This Election Day, Nov. 4, New Yorkers will be asked to approve Proposal 3, which would allow the state to issue $2 billion in bonds to finance the purchase by school districts of devices such as iPads and other computers; expand high-speed and wireless Internet capacity; install “high-tech security features”; and build new classrooms for pre-kindergarten programs. New York should think hard before supporting this costly and costly and wasteful proposal, which will force schools to spend more on items they don’t even consider priorities.
NEWS AND INFORMATION ON PROPOSAL 3
3+3 Reasons for Saying “No” to Proposal 3
Empire Center Online Issue Briefing
Editorial: State Propositions: Redistricting effort better than nothing; school borrowing doesn’t fill a vital need
The Buffalo News
“There are high-priority needs in New York State, not the least of which is repairing roads and bridges, that may be worth borrowing for. Sinking the state even deeper into debt to fund like-to-have items is a mistake.”
Editorial: State’s school tech initiative much too vague
Poughkeepsie Journal
“Indeed, Proposition 3 is incredibly vague, and the state has not done its due diligence.”
CBC: Vote “no” on the Smart Schools Bond Act
Citizens Budget Commission
Spending $2 billion for “smart” schools is not an effective use of borrowed funds, especially when weighed against high-priority investment needs in key infrastructure. The borrowing capacity remaining under the debt cap should be reserved for these high-priority investments, not used to fund yet unjustified one-time technology purchases.
New York NOW on Proposal 3
WMHT
Empire Center President E.J. McMahon sat down with Karen DeWitt to discuss the problems with Proposal 3. (Note: the interview begins at the 15:50 mark).
School Tech Bonds Helping Scarsdale Lost on Yonkers: Muni Credit
Bloomberg
Governor Andrew Cuomo wants to borrow $2 billion for classroom technology in what would be New York’s biggest school-bond issue since 1997. Yet education groups say they didn’t ask for it, and some districts say they’d rather add teachers or universal pre-kindergarten.
School officials divided on bond
NY Torch
Chancellor Tisch’s comments in a radio interview today confirmed what’s been obvious since Gov. Cuomo first rolled out the bond proposal in his January State of the State message: school officials aren’t exactly thrilled with the idea.
New York’s School Bond Boondoggle
By E.J. McMahon – New York Post
On Election Day, New York voters will be asked to let the state borrow up to $2 billion to help public schools buy computer hardware they don’t urgently need and create space for pre-kindergarten programs that most districts outside New York City can’t afford.
CBC Policy Brief on Proposal 3
Citizens Budget Commission
The nonpartisan Citizens Budget Commission “urges New Yorkers to vote ‘No’ for three reasons: the State is approaching its debt cap; capital investment in technology devices is unlikely to yield lasting benefits; and no needs assessment has been done to weigh investment in school technology against other pressing unfunded infrastructure investments.”
Tisch, school groups lukewarm to Cuomo bond proposal
Capital Pro
Board of Regents chancellor Merryl Tisch didn’t give a direct answer when asked whether voters next month should approve a $2 billion bond act to boost technology in schools.
Marlin: Don’t be fooled by Cuomo’s Smart Schools
By George Marlin – Long Island Business News
Why has there been so little talk about this bond referendum? Because supporters are afraid if voters focus on it, a majority will realize it’s a $2 billion dollar boondoggle and vote it down.
Google guy to weigh in on tech funds?
NY Torch
Eric Schmidt, executive chairman of Google, has been named by Governor Cuomo to a commission “charged with advising the State on how to best invest the Governor’s proposed $2 billion Smart Schools Bond Act in order to enhance teaching and learning through technology.”
Follow Proposal 3 news (#P3NY) on Twitter.
About the Author
You may also like
Long Island schools: Ahead of a very mediocre pack
Long Island may be New York's strongest case that money matters in education — and also its strongest warning that, past a certain point, more money is not the answer.
Long Island is widely regarded as one of New York's better education regions, exce Read More
K-12 SOS Little Falls pilot
SUMMARY
Little Falls City School District’s student results are mixed compared with the state average. The district is below the state average in Grades 3-8 reading and math, U.S. History and Government Regents, and the four-year graduation ra Read More
Opinion Poll – Education
Executive Summary
New Yorkers want better educational outcomes, more flexibility for families, and meaningful academic standards, according to new Empire Center poll results.
Voters overwhelmingly believe New York should improve student perfo Read More
Empire Center Poll: Just 4 Percent Approve of New York’s Education System
ALBANY, N.Y. — New Yorkers gave the state’s education system a sweeping vote of no confidence: 47 percent said the state should improve student performance, 41 percent said it should improve performance while spending less, and only 4 Read More
New York Schools will Spend More and Deliver Less – Again
As voters across New York head to the polls to decide their local school budgets, the big question – why New York schools deliver poor results despite spending the most in the nation – is barely on anyone’s mind.
New York’s fourth-grade and eig Read More
Giving Families an Escape Hatch from NYC Public Schools
Zohran Mamdani's stunning election as mayor of New York City marks a watershed moment for the Empire State. As a self-described democratic socialist and member of the Democratic Socialists of America, Mamdani rode a wave of pr Read More
New York’s Education Shows Improvement, but Questions Remain
In the effort to improve transparency and accountability of New York’s education system, the Empire Center has sys Read More
How New York State Compares to Other States in Education (2022-23)
K-12 SOS is a pilot project of the Empire Center to inform parents, politicians, and decision-makers about the state of K-12 education in New York State. Determining why certain schools perform better than others is beyond the scope of this research. Read More
New York’s School Bond Boondoggle
This Election Day, Nov. 4, New Yorkers will be asked to approve Proposal 3, which would allow the state to issue $2 billion in bonds to finance the purchase by school districts of devices such as iPads and other computers; expand high-speed and wireless Internet capacity; install “high-tech security features”; and build new classrooms for pre-kindergarten programs. New York should think hard before supporting this costly and costly and wasteful proposal, which will force schools to spend more on items they don’t even consider priorities.
NEWS AND INFORMATION ON PROPOSAL 3
3+3 Reasons for Saying “No” to Proposal 3
Empire Center Online Issue Briefing
Editorial: State Propositions: Redistricting effort better than nothing; school borrowing doesn’t fill a vital need
The Buffalo News
“There are high-priority needs in New York State, not the least of which is repairing roads and bridges, that may be worth borrowing for. Sinking the state even deeper into debt to fund like-to-have items is a mistake.”
Editorial: State’s school tech initiative much too vague
Poughkeepsie Journal
“Indeed, Proposition 3 is incredibly vague, and the state has not done its due diligence.”
CBC: Vote “no” on the Smart Schools Bond Act
Citizens Budget Commission
Spending $2 billion for “smart” schools is not an effective use of borrowed funds, especially when weighed against high-priority investment needs in key infrastructure. The borrowing capacity remaining under the debt cap should be reserved for these high-priority investments, not used to fund yet unjustified one-time technology purchases.
New York NOW on Proposal 3
WMHT
Empire Center President E.J. McMahon sat down with Karen DeWitt to discuss the problems with Proposal 3. (Note: the interview begins at the 15:50 mark).
School Tech Bonds Helping Scarsdale Lost on Yonkers: Muni Credit
Bloomberg
Governor Andrew Cuomo wants to borrow $2 billion for classroom technology in what would be New York’s biggest school-bond issue since 1997. Yet education groups say they didn’t ask for it, and some districts say they’d rather add teachers or universal pre-kindergarten.
School officials divided on bond
NY Torch
Chancellor Tisch’s comments in a radio interview today confirmed what’s been obvious since Gov. Cuomo first rolled out the bond proposal in his January State of the State message: school officials aren’t exactly thrilled with the idea.
New York’s School Bond Boondoggle
By E.J. McMahon – New York Post
On Election Day, New York voters will be asked to let the state borrow up to $2 billion to help public schools buy computer hardware they don’t urgently need and create space for pre-kindergarten programs that most districts outside New York City can’t afford.
CBC Policy Brief on Proposal 3
Citizens Budget Commission
The nonpartisan Citizens Budget Commission “urges New Yorkers to vote ‘No’ for three reasons: the State is approaching its debt cap; capital investment in technology devices is unlikely to yield lasting benefits; and no needs assessment has been done to weigh investment in school technology against other pressing unfunded infrastructure investments.”
Tisch, school groups lukewarm to Cuomo bond proposal
Capital Pro
Board of Regents chancellor Merryl Tisch didn’t give a direct answer when asked whether voters next month should approve a $2 billion bond act to boost technology in schools.
Marlin: Don’t be fooled by Cuomo’s Smart Schools
By George Marlin – Long Island Business News
Why has there been so little talk about this bond referendum? Because supporters are afraid if voters focus on it, a majority will realize it’s a $2 billion dollar boondoggle and vote it down.
Google guy to weigh in on tech funds?
NY Torch
Eric Schmidt, executive chairman of Google, has been named by Governor Cuomo to a commission “charged with advising the State on how to best invest the Governor’s proposed $2 billion Smart Schools Bond Act in order to enhance teaching and learning through technology.”
Follow Proposal 3 news (#P3NY) on Twitter.
About the Author
You may also like
Opinion Poll – Tort Reform
Executive Summary
New Yorkers are dissatisfied with New York’s litigation environment and broadly favor changes to the state’s liability laws.
Voters overwhelmingly support reforms that align legal outcomes more closely with personal re Read More
New York’s Health Premiums Stayed at the Top in 2025
New Yorkers and their employers paid the highest health premiums in the lower 48 states in 2025, and their costs moved further above the U.S. average, according to recently released federal data.
Read More
Nine Millionaires among NY’s Public Authorities in 2025
Nine millionaires, all healthcare executives, emerged among the 88,228 New York public authority employees, according to, the Empire Center’s transparency website.
The data includes payroll information from 385 different agen Read More
NY’s Medicaid Fraud Watchdog Shows Declining Performance
Enforcement by the New York's Office of Medicaid Inspector General has dropped in recent years across a range of benchmarks – a sign that the state's anti-fraud efforts have slackened even as its Medicaid spending soared. Read More
Long Island schools: Ahead of a very mediocre pack
Long Island may be New York's strongest case that money matters in education — and also its strongest warning that, past a certain point, more money is not the answer.
Long Island is widely regarded as one of New York's better education regions, exce Read More
K-12 SOS Little Falls pilot
SUMMARY
Little Falls City School District’s student results are mixed compared with the state average. The district is below the state average in Grades 3-8 reading and math, U.S. History and Government Regents, and the four-year graduation ra Read More
Another Unrealistic Sales Pitch for AlbanyCare
Proponents of establishing a single-payer healthcare system in New York State are making a fresh set of unrealistic claims about their plan – this time by highlighting the supposed benefits for local governments.
Read More
132 NYSLRS Retirees Receive Pensions Over $200K in FY2026
A total of 132 retirees from the New York State and Local Retirement System (NYSLRS) were eligible to collect $200,000 or more in pensions during the 2026 fiscal year, according to , the Empire Center’s government transparency website.
Among the 132 Read More