The village of Islandia had the highest effective property tax rate in Suffolk County, paying $42.64 per $1,000 of property values during 2014, according to the newest edition of Benchmarking NY, the Empire Center’s annual examination of local property taxes.
“There’s no question that New Yorkers pay some of the highest property taxes in the country, but the burden can vary widely even among neighboring jurisdictions,” said Tim Hoefer, executive director of the Empire Center. “By making it easier to compare taxes in different localities, we hope to encourage local taxpayers and elected officials to search for ways of reducing taxes and spending.”
The lowest effective tax rate in the state was $4.70 per $1,000, levied on properties in Southampton falling within the Sagaponack school district. The taxes on a median-value home there were $2,769, the lowest in Suffolk County.
The property taxes on median-value homes in at least two villages, Old Field in Brookhaven and Huntington Bay in Huntington, exceeded $30,000.
Users can see the components of their local property taxes and compare property taxes in multiple communities using the Empire Center’s Property Tax Calculator, a tool on SeeThroughNY.net, the Center’s transparency website.
Benchmarking NY uses data from the Office of the State Comptroller to calculate effective tax rates–combined county, municipal and school taxes as a percent of market value–for thousands of localities across the state during 2014, excluding only New York City and Nassau County. The complete report, posted here, includes a list of the top and bottom 20 effective tax rates and the top and bottom 20 tax bills on a locality’s median-value home in each of nine regions.
The Empire Center, based in Albany, is an independent, non-profit, non-partisan think tank dedicated to promoting policies to make New York a better place to live, work and do business.
About the Author
You may also like
New York’s Electricity Prices Fifth Highest in the Country
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
ALBANY, N.Y. — Empire Center’s shows New York households paid the fifth‑highest residential electricity prices in the country in June 2026, trailing only Hawaii, California Read More
New Poll Shows New Yorkers Want Cheaper Energy — RGGI’s Price Record Shows They Aren’t Getting It
Editor's note: Roger Caiazza is an adjunct fellow at the Empire Center. He has a long and deep private industry background in environmental regulatory analysis and compliance. His frequently updated personal blog on New York Read More
Opinion Poll – Tort Reform
Executive Summary
New Yorkers are dissatisfied with New York’s litigation environment and broadly favor changes to the state’s liability laws.
Voters overwhelmingly support reforms that align legal outcomes more closely with personal resp Read More
New York’s Health Premiums Stayed at the Top in 2025
New Yorkers and their employers paid the highest health premiums in the lower 48 states in 2025, and their costs moved further above the U.S. average, according to recently released federal data.
Read More
Nine Millionaires among NY’s Public Authorities in 2025
Nine millionaires, all healthcare executives, emerged among the 88,228 New York public authority employees, according to, the Empire Center’s transparency website.
The data includes payroll information from 385 different agen Read More
NY’s Medicaid Fraud Watchdog Shows Declining Performance
Enforcement by the New York's Office of Medicaid Inspector General has dropped in recent years across a range of benchmarks – a sign that the state's anti-fraud efforts have slackened even as its Medicaid spending soared. Read More
Long Island schools: Ahead of a very mediocre pack
Long Island may be New York's strongest case that money matters in education — and also its strongest warning that, past a certain point, more money is not the answer.
Long Island is widely regarded as one of New York's better education regions, exce Read More
K-12 SOS Little Falls pilot
SUMMARY
Little Falls City School District’s student results are mixed compared with the state average. The district is below the state average in Grades 3-8 reading and math, U.S. History and Government Regents, and the four-year graduation ra Read More