mental-hospital-5111324Governor Andrew Cuomo is pushing the broadest and most concerted facility downsizing effort by any New York governor in recent history, as noted here last summer. In addition to prison closures and consolidations, the governor has proposed shutting down nine psychiatric centers for the acutely mentally ill, consolidating a new institutional network of “Regional Centers of Excellence,” and shifting more of the Office of Mental Health (OMH) budget to”community-based” services.

Unsurprisingly, the psychiatric center closures are being contested by the union representing state employees who work at the centers. But they’re not alone. D.J. Jaffe–a knowledgeable mental health advocate not linked to any of Albany’s deeper-pocketed special interest groups–says the governor’s plan could cost more in the long run by “forc[ing] hundreds of seriously mentally ill patients into jails, shelters, prisons, and morgues.”

In City Journal online, Jaffe writes:

Unlike community-based programs, psychiatric hospitals cater to those who need inpatient services, cannot survive safely in the community, or who refuse treatment. New York currently has about 4,000 state psychiatric hospital beds—roughly 27 per 100,000 New Yorkers, down from 600 per 100,000 in 1955. To meet the generally accepted minimum standard of 50 beds for every 100,000 people in a state, New York needs at least 3,000 more psychiatric beds. As a result of the shortage, at least 9,000 mentally ill New Yorkers are currently incarcerated and thousands are homeless. Closing hospitals and losing even more beds will only make the problem worse.

Jaffe is encouraged that Cuomo has nominated Ann Marie Sullivan. a medical doctor who has treated institutionalized psychiatric patients, to be state mental health commissioner. However, he also describes the governor’s Center for Excellence plan as “containing lots of platitudes but few details,” adding:

What’s clear is that many previously hospitalized patients will be declared “recovered” and left to fend for themselves. Others will be transferred to distant facilities, making it hard for their families to visit them. Anyone who gets sick after the hospitals close will simply be locked out.

Law enforcement types apparently agree. In an op-ed article last fall, Michael Biasotti, immediate past president of the state Association of Police Chiefs, pointed to this simple calculus: “When psychiatric beds go down, incarceration goes up.”

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Stigmatizing tax checkoffs

New Yorkers who haven't yet filed their 2014 tax returns are about to be reminded that the Empire State's income tax form is more cluttered than ever -- thanks, in part, to a proliferation of voluntary contribution "check-off" boxes. Since the establishment of the "Return a Gift to Wildlife" fund in 1982, the list of check-offs has expand to 10 causes, including cancer research, veterans remembrance and the development of the 9/11 memorial. As if that wasn't enough, some mental health groups want lawmakers to approve an eleventh checkoff, this one to be known as "Gift for Eliminating the Stigma Relating to Mental Illness." Read More

The drive to improve “Kendra’s Law”

Perhaps the most consequential proposed legislation to fly almost completely under news media radar at the end of session has been a bipartisan bill that would amend and upgrade Kendra’s Law, which allows judges in certain situations to force people with serious mental illness to undergo treatment. Read More

Fight mental illness—close OMH

That's the argument in this provocative City Journal essay by D.J. Jaffe, who says the "skewed priorities" of the state Office of Mental Health are actually preventing the delivery of adequate care to the most seriously mentally ill. Jaffe warns that... Read More