Employee overtime at the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) decreased by more than $100 million last year, according to payroll data posted today on SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website. But while the $1.24 billion in overtime was 8 percent below the 2018 record level of $1.35 billion, it was still 46 percent higher than in 2014.

The Empire Center’s payroll data last year showed MTA overtime had jumped $420 million, or 16 percent, between 2017 and 2018. This disclosure prompted several official investigations that ultimately revealed issues including overtime padding by Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) employees, and led the MTA board to impose new work schedule control measures.

Despite the drop in overtime, the MTA’s total payroll spending last year rose at least 0.8 percent, including a regular pay increase of 0.7 percent alone. Overtime spending, while down from 2018, was still 8 percent higher than in 2017. These figures do not include some MTA Police, for which the agency released only partial data subject to a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) appeal by the Empire Center (see below).

The MTA’s top-paid employee in 2019 was Assistant Police Chief Kathleen M. Finneran, whose $362,077 total included $7,208 in overtime. Number two on the list was Andy Byford, the former MTA Transit head who resigned his $360,018 post earlier this year. The MTA’s top 10 also included two other police officers: Detective-Sgt. Robert Rau, whose $340,780 in total pay included $174,874 in overtime, and Lt. Christopher J. Rockett, whose $339,616 in total pay included $83,213 in overtime. Rau and Rockett each pulled down only slightly less than the $347,707 salary of Chairman-CEO Patrick Foye.

Sixty-five of the 100 highest-paid MTA employees during 2019 worked for the agency’s two commuter railroads. Four of the top five overtime earners worked for LIRR, including three who more than tripled their regular pay with overtime. The top five were:

  • Junior D. Lambert, LIRR car repairman, received $218,877 in overtime in addition to $78,832 in regular pay;
  • Richard R. Bourt, Jr., Metro-North Railroad track supervisor, received $216,123 in addition to $103,607 in regular pay;
  • Martina Eugene, LIRR car repairman, received $214,492 in overtime in addition to $78,935 in regular pay;
  • Robert A. Friscia, LIRR mechanic foreman, received $209,674 in overtime in addition to $106,491 in regular pay; and
  • Patrick N. Damboise, LIRR track foreman, received $201,154 in overtime in addition to $103,372 in regular pay.

All but three MTA subsidiaries included in the data decreased their overtime spending compared to 2018. The three agencies with increased overtime spending were Metro-North Railroad, whose overtime increased by one percent, Bridges and Tunnels, whose overtime increased by nine percent and MTA Bus Company, whose overtime increased by four percent. Average pay increased in all agencies except NYC Transit, as shown in the table below.

The Empire Center has filed an administrative appeal challenging the MTA’s refusal to disclose the names, titles, and pay of an unknown number of MTA police officers in clear violation of the state’s Freedom of Information Law (FOIL).

The MTA earlier this month responded to the Empire Center’s January 2 FOIL request by saying “certain MTA Police Officers” had been removed from the payroll records because it could “endanger the life or safety” of the individuals listed, an exclusion allowed by FOIL only in rare circumstances.

The Empire Center has litigated several cases in recent years to protect the public’s right to know how government agencies spend money. The MTA paid the Empire Center’s legal costs to settle a 2015 lawsuit after the agency repeatedly failed to respond to FOIL requests in a timely manner, as required by law. The Empire Center has also been litigating since 2010 to force the New York City Police Pension Fund to stop concealing the names of its pensioners on grounds similar to those invoked by the MTA to hide the names of its police officers.

The Empire Center, based in Albany, is an independent, not-for-profit, non-partisan think tank dedicated to promoting policies that can make New York a better place to live, work and raise a family.

You may also like

How NY Hid the True Cost of 2019 Climate Law—And What Lawmakers Can Do About It

A new report from the Empire Center reveals hidden and rising costs, questionable assumptions and emerging transparency and practical issues resulting from New York’s 2019 Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act (CLCPA). Read More

2023 Local Government Pay Data Posted on SeeThroughNY

Pay records for more than 168,000 county, city, town, village and other public employees were added today to SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website. In addition to the searchable data, the Empire Center also released the updated edition of What They Make, its annual analysis of the state fiscal year 2023 payrolls for local governments outside New York City. Read More

More NY Pensions Hit $200K

The number of retirees eligible for $200,000+ pensions from the New York State and Local Retirement System (NYSLRS) reached 54 last year, according to new data posted on SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website. Read More

Hochul Tells It Like It Is — Empire Center Responds to FY25 Budget Proposal

In response to Governor Hochul’s FY25 state budget presentation, Empire Center President & CEO Tim Hoefer issued the following reaction: "Governor Hochul is telling it like it is: New York’s  and spending are out of line with na Read More

2022-23 School Pay Records Added to SeeThroughNY

The data, covering all school districts outside NYC, show 75,280 school district employees were paid at least $100,000 last year, compared to 58,631 in 2017-18. Read More

Public Authority Payrolls Updated on SeeThroughNY

Payroll data detailing $6 billion in annual pay for more than 86,000 public employees at 383 agencies including the Thruway Authority, New York City Health + Hospitals and the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) were added today to SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website. Read More

Snips, Strikes and Skaters: NY Borrows To Cover Its Pork Habit

New York state lawmakers and Governor Hochul since January have steered nearly $200 million in borrowed state funds outside the regular budget process to hundreds of pet projects, according to new data posted on SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website. Read More

Port Authority Unloads Big Overtime for Cops

The 10 highest-paid employees of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) last year were police officers who collected more than $370,000 each, according to data posted today on SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website. Read More