Google ’s chairman, Eric Schmidt , and Harlem education advocate Geoffrey Canada joined Gov. Andrew Cuomo on Monday in a push for a $2 billion bond intended to help New York schools improve their technology and Internet access.

Mr. Cuomo’s “smart schools commission,” which included Messrs. Schmidt and Canada as well as Constance Evelyn, superintendent of Auburn schools in Cayuga County, released a 56-page report on the need for the funds, a week before the bond act appears on ballots.

Supporters say the money would narrow the divide between the digital haves and have-nots, and help prepare students for high-skilled jobs. But opponents say there hasn’t been a systematic effort to evaluate schools’ needs for new technology, and the state has more urgent priorities for capital spending, such as repairing bridges and highways.

Mr. Schmidt, speaking at Mineola Middle School, said that what disturbed him the most after three public hearings was “the overwhelming and increasing gap” between those who have sufficient broadband access and those who don’t. He recalled teachers who wanted to give their motivated students online access to Advanced Placement courses but couldn’t.

“That’s a tragedy for the state, and a tragedy for the country,’’ he said.

Mr. Canada said that improving schools’ broadband infrastructure alone “won’t level the playing field, but it’s a necessary prerequisite” to doing so.

But E.J. McMahon, president of the Empire Center for Public Policy, a conservative think tank in Albany, said the state already had a generous tech budget for schools. He called the plan “probably the most ill-conceived and wasteful bond act that’s been proposed in New York for decades.”

If passed, the aid could also be used to install security upgrades and build new classrooms for prekindergarten. It would be allocated by a formula, so New York City would receive $783 million, for example, and a small district, such as Auburn, would get $3.5 million. Districts would have to get their visions for using the money approved by a state panel.

New York City Department of Education’s capital plan says that if the bond act is passed, the city would spend $310 million to add pre-K seats, and the rest to create 4,900 other seats to reduce class sizes.

The bond act will be on the Nov. 4 ballot. The Citizens Budget Commission, a watchdog group that follows local and state finances, advises voters to defeat it.

“The state has massive documented infrastructure needs that are unfunded,” Elizabeth Lynam, its director of state studies, said, “and this is not the best use of the remaining debt capacity.”

© 2014 Wall Street Journal

You may also like

No money has been spent on Cuomo’s $2B bond act to boost schools

Voters in 2014 approved a Cuomo-pushed $2 billion bond act designed to help local school districts purchase needed new technology. But to date, not a dime has been spent on the effort. Read More

E.J. McMahon on “The John Gambling Show”

E.J. McMahon, president of the Empire Center, joined John Gambling to discuss Prop 3. Read More

Upstate turnout looms as election wild card

Proposition 3 would allow the state to borrow $2 billion for educational technology. It is supported by Cuomo and the teacher’s union. The Empire Center, a conservative think tank, has called it a “blank check” to the state’s education bureaucracy. Read More

The Brian Lehrer Show: Ballot Proposal #3: Smart Schools?

Dr. Amy Perry-DelCorvo, CEO of NYSCATE (NYS Association for Computers and Technologies in Education), and E.J. McMahon, senior fellow for Tax and Budgetary Studies at the Manhattan Institute and president of the Empire Center for Public Policy, debate the merits of New York’s ballot proposal #3, a bond act to fund technology for schools. Read More

How Bright is the Smart Schools Bond Act?

The debt this $2 billion bond will create is no small amount in the annual budget. E.J. McMahon, president of the Empire Center for Public Policy, puts the total at roughly $130 million per year, but that figure could change drastically depending on how long the note is for. Read More

Voters to decide on proposed changes to state constitution

Proposal Three would authorize issuing up to $2 billion bond. The money would go to improving technology in classrooms and for technology-based school security. The Empire Center argues it would could about $500 million in interest. Read More

Editorial: New York Proposition 3: No on the Smart Schools Bond Act

Who doesn't want the best for New York's students? But the price tag for electronic equipment that will be obsolete long before it's paid off isn't the best use of the taxpayers' money. We would urge voters to vote "no" on the bond act. Read More

Prop 3: $2 billion Smart Schools Bond Act draws support, opposition

Criticism of the $2 billion bond extends to the think tank The Empire Center for Public Policy, which refers to the Smart Schools Bond Act as full of "highly debatable promises." Considering the state's already "enormous" debt burden, the center advises voter's take caution when thinking about voting on the bond. Read More