New York’s state comptroller reportedly is going to reduce the state pension fund’s discount rate from 8 percent to between 7.5 percent and 7.75 percent, Bloomberg News just reported.  The lower the discount rate, the higher the required tax-funded employer contribution.  So the public pension bill for New York taxpayers is about to grow higher. even higher than already expected given the fund’s performance over the past few years.** [See postscript for caveat, however!]

The comptroller’s move comes as no surprise, given the recent performance of the pension fund’s assets.  The problem is that even a 7.5 percent rate — the lowest used by the fund since 1985 — will significantly understate the true size of the pension fund’s liabilities.

The discount rate applied to future obligations is a crucial determinant of any pension system’s necessary funding levels: the lower the rate, the larger the contributions required to maintain “fully funded” status. Private pension plans must discount their liabilities based on a market rate—typically, a corporate or U.S. government bond rate—which is often much lower than the plans’ projected returns.

Public funds, however, are allowed by government accounting standards to discount their long-term liabilities based on the targeted annual rate of return on their assets—which, for most public funds, is still pegged at an optimistic 8 percent or higher. In other words, the risk premium in the investment target is compounded in the liability estimate.

The typical public pension manager doesn’t just hope to earn 8 percent a year. For all intents and purposes, he or she assures trustees, beneficiaries, and taxpayers that the fund is certain to earn an average, long-run return of 8 percent.  In New York’s case, it appears this target is about to be lowered every so slightly.

But ask yourself: do you know anyone in the world of private investing (anyone not named Madoff, that is), who is willing to guarantee you a 7.5 percent rate of return?  How about 7 percent?  Or even, for that matter, 6 percent?  No junk bonds allowed.  Remember: public pensions are guaranteed by the state Constitution.  The money has got to be there.

While most public pension managers continue to resist the idea, a growing number of independent actuaries and financial economists agree that the net present value of risk-free public pension promises should be calculated on the basis of low-risk interest rates such as the rate on a thirty-year U.S. Treasury bond, most recently dropped below 4 percent.  This is not an argument for actually investing pension funds in T-bills, mind you; it is simply a way to recognize how much it actually costs to guarantee generous such generous pension benefits.

At 8 percent, the state pension fund discount rate is an economic fallacy.   At 7.5 percent, it will still be an economic fallacy.

** PS — For the state government, and for local governments that opt into a pension “amortization” (i.e., borrowing) plan initially proposed by Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, a change in the discount rate won’t necessarily affect annual pension fund contributions.  Under a gimmick approved as part of the 2010-11 state budget, the annual increase in contributions will now be  capped at a percentage point a year and required payments over that amount in any given year can be spread over a 10-year period.  For participating  employers, a higher discount rate effectively will translate into more borrowing from the pension fund, pushing an even larger (but still underestimated) liability onto the backs of future taxpayers.**

PPS — New York City has separate public pension plans unaffected by the state comptroller’s action.  The city’s pension actuary recently began a customary five-year review of assumptions,  which could easily lead to a similar change, however.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Remembering the scandal that brought down Health Commissioner Howard Zucker

The resignation of Dr. Howard Zucker as state health commissioner marks the end of a term marred by scandal over his role in managing the coronavirus pandemic. The much-debated compelling nursing homes to admit COVID-positive patients, though it origi Read More

As leaves turn, NY’s post-pandemic recovery still has very far to go

Entering the second autumn since the COVID-19 outbreak of March 2020, the pace of New York State's pandemic economic recovery has been abysmal by almost any standard. New York was the national epicenter of the pandemic, and Governor Cuomo's "" business Read More

More NY job gains in August—but employment needs to rise a lot further

New York's jobs report for August looked relatively strong—but only by comparison, that is, with . On a seasonally adjusted basis, New York gained 28,000 private-sector jobs last month—a growth rate of 0.4 percent, according to . This was double th Read More

Projected PIT Haul Brightens State Budget Office’s Fiscal Forecast 

Stronger than expected tax payments this spring led the Governor’s Division of the Budget (DOB) to increase its personal income tax (PIT) revenue projections for the next four years by $8.5 billion above its April pr Read More

After 10 weeks, all but five of the Empire Center’s 63 requests for pandemic data remain unfulfilled

Over the 10 days that Hochul has been in office, there has been no further progress on the Empire Center's record requests. Read More

New York’s health benefits remain the second-costliest in the U.S.

New York's health benefit costs increased faster than the national average in 2020, leaving it with the second-least affordable coverage in the U.S. The state's average total cost f Read More

Cuomo’s “FOIL at a Glance”

The document, titled “Foil at a Glance,” lays out the Cuomo administration’s procedures for handling FOIL requests Read More

Manhattan Office Suites Emptier Than Other Major Metros

Fewer than one in four New York City office workers are back in the office, according to a pair of datasets issued this week.    Read More

Subscribe

Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries: Info@EmpireCenter.org

Press Inquiries: Press@EmpireCenter.org

About

The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!