Albany, NY — New York’s Medicaid program spends roughly $12 billion per year on in-home “personal care” for the elderly and disabled — nearly as much as the other 49 states combined — according to a new report from the Empire Center.

In fact, during the decade ending in 2019 New York accounted for 85 percent of the nationwide increase in personal care spending. Per-capita spending is now eight times higher in New York than the national average.

“Personal care” consists of non-medical services provided to the elderly and disabled in their homes, and takes a large — and growing — share of the state’s Medicaid budget. According to the new report, “Long Term Crisis: The Case for Reforming Medicaid ‘Personal Care’ in New York,” New York’s huge and expensive version of the program shows increasing signs of dysfunction and waste.

The report identifies signs of trouble in New Yorks home care program, including high spending, rapid growth, a continued reliance on nursing homes over personal care and an unusually large workforce of home health aides. Despite complaints that the industry is facing a shortage of available workers, employment in the home care industry has nearly doubled in 10 years, a signal of the program’s rapid and unsustainable expansion.

“The overarching goal should be to downsize the personal care program to a scale more proportionate to the state’s demonstrated need. This would not only control costs, but also ease the demand for workers and thereby alleviate labor shortages,” said Bill Hammond, senior fellow for health policy at the Empire Center and author of the paper. “Better, more efficient management of New York’s personal care program has the potential not only to save money, but also to reduce dependence on nursing homes and improve working conditions for care aides.”

The paper includes several recommendations to rein in the program, starting with an independent review of why New York’s program is so much more expensive than every other state.

The full paper can be read here.

The Empire Center, based in Albany, is an independent, not-for-profit, non-partisan think tank dedicated to promoting policies that can make New York a better place to live, work and raise a family.

You may also like

Hammond Warns of Imminent Medicaid “Iceberg” in Legislative Testimony 

New York’s Medicaid program is currently on a crash course for fiscal disaster in the near future, warns Bill Hammond. Read More

State Budget Proposal Doubles Down on Reckless Spending, Empire Center Says

After Governor Hochul’s budget unveiling this afternoon, Empire Center experts offered their reactions to the latest framework. Read More

Budget Testimony: Dangerous Misplaced Priorities on Health Care

In his spoken testimony, Hammond had intended to highlight key shortcomings of the governor's budget, including its lack of a plan to investigate the state's pandemic response Read More

New York Spends More than All Other States on Education and Medicaid

New York’s spending on education and Medicaid will leave a hole in the budget after federal COVID relief money runs out Read More

NYS Reduced Funding for Public Health in Decade Before Pandemic, Expert Says

Sharp reductions in state funding for core public health functions over the past decade may have weakened New York’s defenses against the coronavirus pandemic, according to testimony delivered today by Bill Hammond, the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy. Read More

Report: Cuomo’s Medicaid Reforms Are Breaking Down

The budget crisis in New York’s Medicaid program stems from the failure of a key cost-control measure adopted during Governor Cuomo’s first term, according to a new report from the Empire Center for Public Policy. Read More

Options for eliminating local funding for Medicaid analyzed in new report

The feasibility of a full state takeover of the remaining local share of Medicaid costs in New York is explored in a new report released today by the Empire Center for Public Policy. Read More

Medicaid Drug Spending Surge Driven Mostly by Enrollment, Not Prices

From 2014 to 2016, New York’s Medicaid program saw a surge in drug spending that Governor Andrew Cuomo blamed on “abusive” behavior by drug manufacturers. A new Empire Center issue brief shows that, after accounting for rebates, the surge was smaller than Cuomo described, and that it was mostly driven by enrollment growth. Overall, the report finds that price increases accounted for about one-fifth of the spending surge, while enrollment accounted for four-fifths. Read More