Suffolk County Executive Steve Bellone on Tuesday unveiled a plan he thinks will help local homeowners avoid the new $10,000 federal cap on deductions for state and local taxes.

But one state tax watchdog isn’t sure it’s legal and one key county legislator expressed strong concerns about spending heavy legal fees to fight for it in court.

The Bellone proposal centers on the idea of rebranding property tax payments as charitable contributions. His plan would permit homeowners, in lieu of paying property taxes, to pay an equivalent amount into a charitable fund, then claim those payments as charitable federal tax deductions.

It mirrors a proposal offered by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo — one that the Internal Revenue Service already has said is illegal and won’t be approved. Bellone said he’s submitting legislation to the County Legislature to establish the “Charitable Gift Trust Fund” and stands ready to challenge the IRS in court. He says it would make the first American county to do so.

“We will make clear to the IRS that we are serious about protecting families in Suffolk County, that we will do everything in our power to fight back against legislation that will hurt families and our economy,” Bellone said, according to prepared remarks announcing his initiative. “My message to the IRS is clear: If you try to stop us from protecting our SALT deductions, we will see you in court.”

In 2017, President Donald Trump and a Republican-controlled Congress overhauled the federal tax code. Among the changes, they capped the amount of deduction a taxpayer can take for state and local taxes at $10,000. They also doubled the standard deduction, making it $24,000 for married couples, which analysts said would negate the impact of the SALT limit for many homeowners.

Leaders of high tax states — especially New York, New Jersey, California, Connecticut and Illinois — called the cap a political hit job on primarily Democratic states.

Cuomo, as well as several other governors, proposed a charitable deduction “work around” very similar to Bellone’s. But in August 2018, U.S. Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin said the IRS would prevent “attempts to convert tax payments into charitable contributions.”

Although the IRS ruling hasn’t formally been made final yet and Bellone is promising a legal fight, E.J. McMahon of the Empire Center, an anti-tax think tank, said Suffolk taxpayers should be skeptical of putting money into the proposed charitable fund.

“Any contribution to something like the Suffolk County fund is by no means guaranteed a tax deduction, so the message to taxpayers is don’t count on it,” McMahon said in an email. He called Bellone’s plan “nothing new — basically a Suffolk echo of Cuomo a year ago.”

Further, DuWayne Gregory, a Democrat and presiding officer of the County Legislature, said while he favors an offset of the SALT cap, the issue of the “work around” appears settled and he was leery about “getting involved in spending a lot of money” on a legal battle.

“The IRS said you can’t do it, so I’m surprised. Unless there is some new guidance, I’m not sure we can” implement such a plan, Gregory said. “To me, it’s a settled issue. But we can look at it.”

County Legis. Tom Cilmi, head of the Republican conference, called Bellone’s proposal “another election-year charade.”

“It seems suspect that he’s doing this after the governor tried it and after the IRS said you can’t do it,” Cilmi said.

Bellone said the program would permit homeowners to make unrestricted contributions to the charitable fund and would be able to claim a credit against their property taxes up to 95 percent of the contribution. A business group applauded the county executive’s proposal.

“As a region, we can remain idle and hope the loss of SALT will have little impact on our economy or we can proactively seek to mitigate the crippling economic effects on Long Island,” said Kyle Strober, executive director of the Association for a Better Long Island, a developers’ group.

You may also like

The good, the bad and the ugly in Cuomo’s budget

“We are at the early stages of what shapes up as the biggest state and city fiscal crisis since the Great Depression,” said E.J. McMahon of the Empire Center. “Borrowing and short-term cuts aside, the budget doesn’t chart any clear path out of it.” Read More

Medicaid cuts make the state budget, with some tweaks

Bill Hammond, director of health policy at the conservative-leaning think tank the Empire Center, suggested this is because the proposed cuts are meant to slow the otherwise rapid growth in Medicaid spending, which means an increase is still possible.  Read More

Gov. Cuomo’s Lawsuit on Pres. Trump’s Tax Cuts Dismissed

But according to the Empire Center, a non-profit group based in Albany, the overall impact of the Trump tax cuts actually benefited most state residents. Read More

It’s never simple arithmetic with schools

Earlier this week, the Empire Center did its own report on the plummeting numbers when it comes to students. Overall, the 2019-20 enrollment is at its lowest levels in New York state in the last 30 years. Read More

EDITORIAL: State schools continue spending more for less

As reported by the Empire Center last week, “The number of students enrolled in New York state public schools is the lowest recorded in 30 years.” Since 2000, enrollment in public schools has declined by more than 10 percent statewide with most of it upstate as enrollment in New York City schools has increased 1.3 percent in the last 10 years. Students are not leaving to go to private or parochial schools either because they, too, are showing declines, down about 8 percent in the last decade. Read More

$1 billion semiconductor plant: ‘Flashy mega-project’ or ‘transformational investment’ for New York?

"The state is continuing its strategy of pursuing flashy mega-projects instead of making New York more attractive for all businesses. We're now in the second decade of this approach, and it's still failing to deliver the promised results," Girardin said. "This is the sort of economic development strategy that politicians turn to when they don't want to take on the tougher questions." Read More

Cuomo blames lawmakers for plate fee set by his administration

The new replacement policy, which was tucked into a press release announcing new plate designs, has been criticized as a "revenue enhancer wrapped in a public relations ploy" by E.J. McMahon of the fiscally conservative Empire Center for Public Policy. Read More

New York license plate fee increase draws criticism

"The 'current' $25 fee was for an optional plate choice," said E.J. McMahon, research director at the Empire Center for Public Policy. "The new fee will be mandatory -- the first time ever.  This is a revenue grab under the guise of a PR stunt. Yes, the plates need replacement.  But they don’t cost $25 apiece to manufacture." Read More