Unlike state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli, who says he’s still thinking it over, one upstate local official has already concluded that Governor Cuomo’s local government pension smoothing proposal would be a bad deal.

Gates Supervisor Mark Assini, a former corporate financial analyst and cost accountant, ran some numbers to see how the option would affect pension expenditures for his Monroe County town, based on projected contribution rates gleaned from a chart presented by state Budget Director Robert Megna.

gates-supervisor-150x150-5758620
Gates Supervisor Mark Assini

The plan, which would require approval from DiNapoli and from the trustees of the state Teachers’ Retirement System, would immediately slash local employer contributions and thus allow for significant under-funding of the pension system in the short term, based on the expectation that Cuomo’s Tier 6 pension changes will ultimately yield more than enough savings to make up the difference later in the 25-year period.

A top Cuomo administration official has contended that “at the end of the 25 years, a local government would not have paid a dollar more than they would have if they stayed in the current system, and the locality would save millions in pension costs over the next five to eight years.”

But Assini’s conclusion, detailed in this spreadsheet, is that Gates (population: 28,400) will pay nearly $4.2 million more in pension contributions over the next 25 years if it opts in to Cuomo’s “level payment” plan. In fact, even after saving about $779,000 in the first five years (through 2018-19), the option would represent a net cost to the town by year eleven (2024-25).

This estimate assumes the pension system realizes a 7.5 percent rate of return on assets throughout the period. Assini also produced an alternative estimate based on the assumption that pension fund returns fall short of current actuarial targets, leading the comptroller to “bump up” costs by a total of 4 percentage points after year 10. In that case, Assini found, the added 25-year cost of the governor’s plan would nearly double, to $8 million.

Cuomo’s proposal would allow local employers opting into the level payment plan to “un-elect” or opt out of the plan at any time. But in that case, says the governor’s bill memo, they would have to make “a reconciliation contribution, as calculated by the Comptroller or (TRS) Board, equal to what such employers would have owed had they not chosen the stable contribution option.”

“The bottom line is, you’ve got to make the system whole, sooner or later,” says Assini.  ”I don’t care where you opt out.”

A caveat is in order here: the actual course of pension payments in Gates will depend on the rate at which current employees are replaced by Tier 6 members hired after the pension changes took effect last April 1. A low attrition rate would mean more savings in the short run, and thus a lower net cost in the long run, than Assini assumes based on the budget director’s chart.  But that raises the question of whether any one-size-fits-all 25-year plan will produce exactly what the pension system needs to collect from each employer to remain “fully funded” by normal actuarial standards during that period.

Gates is in relatively strong financial shape and thus is better situated to resist any pressure to opt into Cuomo’s plan, even if the comptroller approves its implementation.  However, Assini is concerned that even if his town and others like it avoid the pitfalls of smoothing, they will end up shouldering any added long-term pension funding shortfall created as a result of under-payments by cities like Rochester, whose mayor would like to opt in.

Assini estimated the impact on his town’s Employee Retirement System (ERS) members only. Relative to payroll, the excess cost of Police and Fire Retirement System (PFRS) members could be even higher, he said.

Assini is a Republican, but the Cuomo proposal also has been questioned by Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner, a Democrat, and by some non-partisan local officials.

Meanwhile, the Cuomo administration has yet to release the work product of the actuaries that are said to have helped with the proposal. And Cuomo has not identified the “financial experts” who are supposed to have reviewed it.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

A Closer Look at $4 Billion in State Capital Grants to Health Providers

The state has awarded $4.3 billion in health-care capital grants over the past decade, with a disproportionate share flowing to upstate providers, Health Department records show. Th Read More

Hochul’s Pandemic Study Is a $4.3 Million Flop

The newly released study of New York's coronavirus pandemic response falls far short of what Governor Hochul promised – and the state urgently needs – in the aftermath of its worst natural disaster in modern history. Read More

82 Questions Hochul’s Pandemic Report Should Answer

This is the month when New Yorkers are due to finally receive an official report on the state's response to the Covid-19 pandemic, one of the deadliest disasters in state history. T Read More

Budget Deal Slows Medicaid Growth But Plants Seeds for Future Spending

The growth of New York's Medicaid spending is projected to slow but not stop as Governor Hochul and the Legislature effectively split their differences over health care in the newly enacted state budget. Read More

New Jersey’s Pandemic Report Shines Harsh Light on a New York Scandal

A recently published independent review of New Jersey's pandemic response holds lessons for New York on at least two levels. First, it marked the only serious attempt by any state t Read More

Albany Lawmakers Push a $4 Billion Tax on Health Insurance

Legislative leaders are proposing an additional $4 billion tax on health insurance plans in the upcoming state budget – but withholding specifics of how it would work. Read More

Hochul’s ‘Straight Talk’ on Medicaid Isn’t Straight Enough

Arguably the biggest Medicaid news in Governor Hochul's budget presentation was about the current fiscal year, not the next one: The state-run health plan is running substantially over budget. Read More

DeRosa Is Still Hiding the Truth About Cuomo’s Pandemic Response

As the long-time top aide to former Governor Andrew Cuomo, Melissa DeRosa ought to have useful information to share about the state's pandemic response – especially about what went wrong and how the state could be better Read More