Amanda Fries & Cayla Harris

Amid both a pandemic and an economic crisis, a $177.5 billion state budget, still awaiting approval by the Assembly late Thursday, contained provisions allowing Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo’s administration to readjust the spending plan during the fiscal year.

Despite a looming recession and billions of dollars in anticipated revenue shortfalls related to the coronavirus outbreak, legislators were hoping to come to an agreement on a budget that keeps education aid at last year’s levels and targets Medicaid overspending.

The financial plan assumes state leaders will need to revisit the budget three times this year to adjust spending as needed, depending on the state’s financial health.

The first period ends April 30; the second on June 30; and the third on Dec. 31.

Cuts could be made if tax receipts are less than 99 percent of what had been projected.

“This is not the budget we had hoped to pass at the beginning of session, or even the budget we had envisioned just a month ago,” Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins, D-Yonkers, said as she stood on the floor of a largely vacant Senate chamber on Thursday. “Our state’s financial situation has been thrust into a true economic crisis due to the coronavirus pandemic.”

The budget, a package of nine bills, was tackled over three days with division largely along party lines, as Republicans took issue with packing policy items in the budget and the provisions authorizing Cuomo’s administration to cut spending throughout the year.

Bill language grants the Legislature a 10-day period to pass a resolution responding to any proposed budget changes, though that measure would be nonbinding.

“Who knows what this governor is going to do in the three events he has to reduce funding in a whole bunch of areas?” state Sen. James Tedisco, R-Glenville, said. “I think the Legislature should be ashamed of itself, relinquishing its power.”

The coronavirus pandemic has crushed New York’s financial health, costing the state an estimated $10 billion to $15 billion in revenue.

Those numbers added to an already-difficult budget year, in which officials faced a $6.1 billion budget gap mostly attributable to Medicaid overspending.

But a historic $2.2 trillion federal relief package has largely enabled the state to plan for spending levels similar to that of years past.

The state also plans to take out $8 billion in short-term loans to make up for lost revenue between April and July, as both the federal and state governments moved back tax filing deadlines, delaying payments to New York until the summer.

Fiscal policy experts estimate the borrowing could reach $11 billion.

Although the state is trying to keep total school aid in line with last year’s, with a slight increase of nearly $100 million for total aid to school districts at $27.4 billion, New York saves about $1.2 billion by using federal aid to alleviate costs, said E.J. McMahon, founder and research director of Empire Center for Public Policy, a fiscally conservative think tank based in Albany.

Bob Lowry, deputy director for the New York State Council of School Superintendents, said given the “grim” outlook for the state, the apparent “budget for education exceeds our expectations.”

But the freeze on Foundation Aid will fall hardest on poor districts that rely heavily on state aid.

“The possibility of mid-year reductions in aid is worrisome,” Lowry said. “Every school superintendent we have heard from would favor starting with realistic aid estimates, even if low, rather than face having to make mid-year cuts to school budgets. No one wants to contemplate laying off teachers and reconfiguring classes part way through the school year if state aid comes up short.”

McMahon cautioned the deep hole the state finds itself in amid the pandemic will require painful cuts and stretch on for years. “The whole budget pretends they’re going to spend as much as they did last year, and that whatever they lost in taxes the feds will make up,” he said. “They have to be aware that isn’t going to happen.”

While education aid is looking flat now, New York could be moving forward with cuts and changes to its Medicaid program, through recommendations the state received from the second iteration of the Medicaid Redesign Team.

Among the panel’s suggestions are nearly $400 million in cuts to hospitals, $715 million in reductions to the state’s long-term care programs, and $71 million in reductions through changes to pharmaceutical practices.

When those adjustments will take effect, however, can be changed, state Budget Director Robert Mujica told reporters during a news conference at the Capitol on Thursday.

The legislation allows the governor to delay implementation until up to 90 days after the end of the state’s emergency declaration in response to the novel coronavirus.

The piecemeal strategy to Medicaid changes will ensure New York can access an estimated $6 billion in emergency federal funds — with the caveat that states not alter their Medicaid programs.

The final plan could drop a Cuomo proposal to shift some Medicaid costs to localities.

In turn, the state would withhold $50 million annually of sales tax receipts from counties and $200 million from New York City to hold in a Distressed Providers Assistance Account, said David Friedfel, director of state studies for the Citizens Budget Commission.

Notably, the budget appears to avoid tax increases, even as some progressive Democrats downstate pushed the governor to tax the rich to help the state deal with its projected budget shortfall.

© 2020 Times Union

You may also like

Editorial: Who Says It’s Andrew Cuomo’s Money?

Governor Andrew Cuomo’s riposte to Senator Mitch McConnell over the question of a bailout for New York has got to be one of the all-time classics of Democratic Party thinking. The governor, at one of his briefings, lit into the Senate majority leader over his suggestion that states that have mismanaged their budgets should consider bankruptcy. Mr. Cuomo boasted that New York pays more money to Washington than any other state. “Just give me my money back,” he exclaimed. Read More

Art of the Bailout Means Conditions On New York Aid

A 2019 New York Post editorial, “Pensions New York Taxpayers Can’t Afford,” with data from the Empire Center named a retired lawyer for the city’s department of housing preservation and development who qualified for a $434,263 city pension, and three other city retirees earning pensions of more than $300,000 a year. One New York City police officer was collecting a $474,511 a year pension. Illinois is no better. Read More

Editorial: How pension ‘double dippers’ exploit New York’s taxpayers

The government watchdogs at the Empire Center report that double dippers statewide grew by more than 4 percent from July 2018 to July 2019, with at least 43 state and local public employees under age 65 getting new waivers to collect combined public pensions and government paychecks of $200,000 or more at the same time. Seven “retirees” collected combined totals exceeding $300,000. Read More

Editorial: Bill de Blasio’s NYC budget is still in denial about coronavirus’ economic impact

Empire Center fiscal expert E.J. McMahon is warning that the local economic outlook is “the grimmest on record,” thanks to the pandemic — yet you’d barely know it from the budget Mayor Bill de Blasio unveiled Thursday.  to $97.4 billion this yea Read More

Editorial: New York Legislature should continue session remotely

In the resulting rush to get out of town, Assembly and Senate leaders gave Gov. Andrew Cuomo wide latitude to essentially proceed however he saw fit, leading to a state budge process that E.J. McMahon, research director for the good-government group Empire Center, called as secretive "as I've ever seen in 30 or 40 years." Read More


"So the choice is really, waste the money that way, or do a bill that actually provides funding to New York state. That bill does not even get us a fraction of the amount of money that is needed." Bill Hammond, director of health policy for the Empire Center, a fiscally conservative think tank based in Albany, concurred with Mujica's assessment, noting that these payments would be made quarterly. Read More

Schools avoid state aid cuts in spite of economic plunge

But will New York actually have the money that it’s promising schools? E.J. McMahon, founder and research director of the Empire Center for Public Policy, scoffed at the aid figures distributed on Wednesday, saying he doubted the state could afford them without a federal bailout or long-term borrowing. Read More

New state budget tries to balance numbers, virus uncertainty

“It’s made up on the fly,” said the Empire Center think tank's E.J. McMahon, who has spent decades analyzing state budgets. “It really sounds contrived … They can’t possibly spend what Cuomo proposed unless they get a federal bailout,” he said. “The tactic is that this budget is balanced as long as the federal government gives them $10 billion. What?” Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.