The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA)’s payroll jumped $663 million, or 9 percent, last year to its highest-ever level as overtime spending ticked up to a new record and subsidiaries dished out $261 million in retroactive pay, according to data posted today on SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website.
Payrolls for most MTA subsidiaries, now searchable on SeeThroughNY, grew faster than inflation year-over-year:
- MTA Police (+$45M, 37 percent)
- Bridges & Tunnels (+$23M, 21 percent)
- Headquarters (+$79M, 14 percent)
- Long Island Rail Road (+$116M, 14 percent)
- NYC Transit Authority (+$312M, 8 percent)
- MaBSTOA (+$40M, 6 percent)
- Metro-North Railroad (+$37M, 5 percent)
- MTA Bus (+$11M, 3 percent)
Overtime as measured using payroll records totaled $1.37 billion, up 6 percent ($75 million) from 2022 and up 22 percent ($246 million) from 2021.
As reported earlier by Newsday, the MTA’s 2023 overtime spending nominally exceeded the record set in 2018. Overtime in 2023 was equal to 23 percent of the MTA’s total regular pay, compared to 24 percent in 2018.
The MTA’s 2023 overtime champion was Metro-North Railroad supervisor Harry L. Dobson, who collected $254,638 in OT, bringing his total pay to $381,255. A total of 13 MTA employees collected over $200,000 in overtime: 5 at LIRR, 3 (including Dobson) at Metro-North, 3 at MTA Police, one at the Transit Authority and one at Bridges & Tunnels.
The top 50 overtime recipients are listed below:
All told, 724 MTA employees last year got over $100,000 each in overtime.
The per-worker overtime was highest on the Long Island Rail Road, where employees averaged $26,028 in OT, followed by Bridges & Tunnels ($25,839), MTA Police ($21,221) and MTA Bus ($20,525).
Overtime increased between 2022 and 2023 at four MTA subsidiaries:
- Bridges & Tunnels (+$5M, 20 percent)
- Long Island Rail Road (+$19M, 9 percent)
- NYC Transit Authority (+$55M, 7 percent)
- MTA Police (+$1M, 5 percent)
Overtime at Metro-North Railroad was basically unchanged, while Headquarters and MaBSTOA each decreased 3 percent and MTA Bus fell 1 percent.
Comparing 2023’s overtime figures at each subsidiary to the MTA’s previous record year (2018) reveals the following:
- Headquarters (+$11M, 199 percent higher in 2023)
- Bridges & Tunnels (+$5M, 21 percent)
- MTA Bus (+$15M, 20 percent)
- MTA Police (+$4M, 13 percent)
- Metro-North Railroad (+$6M, 4 percent)
- NYC Transit (including MaBSTOA) (-$5M, -1 percent)
- Long Island Rail Road (-$10M, -4 percent)
Four Bridges & Tunnels officers were the MTA’s highest-paid employees of 2023, led by Lieutenant Edwin Lee, who collected $531,659 (including $185,338 in retro pay and $181,065 in overtime). A total of 94 Bridges & Tunnels sergeants and lieutenants collected over $100,000 each in retroactive pay, with one collecting $203,970, after the MTA in 2022 settled a union contract that had been expired for a decade.
The Empire Center’s 2019 payroll analysis sparked a sweeping probe of MTA overtime practices.
The Empire Center, based in Albany, is an independent, not-for-profit, non-partisan think tank dedicated to promoting policies that can make New York a better place to live, work and raise a family.
You may also like
Educators Receiving $200k+ Doubles in Five Years
The number of school district employees receiving a total compensation of more than $200,000 have more than doubled since 2019, according to posted today at , the Empire Center’s transparency website. The public educator pay data are based on Fiscal Ye Read More
Median Teacher Pay Exceeds $100K in a Quarter of NY School Districts as Federal Funding Cuts Loom
A total of 186 out of 685 school districts outside New York City last year had a median classroom teacher pay over $100,000, according to , the Empire Center’s government transparency website, up from 159 five years earlier.
All eight Rockland Coun Read More
New Report Says Businesses Should Ask: What Would Micron Get?
With chip-maker Micron Technology set to pull down the largest taxpayer subsidy in New York state history, a new report from the Empire Center looks at the other types of special treatment the company is receiving, and challenges other New York businesses to ask the question: what would Micron get? Read More
Which Retired NYPD Cops Are Collecting $600K?
Two New York Police Department retirees each collected total retirement benefits of more than $600,000 last year—a new record high for the NYPD, according to data posted on SeeThroughNY, the Empire Center’s government transparency website.
However, unlike the pension systems covering all other public employees in New York State, the New York City Police Pension Fund refuses to identify its top two pensioners, or any of its 53,215 NYPD retirees receiving benefit payments that totaled $3.3 billion last year. Read More
Hammond Warns Against ‘Unsustainable’ Medicaid Spending
Albany, NY — Governor Hochul's budget would allow Medicaid spending to continue spiraling at double-digit rates despite a growing economy and the threat of deep cuts in federal aid, warns Bill Hammond, Empire Center senior fellow for he Read More
Most New Yorkers Aren’t Getting Money’s Worth From Taxes: Poll
New Yorkers by a margin of more than two-to-one said they aren’t getting their money’s worth from taxes they pay in the state, according to recent polling by the Empire Center for Public Policy in Albany. Read More
Empire Center Sues Health Department for Records on CDPAP and Medicaid
The Empire Center filed a pair of lawsuits this week charging the state Health Department with improperly withholding public records in violation of the Freedom of Information Law. Read More
Report Finds Evidence of Growing Over-Enrollment in New York’s Medicaid Program and Essential Plan
A new analysis of New York’s Medicaid program reveals a ballooning disparity between its rising enrollment and the state’s declining poverty rates. As many as 3 million New Yorkers appear to be receiving state-sponsored health coverage from Medicaid or the Essential Plan despite having incomes above the eligibility limits, according to the just-published report from the Empire Center. Read More