Federal prosecutors suggested this week that a “culture of fraud” has afflicted the Long Island Rail Road. They were referring to alleged phony disability claims by LIRR employees — but the phrase could just as well describe the chronic lowballing of past cost estimates for the LIRR’s East Side Access connection to Grand Central Terminal.

Even as the U.S. attorney’s office was preparing to indict 10 more LIRR retirees this week, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority was confirming that the cost of East Side Access had risen to $8.2 billion — nearly $1 billion more than the amount budgeted in 2009. The target date for completion has now been pushed back another year, to 2019.

MTA officials cited the difficulty of tunneling beneath more than a dozen intersecting LIRR and Amtrak lines at the Harold Interlocking complex in Queens. But if such complications were unforeseen in the current capital budget, they were hardly unforeseeable. MTA officials say the “risk informed” approach to cost estimates now used by the agency would have confirmed, at least three years ago, an 80 percent likelihood that the East Side Access price-tag would exceed $8 billion.

The MTA is already on the hook for nearly $5 billion in East Side Access construction costs, more than double the figure cited by agency officials when the project was first put on track in the late 1990s. Back then, little mention was made of the Harold Interlocking issue — or of the immense subterranean work the project has required in Manhattan.

East Side Access entails an all-new midtown train terminal, rivaling the space now allocated to LIRR at Penn Station, 15 stories below Grand Central. A projected 80,000 Long Island commuters to the East Side will save an average of 30 to 40 minutes on their daily round trips — although the long escalator ride up to street level may feel like a commute in itself.

The decisive political force behind this grandiose project was probably former U.S. Sen. Alfonse D’Amato, whose clout in MTA matters was strengthened by the 1994 election of his political ally, Gov. George Pataki. At the peak of his power in Washington and Albany, D’Amato pushed East Side Access as a prime regional transit concern, even though other projects arguably deserved higher priority.

Having feasted on the political capital generated by their commitment to one of the biggest public works projects in New York’s recent history, Pataki and D’Amato aren’t around now to pick up the check. And at this point, it’s unclear where the added billion dollars for East Side Access — or the rest of MTA’s next five-year capital plan — will come from.

Advocates of the project have long suggested that the availability of a one-seat train ride to the East Side will boost Long Island real estate values. But what about the negative impact of a further increase in regional MTA taxes?

Because if taxes are not increased (again), the remaining choices are limited to the following:

Demanding bigger subsidies from Albany — which is just another way of passing the buck to downstate residents and businesses, who generate a disproportionate share of state tax revenues, while further hampering the competitiveness of struggling upstate areas.

More borrowing, which will only add to MTA debt — which has already more than doubled, to $32 billion, in the past decade.

Plead for more money from the federal government — which itself is bleeding red ink and still hasn’t forked over a $2 billion loan the MTA needs to balance its current capital plan.

Higher fares for LIRR riders — over the united, knee-jerk opposition of Long Island pols, notwithstanding the fact that riders barely cover half of LIRR operating expenses as it is.

Savings through greater operating efficiencies — which inevitably will require pitched combat between the MTA and politically powerful unions whose expensive and unproductive contracts boost costs.

Joseph Lhota, who became MTA chairman last year, is pledging to get real about capital plans in the future. The era of underestimating big capital projects is over, he says.

Lhota’s approach is refreshing, but MTA chiefs tend to have a short half-life. His boss, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo, should promptly take steps to ensure that a rigorous, risk-adjusted approach to estimating construction costs becomes a permanent part of the planning process for every public agency in New York.

It’s too late to turn back on East Side Access, but it’s never too early to cast a skeptical eye on cost estimates for future megaprojects — starting with the new Tappan Zee Bridge, for which the Cuomo administration is due to unveil a financial plan next month.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Hochul Tells It Like It Is

Presenting her budget this week in Albany, Gov. Kathy Hochul delivered more than just a financial plan. She gave the state a refreshing dose of fiscal honesty. “The truth is,” Hochul said, “we can’t spend like there’s no tomorrow, because tom Read More

Putting Hochul to the test: Will the governor use her budget powers to protect New York’s fiscal future?

“We will not be raising income taxes this year,” Gov. Hochul declared in January at the opening of New York’s 2023 legislative session. Read More

Why does the MTA bleed money?

Rep. Josh Gottheimer ruffled feathers when he called for Congress to investigate the spending practices of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, operating New York’s mass transit. Read More

What Gov. Hochul must do to prevent a coming fiscal crash

The pandemic and its fiscal aftermath have given rise — temporarily — to a state budget trend unique in New York’s history. Read More

Bear market spells big trouble for NY state and city budgets

Wall Street generates an outsized share of New York’s tax revenue, so the recent drop in stock prices should worry both Gov. Kathy Hochul and Mayor Eric Adams. Read More

NY officials covered up more than just nursing-home deaths

Gov. Cuomo’s coverup of nursing-home deaths revealed the stunning lengths to which he and his staff go to keep damning information from the public. But few New Yorkers may realize that such behavior is actually standard operating procedure throughout mu Read More

Calling Tax Cut “Theft,” Cuomo Continues to Push For Federal Bucks With Phony Math

The results of this week’s Georgia Senate runoffs, assuring Democrats will soon control both houses of Congress, as well as the White House, had to come as a huge relief to Gov. Andrew Cuomo. Read More

Students Need Reforms, Not HEROES

Families and businesses are watching their bottom lines and stretching each dollar. But House Democrats are pushing a plan to prevent America’s schools from doing the same thing. Read More