Thanks to a last-minute bill language tweak sought by police and firefighter unions, Governor Andrew Cuomo’s watered-down “reform” of New York’s compulsory arbitration law will not apply to a number of unsettled contracts that hadn’t even reached the arbitration stage before the law was extended just before the Legislature adjourned last month. Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) records now indicate that up to two dozen contract disputes may have been carved out of the new law (Ch. 67 of 2013), with the full impact ultimately depending on how many of these employers are considered fiscally distressed enough to otherwise qualify.

Cuomo has claimed that the arbitration change ”will improve the process and help municipalities continue to protect the public’s safety while balancing the interests of their taxpayers.” However, because the governor caved to union demands in the final week of the session, the full measure of those purported (and debatable) benefits won’t immediately flow to taxpayers in some of the state’s most distressed localities — including Suffolk County and the cities of Gloversville and Syracuse.

First enacted in 1974 and regularly extended ever since, the arbitration law has done much to drive up and lock in police and firefighter compensation costs across the state.  However, with the law set to expire June 30, Cuomo entered this year’s legislative session in a commanding position to insist on sweeping changes as his condition for keeping the law alive, assuming he’d agree to any extension.  Cuomo initially took a step in the right direction by proposing 2013-14 budget bill language that would have imposed a 2 percent cap on the total value of arbitration awards — establishing a link between a big local cost item and the new property tax cap. Something similar was done in New Jersey a few years ago.

But after the Legislature predictably balked at the arbitration cap, the governor spent the rest of the session seeking a deal that would do more to placate unions. He ultimately came up with one as part of his financial restructuring bill, which extends arbitration for three more years while requiring arbitrators to give heavier weight to a government employer’s government’s “ability to pay,” including the impact of the tax cap. It also would require arbitration panels to “recognize and take into account … the constraints, obligations and requirements imposed by” the state’s property tax cap.

As explained here last month, there are the two problems with this approach:

  1. There are no rules for systematically quantifying and defining “ability to pay.” Arbitration rulings have long been maddeningly inconsistent on this very point, and will no doubt continue to be.
  2. The tax cap itself can be overridden by a two-thirds vote of local county and municipal governing boards, and thus is not much of a constraint or obligation.

In addition, like the governor’s original proposal, the change is limited to local governments in fiscal trouble, as measured by tax levels or budgetary reserves.

The agreed-upon bill language posted on the governor’s website on the morning of June 18 affected all collectively bargained or arbitrated settlements that expired before April 1, except for disputes in which either party had formally petitioned for PERB arbitration by June 14. But hours after the original bill was released by the governor’s office, that paragraph was expanded with wording that also excludes from the law any dispute in which either party formally filed a declaration of impasse with PERB before June 14. Under the Taylor Law, impasse is the stage before arbitration.

Syracuse city officials quickly confirmed that the carve-out would affect that distressed city’s unresolved contract negotiations with the Syracuse Firefighters Association, which filed an impasse declaration with PERB on May 20.  It turns out that, in addition to Syracuse, PERB records indicate another 23 unions in other counties, cities and towns, as well as two large public authorities, had filed impasse declarations before the deadline. A complete list follows:


As shown above, most of the impasse declarations were filed by unions within a month of the arbitration law’s expiration–and two, involving detective investigators in Suffolk County and deputy sheriffs in Onondaga County, were filed on the last possible day to be exempted from the new laws.

Other unions protected by the carve-out include the PBA in the Village of Rockville Centre, home base of Senate Republican Leader Dean Skelos. Rockville Centre cops, among the best-paid in the state, scored a big win in their last arbitration just a few months ago.

If Rockville Centre is fiscally responsible enough to maintain even a modicum of budgetary reserves, it may not have been affected by the new arbitration language in any case.  The logic of the law is that you can’t catch an added break until, thanks to arbitration, you are actually broke.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Emails show Cuomo’s staff working on his memoir at the peak of New York’s pandemic

Newly available records shed further light on the origins of former Gov. Andrew Cuomo's pandemic memoir, which won him a $5.1 million publishing contract before contributing to his political downfall. The records reveal that his government staff were a Read More

The Full Senate Must Vote on Hochul’s Chief Judge Pick 

Governor Hochul may be getting ready to take the confirmation battle for her Court of Appeals chief judge nominee, Hector LaSalle, to the courts. Read More

Utility board turns into union tool

The idea that the PSC would artificially drive electricity costs higher to benefit a political constituency represents a new low. Read More

Hochul Can Block Legislative Pay Raise

New York legislators yesterday voted to raise their salary to $142,000 in a lame-duck special session. Read More

NY lawmakers want to be nation’s highest-paid

New York’s part-time senators and assemblymembers are poised to give themselves a 29 percent pay increase that would make them, by far, the highest paid state Legislature. Read More

Hochul’s Pandemic Study Is Off to an Underwhelming Start

Although Governor Hochul's long-promised review of New York's COVID response hasn't formally started yet, it has already exposed important information about the state's pandemic preparedness – much of which is unflattering. Read More

New Docs Raise Big Questions About NY’s Megafab Mega-Deal

The Hochul Administration published a pair of documents concerning the Micron Megafab deal that raise more questions than they answer. Read More

City union scandal isn’t NY’s first

One of New York City’s largest public-sector unions has been effectively taken over by its national parent after an audit revealed extensive financial mismanagement. It’s the latest example of misconduct made possible under New York’s public-sector collective bargaining rules that force the government to collect hundreds of millions of dollars annually without any safeguards on how the funds are spent.  Read More

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!