gfp-a-mailbox-150x150-3159191

The second of two Election Eve check-in-the-mailbox tax credit gimmicks concocted by state officials in Albany is unfolding this week. 

Most New York State homeowners outside New York City have received or are about to receive a payment equivalent to roughly 1.5 percent of their 2014-15 school property taxes—which will typically range from an average of $60 upstate to $130 in downstate suburbs. This is on top of the $350 tax credit sent recently to families that had at least one child under 17 as of 2012. 

Governor Andrew Cuomo misleadingly calls this a “tax freeze,” but it’s really a conditional property tax rebate–and, like the family tax credit, it’s temporary, due to expire after 2016. Essentially, the first year of the rebate–the only one processed outside the annual income tax filing process–is couched as a sort of reward to residents of school districts that have stayed under the tax cap this year, which was almost all of them. In its second and last year, the rebate will be available only in those jurisdictions that have stayed under their caps again and demonstrated progress in saving money by merging or sharing services. The process of determining who qualifies will almost certainly be confusing and contentious.

While the policy is framed as an incentive for localities to spend less, it actually could accomplish the opposite in some cases by giving schools and municipalities an incentive to raise taxes right up to their levy limits even if they don’t really need to—because, after all, officials can argue the state is going to make up the difference. This was also a predictable if unintended consequence of the School Tax Reduction (STAR) program initiated by Governor George Pataki in the late 1990s. Two different academic studies found that as the STAR homestead exemption was being phased in, school tax levies actually increased faster.  This makes sense in light of what might be called the iron law of government: when you subsidize something, it gets bigger.

Cuomo’s property tax rebate/credit is especially illogical when applied to school property taxes. After all, thanks to the governor’s tax cap law, a simple majority of voters in any school district (outside the Big Five cities) can choose to truly, absolutely freeze school tax levies simply by voting against any school budget proposal that would raise taxes.  In effect, the state is now reimbursing school tax hikes that school district voters implicitly have shown their willingness to pay

This convoluted and wasteful plan will cost a total of $1.5 billion over the next three years.  There are any number of ways that money could be more effectively used: on much-needed infrastructure investments, for example. In the alternative, a more imaginative program, linked to Taylor Law changes, might have been crafted to help municipalities and school districts buy their way out of costly employee union contract provisions.  This could lead to permanent, recurring savings in what remains, by far, the largest category of local expenditures. But it would require a commitment to true structural reform and mandate relief–which clearly doesn’t exist in the governor’s office or the Legislature.

Finally, there’s a risk that today’s temporary credit will be tomorrow’s permanent entitlement. Get ready to hear calls from legislators, if not Cuomo himself, to make the tax credit permanent after 2016.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Albany Lawmakers Push a $4 Billion Tax on Health Insurance

Legislative leaders are proposing an additional $4 billion tax on health insurance plans in the upcoming state budget – but withholding specifics of how it would work. Read More

As migrants flow to NY, so does red ink 

The influx of foreign migrants to New York could cost the state $4.5 billion more than expected next year, Governor Hochul today warned.  Read More

The Bill Arrives: NY Faces $9B Budget Gap Next Year 

New York’s outyear budget gaps, the shortfall between planned state expenses and state tax receipts over the next three years, has exploded to more than $36 billion, just-released documents show.  Read More

NY school spending again led US, hitting all-time high in 2020-21

Public elementary and secondary school spending in New York rose to $26,571 per pupil in 2020-21, according to the latest Census Bureau data Read More

A Tale of Two Levies

New York school districts are getting record levels of state aid. But how many are using it to cut taxes? Read More

Albany’s Belated Budget Binge 

State lawmakers have begun passing the bills necessary to implement the state budget for the fiscal year that began April 1. Read More

Courts set a limit on NY’s tax reach

Just in time for tax season, New York State's tax agency just lost a major legal challenge to its policy of pursuing maximum income tax payments from wealthy vacation homeowners—even when they live elsewhere. Read More

DiNapoli aims to curb NY’s borrowing binge

Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli has unveiled a new proposal for constitutionally curbing the state’s seemingly uncontrollable appetite for borrowing. Read More