generic-tax-reform-231x300-8389529The report of Governor Cuomo’s Tax Reform and Fairness Commission is a useful, well researched collection of interesting and provocative ideas — some much better than others. Not a bad place to start a further exchange of ideas leading to a fruitful debate on the topic, assuming such a thing is possible in Albany. (One can always dream.)

For example, the report is very good on the subject of how to “modernize” (i.e., broaden) the sales tax base. But takes a wrong turn in recommending what ought to be done with the money raised by these changes.

The sales tax base-broadeners would include repeal of the tax exemption for purchases under $110. Adopted in the late 1990s as a priority of Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, the clothing exemption was virtually worthless as an economic matter, barely noticeable to individuals and families. Repealing it would raise a cool $800 million for the state alone, the commission says.  It also suggests applying the sales tax to more goods and services now exempted, including Broadway tickets and purchases of digital music online, which would raise a combined $446 million. Another $371 million would come from lifting the $2 per gallon cap on taxable gasoline sales.

These sales tax changes as a package would be defensible if the report also recommended that they be used to reduce the overall sales tax rate, or (in one category) other purposes directly linked to the more heavily taxed item.

For example, the lifting of the gas tax cap, plus another $47 million the report says can be raised by merging the petroleum business tax with the motor fuels tax, could be dedicated to the state’s currently over-leveraged and largely tapped out highway and bridge dedicated trust fund. Or, sticking strictly to revenue neutrality and excluding any redirection to spending programs, the $1.7 billion raised by all the sales tax base broadeners would make it possible to cut the combined state and local rate by a full percentage point, which would mean going to 7 percent from a current 8 percent in most of the state.  That may not sound like much, but over time it would add up for both individuals and businesses alike (especially non-manufacturing firms).  For example, a single percentage point reduction would reduce the average new car price by $312.

Unfortunately, the commission proposes that all the money generated by sales tax changes should be redirected away from the sales tax base in the form of income tax credits to provide “low- and middle-income tax relief” and, worst of all, property tax relief.

In fact, New York already offers exceptionally generous refundable credits to low-income taxpayers, most of whom get a net refund, while middle-income families pay a much lower average tax rate than more affluent filers. The idea of creating some new state-subsidized property tax relief credit, playing into Cuomo’s 2014 agenda, is especially bad one. State subsidies of local property taxes are invariably both inequitable and inefficient. Besides, New York already spends $3.5 billion on STAR, the nation’s largest state subsidized property tax abatement program.  This presumably would be in addition to that.  In a word, wasteful.

The commission also suggests reforming the Estate Tax by raising the taxable estate threshold to $3 million. That’s a good start, but doesn’t go far enough.  On the (very) negative side, the commission suggests this be financed by creating a gift tax, which would exchange one anti-competitive levy for another. New York is one of only 19 states that still impose their own estate taxes; a better idea would be to initiate a phase-out of the whole thing, period.

Finally, and somewhat unexpectedly, the report includes some solid recommendations for reforming real property tax administration (see below).  Some very interesting ideas there, worth further exploration.


About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Emails Confirm That Cuomo’s Staff Launched Its ‘Book’ Project in March 2020

A pair of state-employed writers began researching, outlining and drafting a book about Governor Andrew Cuomo's pandemic response in late March 2020, weeks before New York's harrowing first wave had passed, according to newly disclosed email records. Read More

NY school spending again led US, hitting all-time high in 2020-21

Public elementary and secondary school spending in New York rose to $26,571 per pupil in 2020-21, according to the latest Census Bureau data Read More

A Tale of Two Levies

New York school districts are getting record levels of state aid. But how many are using it to cut taxes? Read More

A Politically Active Medical Group Gains Access to Funds for ‘Distressed’ Providers

A politically connected medical group in the Bronx garnered an unusual benefit in the new state budget – access to money previously reserved for financially troubled safety-net hospitals and nursing homes. Read More

Albany’s Belated Budget Binge 

State lawmakers have begun passing the bills necessary to implement the state budget for the fiscal year that began April 1. Read More

Hospital Lobby’s TV Campaign Spreads Misinformation About Medicaid

As New York's health-care industry agitates for more money from the state budget, two of its most influential lobbying groups are airing TV ads that make alarmist and inaccurate claims about Medicaid. Read More

Hochul’s ‘Pay and Resolve’ Push for Hospitals Triggers Déjà Vu

Two years ago last week, I wrote in the Daily News about how then-Governor Andrew Cuomo was pushing a costly change to insurance law on behalf of a hospital group that had supported his campaign through a fund-rai Read More

The Looming Collapse of a Long-Term Care Insurer Raises Questions for DFS

As the Hochul administration presses for the creation of a "guaranty fund" to bail out failed health insurers, the state is quietly moving to seize a small company that could be the fund's first target. Read More

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!