The battle over public-sector union dues in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Janus v. AFSCME decision heated up on Wednesday as the Cuomo Administration and outside groups offered up differing opinions on the importance of membership cards.

The latest dustup started early in the day when a group known as New Choice NY sent out an email blast to more than 500,000 New York public sector employees inviting them to a website that includes a form letter for people who want to leave their unions.

Hours later, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said he ordered the state Department of Labor to issue guidance on complying with Janus. The guidance said: “Public employee unions are not required to produce dues authorizations cards for members from whom the employer has previously deducted dues.”

That drew fire from Ken Girardin, policy analyst for the fiscally conservative Empire Center.

He pointed to state labor law that says union dues should be deducted “upon presentation of dues deduction authorization cards signed by individual employees.”

In June’s Janus decision, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that public employees who don’t belong to unions no longer need to pay “agency fees” which are akin to dues and are supposed to pay for their unions’ efforts when it comes to collective bargaining and other employment related issues.

It was a long-anticipated decision that was seen as a significant victory for conservatives who dislike public employee unions. The fear among union leadership was that, since non-union members could now stop paying their fees, full members might just leave their unions as well and pocket the dues money.

If enough dues-paying members were to quit, New York’s historically powerful public-sector unions representing employees such as teachers and police as well as state and municipal workers would eventually face financial challenges and consequently lose some of their considerable political clout.

The majority of the approximately 1.2 million public employees in New York belong to unions, although there has always been a small number who pay the agency fees. Those fees are no longer being withheld following the Supreme Court’s decision.

Several public employer groups said they didn’t believe the need to show membership cards for union members would be an issue, since the court decision is aimed specifically at non-member agency fee payers.

“There has not been much discussion of union membership cards by the county employers,” Stephen Acquario, executive director at the State Association of Counties, said in an email.

“The whole Janus decision and what school districts need to do only affects those people who were not full-fledged (union) members,” added Jay Worona, general counsel at the state School Boards Association, whose members employ teachers.

Still, there were inklings that the membership card question could become an issue. The Empire Center in a news release, included a transcript of a recent Saratoga County Board of Supervisors meeting where officials noted that they were the only county statewide so far that was interested in seeing union membership cards from their 625 employees who belonged to the Civil Service Employees Association.

The county payroll department had names of CSEA members but just a handful of their union cards on file.

No matter where the card issue ends up, there seems to be at least some level of curiosity about the situation post-Janus.

Robert Bellafiore, spokesman for New Choice NY,  said the website logged at least 3,000 visits by noon. They had obtained names of public employees and deduced their emails by using the standard conventions for government internet addresses.

He also downplayed the idea that they are pushing people to quit their unions. “We’re not being critical,” he said. “We are just saying that these are your rights.”

You may also like

Editorial: Cuomo’s problematic Medicaid maneuvers

“It’s everything that’s wrong with Albany in one ugly deal,” Bill Hammond, a health policy expert at the fiscally conservative Empire Center, told The Times. Read More

MTA, LIRR union relationship worse than ever; up next is collective bargaining

The MTA’s heightened focus on overtime follows an April financial report from the Empire Center for Public Policy that revealed alarmingly high overtime rates among some MTA employees, including former LIRR chief measurement officer Thomas Caputo, who made $344,147 in overtime on top of his base salary of $117,499. Read More


An April report from the Empire Center for Public Policy highlighted a 16% surge last year in overtime costs at the MTA — where the $418 million payroll cost in 2018 was $82 million more than what the authority expects to take in from the last fare and toll increases. Read More

EDITORIAL: Prevailing wage leads to prevailing waste

Research has found that prevailing wage requirements increase the cost of construction. In New York, a 2017 report released by the Empire Center for Public Policy found that prevailing wage requirements inflated the cost of publicly funded construction projects in the state by 13 to 25 percent. Read More

Man behind Janus case says public unions will have to sell themselves better after Supreme Court ruling

The Illinois state worker behind a landmark U.S. Supreme Court ruling that public workers cannot be forced to pay union dues said Thursday morning that the unions will be forced to do a better job selling themselves. Read More

Unions fight back after Supreme Court defeat

“The unions had said the loss of agency fees would diminish their political power,” the Empire Center’s Ken Girardin explained. “Reducing their power would put them on a level playing field” with government officials while negotiating, perhaps yielding less-lucrative contracts. Read More

Supreme Court blow to mandatory union dues likely to have big impact in New York

The Supreme Court ruling Wednesday striking down requirements that public-sector employees covered by union contracts pay union fees even if they are not union members could have a dramatic impact in New York. Read More

Janus decision: What it means in New York, the nation’s most unionized state

The Supreme Court ruling Wednesday that unions cannot collect fees from non-members could have wide implications across New York, which has the nation’s most heavily unionized public sector. Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries:

Press Inquiries:


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!