The names of former New York City firefighters and the public pensions they are receiving must be released under the state Freedom of Information Law to a group that is building a database of public employee pensioners, a judge ruled.

Acting Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Peter Sweeney rejected the argument by unions representing firefighters and the city that releasing the data to the Empire Center for New York State Policy could subject former officers of the New York Fire Department (FDNY) who were in law enforcement jobs to potential dangers by identifying them by name.

“One would think that if someone who had a grudge against a law enforcement officer, he or she would already know his or her name,” Sweeney wrote in Hagan v. City of New York, 012574/2014.

He also said, as a general rule, public employees have a lower expectation of privacy than private sector employees about their pensions since the benefits are taxpayer funded.

Josh Stillman, an associate at Jones Day in Manhattan, represented the Empire Center. Harry Greenberg, partner at Greenberg Burzichelli Greenberg in Lake Success, represented the firefighters’ unions. Assistant New York City Corporation Counsel Lauren Lively argued for the city and the FDNY.

Security and privacy concerns were raised by both the firefighters’ unions and the city in the FOIL request filed by the Empire Center, an Albany-based think tank that has been making public employee salary and pension information available on its website,

In May 2014, the state Court of Appeals ordered compliance with a similar FOIL request by Empire Center for teachers’ pension information in Empire Center v. New York State Teachers’ Retirement System, 23 NY3d 438 (NYLJ, May 7).

© 2015 New York Law Journal

You may also like


Six-figure pensions are becoming the norm among retirees from New York’s largest downstate suburban police departments, according to data posted at, the Empire Center’s transparency website. Read More

Comptroller warns of financial distress at the MTA, and the MTA goes on a hiring spree

According to Ken Girardin, a labor analyst at the right-leaning Empire Center for Public Policy, every new police officer will cost the MTA roughly $56,000, which means the new personnel would initially cost the MTA roughly $28 million a year. Those costs should rapidly increase over time, as police salaries rapidly increase. Read More


One of the great government watchdogs in New York State is the Empire Center for Public Policy, led by EJ McMahon. The Empire Center recently came out with its annual report on overtime costs and the highest earning public servants in NYS. Read More

Genesee Community College president tops pay list in Finger Lakes

ALBANY — Genesee Community College President Dr. James Sunser was the highest-paid municipal government worker in the Finger Lakes region, according to the latest edition of “What They Make,” the Empire Center’s annual report summarizing total local government pay. Read More

Pensions New York taxpayers can’t afford

Another day, another shocking Empire Center revelation. Announcing the latest update to its SeeThroughNY database of New York public employee pensions, the watchdog flagged the city government retirees now scoring the highest pensions. Read More

These Dutchess City, Town Workers Are Among Highest Paid In Upstate NY

Citing data from the New York State and Local Retirement System based on regular, overtime pay and unused vacation time, Empire Center’s 2018 “ What They Make ” report determined which town, city, and village employees are getting paid the most. Read More

LIRR union chief blames OT on inadequate staffing levels, increased workload

“That’s one heck of an incentive,” said E.J. McMahon, research director for the Empire Center for Public Policy, the organization that publicized the MTA’s alarmingly high overtime rate in an April MTA payroll report. Read More

Fiscal Watchdog Wins Open Records Case

The Empire Center for Public Policy on Monday notched a victory in state court Monday after a judge found the names of retired New York City police officers who receive pensions are public records that must be released. Read More