal and priority Covid testing for family and friends. Compared with Nixon, the public investigative record is far from complete.

If the Assembly determines it’s no longer interested in investigating, Lieutenant Governor Hochul will need to make good on her promises of transparency and accountability and order an independent commission to complete the investigations already begun.

Anything less would be, well, criminal.

 

About the Author

Cam Macdonald

Cameron J. “Cam” Macdonald is an Adjunct Fellow with the Empire Center and Executive Director and General Counsel for the Government Justice Center.

Read more by Cam Macdonald

You may also like

The Health Department takes a big step toward COVID transparency

The state Health Department released a flurry of 20 COVID-related data sets this week, taking its biggest step yet toward full transparency about the state's pandemic response. Read More

Remembering the scandal that brought down Health Commissioner Howard Zucker

The resignation of Dr. Howard Zucker as state health commissioner marks the end of a term marred by scandal over his role in managing the coronavirus pandemic. The much-debated compelling nursing homes to admit COVID-positive patients, though it origi Read More

After 10 weeks, all but five of the Empire Center’s 63 requests for pandemic data remain unfulfilled

Over the 10 days that Hochul has been in office, there has been no further progress on the Empire Center's record requests. Read More

New York’s health benefits remain the second-costliest in the U.S.

New York's health benefit costs increased faster than the national average in 2020, leaving it with the second-least affordable coverage in the U.S. The state's average total cost f Read More

Another Hochul To-Do: Timely Financial Reporting

The state will spend a record $212 billion in the current 2022 Fiscal Year, under the budget its elected leaders adopted in April. Read More

The Gov’s pension

There are several (dozens? hundreds?) of unanswered questions as the fallout from Andrew Cuomo's resignation earlier today continues. Among those are questions related to his pension, some of which can be answered, sort of. Read More

The Health Department’s FOIL Responses Signal an Indefinite Wait for Pandemic Data

The quest for comprehensive data on New York's coronavirus pandemic hit a bureaucratic roadblock this week Read More

A Study of COVID-19 in Nursing Homes Raises Doubt About New York’s Minimum Staffing Law

A newly published study of COVID-19 in nursing homes links larger numbers of employees to higher rates of infection and death for residents – raising fresh doubts about New York's recently enacted "safe staffing" law. Read More

Subscribe

Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries: Info@EmpireCenter.org

Press Inquiries: Press@EmpireCenter.org

About

The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!