screen-shot-2019-09-24-at-4-34-16-pm-300x193-3042921A little-discussed hazard of creating a state-run single-payer health plan in New York would be its vulnerability to the business cycle.

The single-payer bill being debated in Albany, known as the New York Health Act, would entail an unprecedented tax hike conservatively estimated at $156 billion – roughly three times what the state currently collects in income taxes.

The legislation does not give details, but it calls for imposing two new levies, on payroll income and non-payroll income. Both would exempt the first $25,000 of taxable income and charge progressively higher rates on higher brackets. The sponsors have also asserted that these taxes would be structured so that the vast majority of New Yorkers would pay less than they currently do for health coverage.

Assuming such a tax plan was feasible, it would depend heavily on collections from high-income New Yorkers, a source of revenue that’s especially prone to booms and busts. A recession – or a downturn in the stock market – could easily open a budget hole not just in the billions of dollars, but in the tens of billions of dollars.

Lawmakers would be faced with a choice of cutting that amount from health-care spending, jacking up taxes even further, diverting funds from other programs such as school aid, or a combination of all three.

In a 2017 paper in the Yale Law Journal, Michigan Law School Professor Nicholas Bagley warned that a similar “countercyclical trap” faces any state contemplating a big expansion of health coverage:

The federal government can deficit-spend to manage these countercyclical fluctuations. The states, however, cannot. With the exception of Vermont, the states are legally obliged to balance their budgets every year. And states are understandably reluctant to adopt large obligations that will require savage spending cuts or hefty tax increases when times get tough. Cuts and taxes are not only unpopular, but they would also depress the economy further, exacerbating the recession. Broad coverage expansions thus commit states to an economic policy that could inflict serious damage on their residents.

This dilemma would be heightened by New York Health Act’s progressive tax structure. This is because many of the state’s wealthier residents derive their income from Wall Street, where fortunates fluctuate with the stock market.

As seen in the chart below, the aggregate income of New Yorkers making $1 million or more per year – about 1 percent of all filers in 2016 – is far more volatile than that of the bottom 99 percent. From 2007 to 2009, the Great Recession reduced incomes at the top by almost half, while the rest of the state sustained a relatively modest 3 percent dip.

agi-92-16-1836480
Source: NYS Department of Taxation and Finance (click to enlarge)

 

The progressive taxes necessary to finance single-payer would inherently magnify the volatility, as illustrated in the chart below. This hypothetical scenario uses projected payroll tax rates drawn from the RAND Corp.’s fiscal analysis of the New York Health Act: 0 percent for incomes below $30,000 a year, 12.9 percent for incomes between $30,000 and $150,000, and 25.6 percent for incomes over $150,000. (Two caveats: For simplicity’s sake, these brackets are slightly different than the ones RAND used and marginal rates are applied to total income.)

revenue-roller-coaster-6370058
Source: Empire Center calculations (click to enlarge)

 

As can be seen, revenue from middle-income New Yorkers (shown in blue) stays relatively steady through booms and busts, while revenue from the higher-income group (in red) moves dramatically up and down. The net result, under this hypothetical scenario, is a drop in single-payer revenue during the Great Recession of 22 percent or $26 billion – which, at the time, was more than the total amount Albany was spending on school aid.

How would the state’s health-care system sustain losses of that magnitude? Do the sponsors of the New York Health Act have a plan for avoiding this kind of crisis? These are questions worth asking before the bill next comes up for a vote.

 

About the Author

Bill Hammond

As the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy, Bill Hammond tracks fast-moving developments in New York’s massive health care industry, with a focus on how decisions made in Albany and Washington affect the well-being of patients, providers, taxpayers and the state’s economy.

Read more by Bill Hammond

You may also like

Even With Federal Cuts, New York’s Health Funding Would Remain High

New York's health-care industry stands to lose billions of dollars in federal funding under the major budget bill being debated in Washington – a rare and jarring turn of events for a sector accustomed to steadily increas Read More

As Albany’s Session Ends, Watch for Rising Health Costs

Every session of the state Legislature brings a fresh crop of proposals that would drive up health-care costs, and 2025 is no exception. Here is a sampling of pending bills that, if Read More

House Budget Would Burst New York’s Essential Plan Bubble

The extraordinary cash bonanza associated with New York's Essential Plan – which has generated billions more than state officials were able to spend – would come to a crashing end under the budget bill advancing in Cong Read More

The House GOP’s Shrinking Budget Plan Could Still Cost New York Billions

The likely impact of federal health-care cutbacks has diminished in recent days as House Republican leaders backed away from some of their bigger-ticket proposals, reducing the estimated savings to $625 billion from previous figures of $715 billion and $8 Read More

How Medicaid ‘Expansion’ Changes Could Affect New York

As House Republicans consider cutbacks to federal Medicaid funding, their focus has turned to the so-called expansion population. Although the details of remain undetermined, the s Read More

New York’s Home Health Workforce Jumps by Another 10 Percent

New York's home health employment is continuing to soar, growing by 57,000 jobs or 10 percent from 2023 to 2024, according to newly released data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Read More

Immigrant Enrollment in ‘Emergency Medicaid’ Surges to 480,000

One of the biggest drivers of New York's Medicaid enrollment growth over the past decade has been "emergency Medicaid" for undocumented immigrants, newly released state records show. Read More

Upstate Insurance Customers Pay the Price for Medicare’s Hospital Rate Hike

A billion-dollar Medicare windfall for upstate hospitals has turned into a crisis for upstate health insurers that's threatening to disrupt coverage for millions of New Yorkers. The Read More