Dear Mr. Dahl,

We received your communication of January 25, 2022 (attached), informing us that the Legislature would not allow three separate individuals from our organization, with expertise in three separate areas of policy, to present oral testimony on three different budget bills.

Your communication suggests that we might not have realized multiple requests were made. I assure you, we were aware the requests were made, following a pattern of many years where the Legislature did allow multiple people from a single organization, including ours, to present oral testimony. In fact, we often felt like that testimony was appreciated by legislators as they considered their significant responsibility in the budget process.

As you also explained, this policy extends beyond organizations to individuals.

I’m sure you can imagine our shock and dismay at the change of procedure when it comes to allowing citizens to participate in the process of their government spending billions of their tax dollars through the budget.

As I assume you are aware, there are hundreds of programs in the state budget. Giving those who wish to do so a chance to directly present their views and, often, expertise to their representatives in government doesn’t seem like too much to ask.

Your letter claims this change is “due to time constraints,” which seems odd given that testimony has already been limited to only three minutes and the events are happening in a virtual-only setting. If anything, this shortened virtual format would seem to allow for more testimony. Either way, I’m not sure there’s a more important task for a state legislator than understanding the views of their constituents, especially in this kind of direct participation on a topic of this importance, and cost.

We respectfully request that you reverse this abrupt change in protocol. Intentional or not, this is a direct affront to every New Yorker’s ability to participate in our government.


Tim Hoefer

President & CEO

cc: Hon. Kathy Hochul
Hon. Andrea Stewart-Cousins
Hon. Carl Heastie
Assembly Ways & Means Committee

You may also like

Over-Budget and Over-Deadline: The 2023 New York State Budget 

After the official release of the New York state budget, the experts at the Empire Center provided the following insight. Read More

Hammond Warns of Imminent Medicaid “Iceberg” in Legislative Testimony 

New York’s Medicaid program is currently on a crash course for fiscal disaster in the near future, warns Bill Hammond. Read More

State Budget Proposal Doubles Down on Reckless Spending, Empire Center Says

After Governor Hochul’s budget unveiling this afternoon, Empire Center experts offered their reactions to the latest framework. Read More

Empire Center Experts React to the 2023 State of the State 

In response to Governor Hochul’s State of the State address and policy book, Empire Center experts issued the following reactions. Read More

$68 Million in DASNY Pork Projects Range from Recreation to Legislative Drafting

A total of $68 million in grant awards was steered to 276 local projects between November 2021 and March 2022 by the Dormitory Authority of the State of New York Read More

Legislative Spending Unevenly Divided Among Members

Spending by state lawmakers on office personnel and administrative costs varies widely, with some paying out nearly twice as much as others Read More

Testimony: New Yorkers Need the Facts on CLCPA

The Climate Action Council is leaving New Yorkers in the dark when it comes to their far-reaching Climate Act Read More

Spend, Spend, Spend: Empire Center Weighs in on New York State Budget 

After nearly a week’s delay, Governor Kathy Hochul has finally announced a budget deal. Though the legislature has yet to formally agree to most of it, she disclosed numerous specifics of the purported $220 billion deal. Read More