ALBANY—She’s a Manhattan liberal who has pushed legalizing recreational marijuana and expanding abortion rights.

He’s an upstate conservative who voted against same-sex marriage and sought to repeal gun restrictions.

On the state Senate floor, Liz Krueger and John DeFrancisco have become the Capitol’s premiere variety show, their colleagues say, engaging in lengthy debates that have inspired some fellow lawmakers and grated on others.

“When Liz and John are going at it, it helps illuminate the issues for a lot of their members, in addition to being entertaining,” said Sen. Mike Gianaris, a Queens Democrat.

Now, at the tail end of a tumultuous legislative session for both Democrats and Republicans, Ms. Krueger and Mr. DeFrancisco have found common ground: stark opposition to Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s economic policies. And rather than fighting each other, the two have begun teaming up to push back against the Democratic governor.

“Nobody ever said democracy was nice and clean and simple, and we both feel strongly it’s worthy of intellectual debate,” said Ms. Krueger, who represents Manhattan’s East Side. “We both have healthy cynicism about New York state’s economic-development models and questions about how much money is going into them.”

Both are long-serving lawmakers who share a commitment to public-policy discussions. Ms. Krueger, 57 years old, is a former food-bank director elected in 2002, taking a seat that had been in Republican control for more than 30 years. Mr. DeFrancisco, 68, is a Syracuse-area attorney and chairman of the Senate finance committee.

“They are both exceptionally smart and substantive, which I think explains why they obviously respect each other despite their frequent disagreements,” said E.J. McMahon, president of the Empire Center for Public Policy, a conservative think tank. “Both are good listeners who make an effort to understand all sides of an issue.”

In a joint interview, the two senators finished each other’s sentences as they rattled off criticisms of Cuomo-led economic initiatives that they have been bringing up on the Senate floor.

Start-Up NY, a tax-relief program for some new businesses in New York that Mr. Cuomo announced two years ago, “is a bad program,” Mr. DeFrancisco said.

“It’s not going to create jobs,” said Ms. Krueger, “and it’s costing a whole lot of tax dollars.”

A tax credit for filming movies in New York is “too generous,” Mr. DeFrancisco said.

“It’s too generous compared to any other state,” Ms. Krueger added.

And a Cuomo plan to grant millions in state funds to three upstate regions that win a contest for the money “is not fair to the rest,” Mr. DeFrancisco said. “And once again the governor picks the winners.”

They both shook their heads.

“One thing John DeFrancisco and I have in common is we actually like to do our homework, look at the facts and say, ‘This one makes sense, and this one really doesn’t,’ ” Ms. Krueger said.

Richard Azzopardi, a spokesman for Mr. Cuomo, said: “Everything they mentioned passed the Senate with bipartisan support and has helped turn around New York’s economy.”

Even when they agree, Mr. DeFrancisco and Ms. Krueger often talk at some length in public, and their debates this year have stretched into the wee hours. Ms. Krueger, a member of the Senate’s Democratic minority, is usually in the position of quizzing Mr. DeFrancisco, a member of the Republican majority.

During an unpredictable session that saw two high-profile corruption arrests of legislative leaders, and subsequent upheaval for both parties, their animated debates have become welcome comic relief for the state’s political circles.

“John DeFrancisco and Liz Krueger are ‘Budget Buddies’—new buddy cop show this fall,” tweeted upstate television reporter Nick Reisman during one of their sparring matches over the state budget last March.

An aide to one upstate mayor called them “the most intriguing pair to come out of Albany since Alexander Hamilton and Elizabeth Schuyler,” referring to the founding father and his wife.

The two are expected to poke fun at themselves at the annual Legislative Correspondents Association show on Tuesday where the Albany press corps roasts state lawmakers and vice versa. Mr. DeFrancisco will deliver the Republican rebuttal. Asked if Ms. Krueger would play a role in his skit, he said “that’s strictly forbidden to talk about, but I’d keep an eye on it.”

But the pair’s debates have also begun to elicit some groans.

“Liz Krueger is smart, but…she asks question after question,” said Sen. Ruben Diaz Sr., a Bronx Democrat. “Sometimes it’s annoying. People get bored, they walk out.”

Asked about the rapport between the two senators, Greg Ball, a former Republican senator for upstate New York who last year moved to Texas and left government, said in an email: “nightmares.”

Even after nuanced debates, the two senators vote down party lines. He voted in favor of this year’s state budget, and she voted against parts of it. He voted against a medical-marijuana program, and she voted for it.

A friendship has developed between the two, nonetheless. During lengthy budget hearings, Ms. Krueger said, they took alternating food breaks while the other monitored the discussions.

And after the Senate was riven by coups in 2009, Ms. Krueger said, they joked they would form a faction called “the Common Sense Party.” An aide to Mr. DeFrancisco said he doesn’t recall that particular comment.

But their differences on major social issues remain stark. Asked if either had converted the other on policy through their friendship, Ms. Krueger joked: “I’m making him more liberal every day.”

Mr. DeFrancisco said: “We’ve both become more reasonable.”

© 2015 Wall Street Journal


You may also like

Bill Requires Municipalities To Maintain Their Websites

Skoufis’ legislation references a 2014 Empire Center highlighted the poor quality of municipal websites many of which lacked basic information. The report found that less than 20% of local governments received a passing grade on their website’s availability of information and usability including two municipalities that did not have a website. Some of those websites have improved over the past five years, including Jamestown’s, which received an “F” rating in 2014. The updated city website includes all of the information Skoufis’ legislation would mandate. Read More

Albany’s ‘big ugly’ provides political cover, but has some benefits

“This has been one of the worst developments in the political process here in New York in modern history,” said E.J. McMahon of the fiscally conservative Empire Center for Public Policy think tank and a former aide to Gov. George Pataki. “It really is corrosive of accountability and democracy and, implicitly, the constitution prohibits it.” Read More

Panel at LIA meeting knocks state single-payer health care bill

"Ninety-three hospitals would lose more than 10 percent of revenue," said Bill Hammond, director of health policy at the Empire Center for Public Policy, a fiscally conservative  Albany think tank. Read More

‘Pork’ Bill Hangs Over Other Issues in Albany

E.J. McMahon, research director for the Empire Center for Public Policy, a fiscally conservative think tank, questioned the need for these projects. His organization found recent SAM allocations paid for projects he deemed frivolous such as a skate park and a local highway garage. “It’s this huge mutual back-scratching,” he said. Read More

Capitol pressroom

Former Assemblyman Richard Brodsky and EJ McMahon, Founder and Research Director of the Empire Center, shared their insights into the effects of the legislation and the political implications. Read More


Of the $508 million in pork awarded last year, most of it came from the State and Municipal Facilities program, which is widely derided as legislative slush fund, according to an analysis by the fiscally  conservative Empire Center for Public Policy. Read More

Report says move start of state fiscal year, add budget office

Moving the start of the state fiscal year to July 1 and establishing a Legislative Budget Office are among the recommendations of the Empire Center to improve accountability in the budget process. Read More

Lawmakers look to make New York even more litigious

A 2017 study by the Empire Center found liability costs in New York exceed $20 billion a year. If those costs were passed on to every household in the state — which really they are, in a way, because all affected organizations and insurers have to pass their costs on to their clients —- it would work out to be $2,700 annually. Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries:

Press Inquiries:


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!