Anyone wondering how New York consistently has the nation’s highest public school spending but below-average student outcomes got a succinct explanation from Albany earlier this month.
In response to Gov. Hochul’s plan to spend a record amount on aid to local school districts, state lawmakers countered by calling for about a billion dollars more.
Assembly members and senators took exception with Hochul’s move to trim allocations in spite of decreased enrollment. Instead of cutting anyone’s aid – even in the state’s wealthiest downstate locales – the chamber’s Democratic conferences proposed giving every district, even shrinking ones, a minimum 3% aid increase. Because more is never enough.
New York’s public school system displaced New Jersey’s as the nation’s costliest in 2008-09, a title it’s since held continuously. In the most recent federal ranking, New York spent $26,571 per student — 85% more than the national average ($14,347) and nearly $3,000 more than the next state (Vermont).
Matching the total per-pupil outlay of neighboring Massachusetts ($20,376) would have saved New York taxpayers nearly $15 billion—and still tied New York for fourth-highest spender.
Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Jersey and Vermont bested New York in all four categories of the 2022 National Assessment of Education Progress (NAEP, also known as the Nation’s Report Card).
Even Ohio and Illinois, spending just $14,613 and $18,316, respectively, beat or tied New York’s average scores in all four areas (Grade 4 and 8, math and reading). In the case of grade 4 NAEP subjects, New York came in below the national average in reading and had the nation’s fifth-worst average score for math.
This happened despite New York having the highest paid teachers and one of the lowest student-teacher ratios.
Instead of more state money, as lawmakers (in both parties) now propose, members of the Assembly and Senate need to determine why New York has, for over a decade, had the highest spending without anything close to the best results.
Lawmakers send money because that’s easier than confronting problems with the state education bureaucracy, its standardized test system or teacher tenure rules, just to name a few neglected subjects.
Ultimately, it’s up to the governor to make sure the budget is balanced. Hochul sees the significant gaps between revenues and expenses on New York’s fiscal horizon. Taxpayers need her to curb the unsustainable growth of school spending. And students need their lawmakers to focus instead on why the nation’s highest level of education spending couldn’t give them better results.
About the Author
You may also like
How NY businesses get shafted — as Albany boosts Idaho’s Micron with $5.5B
Every business owner in the state, looking at his or her own challenges, their tax bills, their regulatory burden, should be asking the question: How different would things be if my company was a politically favored project being announced by the governor? What favors would Albany do for me? What would Micron get? Read More
Can New York Survive a Cuomo Comeback?
Andrew Cuomo picked a portentous day to launch his New York City mayoral campaign. Sunday was the fifth anniversary of his announcement, as governor, of the city’s first confirmed case of Covid-19. Read More
Hochul invites havoc as wildcat prison strikes spread
A central provision of New York state law — its prohibition on public-employee strikes — is at risk of breaking into pieces, as Gov. Hochul frantically tries to tape the shards back together. Read More
NY’s own researchers warn of state’s off-the-charts school spending
What was expected to be a mundane state-ordered study into how Albany doles out cash to local school districts turns out to be required reading for New York taxpayers — and state lawmakers. Read More
Hochul’s mad Medicaid spending woos health honchos
Perhaps the most damning commentary on Gov. Hochul’s Medicaid spending plan — which made up roughly half of the $252 billion state budget she released Tuesday — was the silence of the attack dogs.
Last year, the hospital lobby spent millions on TV ads falsely accusing Hochul of “cutting” the state-run health plan, which covers 7 million lower-income New Yorkers.
This year, the ad campaign has gone quiet, a sign she is giving hospitals everything they could want and more. Read More
New York Is a Cautionary Tale on Home Care
Fans of ’s “Medicare at Home” proposal should study up on New York’s bloated home healthcare system, which covers about 850,000 people. Its large scale and rapid growth embody a cent Read More
Hochul bows to health-worker union’s $9B senior-care power play that could bust NY’s budget
Gov. Hochul’s overhaul of the reached a milestone last week when she named a Georgia-based company as the winning bidder to be the program’s statewide “fiscal intermediary” — and to replace that currently handle those duties.
The dre Read More
Another Voice: Albany’s MTA congestion pricing battles have implications for Western New York
Gov. Kathy Hochul has taken blistering criticism for postponing congestion pricing, a long-planned $15 toll on drivers entering lower Manhattan meant to reduce traffic — and collect $15 tolls.
Most of the drama may be playing out in New York City, but pay attention, upstate: you stand to lose — or win — in this fight. Read More