as-new-yorks-future-healthcare-costs-skyrocket-mayor-bloomberg-raids-the-modest-fund-to-pay-them

As New York’s future healthcare costs skyrocket, Mayor Bloomberg raids the modest fund to pay them

A new report out from the state’s Financial Control Board (FCB), which reviews New York City’s finances, shows the updated value of New York’s projected costs over time for providing healthcare to retirees.

This liability has grown by 36 percent in the three years since the city has had to report it, and will near the $100 billion mark in less than a half decade.

In 2006, when new accounting regulations forced New York to disclose how much it has promised in future health benefits to retirees, the figure was $50.5 billion.

Today, it has risen to $68.8 billion.

Four years from now, the number will have grown to $96.4 billion — another 40 percent, and nearly double the first $50.5 billion figure.

Unlike with pension benefits, no government body requires the city to set aside money to fund these liabilities. (And unlike with pension benefits, the state constitution does not guarantee payment to retirees.)

But in 2005 and 2006, flush with record surpluses, Mayor Bloomberg put a total of $2.5 billion into a “retiree health benefits trust,” supposedly to fund this future liability.

The Financial Control Board’s new report notes that the city needs to do more, though, to “address this serious growing liability,” either by reducing benefits through bargaining with unions, or by aggressively increasing its contributions to the trust fund, or both.

Instead, Mayor Bloomberg is drawing down $1.5 billion from this “trust fund.” The money withdrawn will fund current pension contributions, the city says.

However, pension contributions are part of the city’s annual operating budget. They’re just another labor cost. And all operating money is fungible.

So the city is really using a long-term store of savings to cover its immediate budget gap.

This Monday, the New York Times‘s Michael Barbaro reports, the FCB’s three board members from the private sector “scolded the city” for taking money out of the trust fund when it should be adding to it.

“Troubling to us is that many reports on the city’s fiscal condition treat the health benefit trust fund like it is a budget reserve to be used to close deficits,” the members said at the board’s annual meeting, which nevertheless certified that the city’s budget is balanced.

The fiscal propriety of creating anything called a “trust fund” and using it instead as a mechanism through which to paper over operating imbalances in the budget is dubious, at best.

New York would not be able to raid pension funds to help close its operating budget gap, nor would it be able to borrow by issuing bonds for this purpose.

But, in effect, by raiding a long-term fund whose coffers will have to be replenished eventually, New York is borrowing from the future, just as it would if it were floating bonds.

You may also like

Budget Update Paints Less Alarming Picture of Federal Health Cuts

A new fiscal report from the state Budget Division suggests federal funding cuts will hit New York's health-care budget less severely than officials have previously warned. A relea Read More

Parsing the Impact of Mamdani’s Tax Hike Plans

The front-running candidate for New York City mayor, Zohran Mamdani, has said he can finance his costly campaign promises – including free buses and universal child care – by taxing only a sliver of the city's residents Read More

K-12 SOS. Buffalo City School District

K-12 SOS is a pilot project of the Empire Center to inform parents, politicians, and decision-makers about the state of K-12 education in New York State. Determining why certain schools perform better than others is beyond the scope of this research. Read More

DOH Ducks a Simple Question on Covid in Nursing Homes

Five years after the coronavirus pandemic, the state Department of Health is pleading ignorance about one of its most hotly debated policy choices of the crisis – a directive that sent thousands of infected patients into Read More

An Eerie Silence About the State of Education in New York

A by National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) lamented the declining state of U.S. education by highlighting how scores in grade 12 math and reading have hit record lows. While Covid-19 was definitely a factor, others correctly pointed out that Read More

In the Fight Over ACA Tax Credits, the Stakes Are Lowest for New York

As Washington skirmishes over the future of enhanced tax credits under the Affordable Care Act, New York has relatively little to gain or lose. The number of New Yorkers using any A Read More

New York’s Immigrant Health Coverage Becomes a National Flash Point

A little-noticed New York program that provides Medicaid coverage to elderly undocumented immigrants was thrust onto the national stage this week as the White House sparred with congressional Democrats over the federal gove Read More

Why New York’s Health Premiums Keep Going Up

New Yorkers continue to face some of the costliest health premiums in the U.S., and the insurance industry's recently finalized rate applications shed light on why that is. In summa Read More