The city of Detroit lost its investment-grade credit rating from S&P Tuesday night, slipping to BB after just barely hanging on to a halfway decent rating for the past two decades. New York is not Detroit. But since one of Detroit’s major problems was that it couldn’t politically and psychologically adapt to the long-term changes and failures of its major industry, automobiles, New York can learn a lesson as its major industry possibly goes through a similar long-term local contraction.

Detroit joins New Orleans, Scranton, Littlefield (TX), and East Chicago (IN) in the junk-grade bond category, according to the Free Press.

The downgrade will make it more difficult for Detroit to raise bonds (obviously), because pension funds, insurance companies, and the like often can’t put money in speculative-grade debt. It could also have a ripple effect in the rest of the muni market, as muni mutual funds and other large-scale investors wonder what other cities are on the brink of becoming “fallen angels.”

S&P cut Detroit because, it said, of “the city’s inability to regain structural balance” in its budget. “Additional rating factors include Detroit’s ongoing reliance on the… automobile industry … and a high debt burden that places fixed-cost pressure on operations.”

Plus, truthfully, Detroit isn’t very good at budgeting, seeming not to know how much money it has at any given time.

New York City, thankfully, doesn’t have this particular problem, largely due to reforms that the state made it implement in the last fiscal crisis, in the Seventies.

New York could, however, have one thing dangerously in common with Detroit.

Over three decades, Detroit never could muster the political will or competence to restructure its city budget to deal with a reality in which the Midwest wasn’t the capital of American auto manufacturing. Carmaking changed — and Detroit never did, not even realizing the change until it was too late.

New York, over the next decade or so, may face the same economic challenge Detroit faced starting 30 years ago.

Wall Street, New York’s main private industry, could be changing, not just temporarily, but forever. The financial sector may not return to its size and profitability of the bubble-era mid-2000s.

And neither New York nor London is guaranteed to be a world financial capital, because smaller markets from Asia to Africa to Eastern Europe now possess the capacity to create their own domestic financial markets when the general financial world begins its slow recovery.

Over the past 18 months, New York — while it has operationally competent enough people in government — hasn’t shown the political courage necessary to deal with a challenge of this magnitude.

If it chooses to continue to punt, raising taxes and cutting quality-of-life spending, it will lose the middle class that supports competent leadership.

Then, it really will have a problem from which it’s much more difficult to recover, as Detroit and New Orleans have shown.

This erosion could happen so slowly that we barely notice it until it’s too late. Or it could happen lightning-fast, just as the global manufacturing and services sector have lost business lightning-fast in the past six months as the world economy reversed itself.

Things change — and government shouldn’t be complacent about its ability to deal with the changes after they’ve reached a certain point of no return.

You may also like

In Pandemic Recovery, New York’s Tax Base Is More Fragile Than Ever

New York's exceptionally wealthy state tax base is also exceptionally fragile, due to its heavy dependence on the highly volatile (and portable) investment-driven incomes of Wall Street workers and fund managers. Read More

New York’s Private Jobs Rebound Still Trails Most of U.S.

In the seventh month of the coronavirus pandemic, private-sector employment in New York was still recovering more slowly than in other states from the after-effects of the broad spring shutdowns of normal business and social life, according to federal Bureau of Labor Statistics data. Read More

Mixed September for NY: Job Recovery Sluggish, Tax Receipts Up

Continuing a trend from mid-summer, New York's private jobs recovery slowed a little more in September—but state tax receipts came in a bit stronger than expected, according to two monthly reports released by the state late today. Read More

De Blasio’s (Apparent) Good Move Dissolves Into Phony “Savings”

Late Thursday, as hailed in this space, Mayor de Blasio finally made a decisive move—or at least seemed to make a move—in the direction of actually saving some money on labor costs by getting tough with a powerful (and powerfully self-entitled) municipal union. Read More

‘Clusters’ Drive a Widespread Surge in New York’s Coronavirus Infection Rates

New York's coronavirus infection rates have surged to their highest levels since May, pushing 10 counties – including Brooklyn, Rockland and Orange – above a threshold that the Cuomo administration uses to justify travel restrictions on other states. Read More

Not a Moment Too Soon, Bill de Blasio Is Setting a Good Fiscal Example

After months of flailing, floundering and stalling on desperately needed cuts to New York City's pandemic-ravaged budget, Mayor de Blasio just made a smart and appropriate move to save money—in the process defying one of New York's most powerful government employee unions. Read More

Cahill Charges Are An Indictment Of Cuomo’s Policies

Yesterday’s indictment of the state’s top construction union official on federal corruption charges raises a big question: if private companies are paying bribes to avoid having to work with certain construction unions, why is Governor Cuomo insisting that the state keep doing it? Read More

It’s Official: New York State’s Second Quarter Economic Crash Was the Worst on Record

Further evidence of the massive damage done to New York’s economy by the coronavirus pandemic shutdown has emerged in the latest gross domestic product (GDP) data from the federal Commerce Department's Bureau of Economic Affairs. Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.