Governor Cuomo today unveiled proposed “pension reform” legislation that follows exactly the outlines he began leaking to the media a month ago — which is a disappointment, if not exactly a surprise.  Certainly if Cuomo’s pension program ends here, it will undermine the governor’s attempts to portray himself as a “transformational” reformer.

For newly hired employees, at both the state and city level, Cuomo would keep intact the existing defined-benefit pension system while reducing benefits, raising retirement ages and increasing employee contributions.  While it will be labelled “Tier 6,” Cuomo’s plan might more accurately be described as Tier 5-A — a few steps beyond David Paterson’s 2009 pension reform without breaking the defined-benefit (DB) mold.  Cuomo isn’t going anywhere near a defined-contribution (DC) retirement alternative, not even as an option, although he floated a few trial balloons in that direction as recently as a month ago.

Public employee unions will howl bloody murder over this proposal, but don’t be fooled. If history is any guide, assuming yet another new “tier” is ultimately adopted, they will lobby to restore benefits to current levels long before anyone in the new plan reaches retirement age.

Even the parts of the proposal that sound far-reaching do not go as far as they could.  For example, the governor’s bill would eliminate overtime and accumulated vacation pay from “final average salary,” or FAS, used to calculate pension benefits, eliminating an important source of pension enrichment for cops and firefighters.  That’s good as far as it goes.  But there is no mention of excluding from FAS the differential or holiday pay commonly collected by the same workers.

Another positive aspect of the bill is that it would apply to New York City municipal workers as well as all other state and local workers.

However, while Cuomo’s bill promises to reduce the “expected long-term rate” of employer contributions by more than half, it will remain impossible for employers to project their pension costs more than a year  or so in advance.  That’s the nature of the DB system he would preserve.

Under Cuomo’s proposal, New York’s public pension funds would continue to systematically understate the true cost and value of benefits, misrepresent the size of long-term liabilities associated with keeping pension promises, and expose future taxpayers to massive, open-ended financial risks that can result in skyrocketing costs.

In other words, he isn’t fixing the fundamental problem here.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

The State of the State Spending Spree

The State of the State is the prelude to Hochul’s state budget reveal. It’s a budget that represents a generational opportunity. Read More

Since downstate is the epicenter of omicron, why are upstate hospitals feeling the crunch?

A puzzling pattern has emerged from New York's latest wave of the pandemic: Downstate hospitals are dealing with the lion's share of COVID patients, but upstate hospitals are the ones running out of beds. The paradox was Read More

Climate Act Accounting Overstates Benefit to New Yorkers

The Scoping Plan prepared by the Climate Action Council claims benefits of up to $430 billion from the Climate Act. Read More

Putting Governor Hochul’s $10 billion health-care ‘investment’ in context

In her State of the State address this week, Governor Hochul prominently called for a $10 billion "multi-year investment" in the state's health care system, including $4 billion earmarked for wages and bonuses, with a goal Read More

Hochul’s new old “middle class tax cut” agenda

In her first State of the State message today, Governor Kathy Hochul pledged to accelerate scheduled personal income tax cuts for "middle class" New Yorkers, with a fiscal impact she pegged at $1.2 billion. That figure sounds large but doesn't amount t Read More

Lights Out for New York?

New York can have 100 percent zero emissions electricity in 2040. But it can’t have enough of it to keep the lights and the heat on. Read More

Pandemic drove largest New York population loss ever

Thanks mainly to a pandemic-driven boost in its already high outflows to other states, New York has just suffered its largest single-year population loss ever—and the worst, in percentage terms, of any state in the past y Read More

Hochul faces a test on health insurance costs

With judicious use of her veto pen this month, Governor Hochul could draw a line against spiraling health expenses for consumers and taxpayers. Several health insurance-related bill Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries:

Press Inquiries:


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!