Battle lines have been drawn on public pension reform in New York and some of the fiercest public employee union attacks are focusing on Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s proposal to let future government employees choose between a traditional pension and a defined-contribution retirement savings plan.

The outcome of this civil war between a popular Democratic governor and powerful unions in a deep blue state could have national implications.

For anyone who follows the public pension reform saga around the country, the underlying issues in New York will be familiar. The cost of the Empire State’s traditional defined-benefit pension system has been skyrocketing — even while accounting rules obscure the full extent of the financial risks borne by taxpayers who guarantee pension benefits.

Portable defined-contribution plans, such as the 401(k)s that are now the norm in the private sector, have the virtue of creating no long-term liability for taxpayers, while giving greater career flexibility to employees.

Cuomo’s union adversaries and their allies, such as state Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, claim that “replacing defined benefit pensions with 401(k)s will put workers’ retirement security in danger.”

In fact, all 401(k)s are not alike. For that matter, all defined-contributions plans are not 401(k)s — any more than all cars are Chryslers.

But the real model for the governor’s proposal is a defined-contribution option established nearly 50 years ago by the sprawling State University of New York system.

Over 21,000 SUNY employees, including nearly three-quarters of the faculty, have personal accounts managed by private firms over a standard pension.

The same sort of plan is available at the state-funded City University of New York, where defined-contribution is the preference of more than 9,000 employees, including 72 percent of faculty.

Most other states, following New York’s lead, offer similar options to employees of their public university systems.

Unlike a typical 401(k), the SUNY and CUNY plans are focused on annuity contracts, which are designed to provide a lifetime stream of retirement income to those who want and need it.

Annuities protect against the risk that retirees will outlive their savings — a key shortcoming of many 401(k) plans, which are focused primarily on investment returns during the accumulation stage. That’s why the Obama administration has been seeking to encourage use of annuities in such plans.

Even in a tough economy, after a rough period for the stock market, long-serving SUNY and CUNY professors are approaching retirement age with an average of close to a $1 million in their accounts with the Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association — College Retirement Equities Fund, according to data in a new study by the Manhattan Institute’s Empire Center.

University employees in their late 50s, who won’t retire until up to a decade from now, have saved enough to replace 50 to 70 percent of their incomes in retirement, depending on future investment returns.

Investment gains aside, of course, the key to adequate retirement is the amount saved in the first place. In this respect, Cuomo’s proposal is far short of ideal — requiring a minimum employer contribution of just 4 percent with no required contribution from employees.

A better plan would require savings of 12 percent of salary, with employees contributing up to half the total. By adapting the higher-education plan to a broad cross section of government employees, Cuomo could create a model for all states.

The ultimate sticking point in this fight, in New York and across the country, is union opposition to letting workers choose the kind of retirement plan that best suits their needs.

As Cuomo said when he unveiled his reform proposal last month, “Why wouldn’t you want to give the person the option?” Why, indeed?

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Questions on Cuomo’s COVID memoir need answers

As New York marks the third anniversary of the beginning of the coronavirus pandemic, questions about how state leaders handled the crisis keep piling up. The latest disturbing revelation concerns the memoir that Andrew Cuomo published in October 2020. Read More

Want to Save the Planet? Where’s Your Union Card?

New York state officials this week took their most serious step yet to limit the state’s greenhouse-gas emissions. But they also showed they are more serious about taking care of one of the Read More

Nassau should post labor contracts on its website so taxpayers aren’t left in the dark

Nassau County taxpayers face what could be a $109 million bill. When will they be allowed to see the details? Read More

Big Labor’s next target: Grad schools

Christakis remarked on the website that graduate students, now moving to unionize at the school, are not ordinary worker. Read More

And Now the Union Would Like a Word in Private

The onboarding process has become a key battleground for the country’s government unions. Read More

State senators to get a harsh reality check as their own workers unionize

Labor leaders were giddy when a group of state Senate employees last month announced their intent to unionize. Read More

Albany’s latest gift to the teachers union will shackle NYC schools — and their budgets

The Legislature last week put a new spin on the debate over “mayoral control” of New York City’s schools by shackling the Big Apple with a costly class-size mandate. Read More

Hochul’s first budget rewards unions at taxpayers’ expense — and sets the state on the road to insolvency

New Yorkers are aghast that the Buffalo Bills stadium deal, which will fill the pockets of a wealthy NFL team owner with their tax dollars, is in the state budget the Legislature just adopted. Read More