Writing in today’s FT, investment-banking veteran (and former New York bailout-facilitator) Felix Rohatyn and ESC consulting-firm president Everett Ehlrich, pointing out that states still face $200 billion in operating deficits in the next three years, suggest a repeat of February’s economic stimulus.

Rohatyn and Ehlrich state that “the problem is not state profligacy but … a collapse in income tax revenues driven by cyclical economic conditions, for one, and the collapse of capital gains tax realisations.”

They suggest that Congress expand the February stimulus by $100 billion solely to “plug the states’ fiscal hole,” with “one-third to go directly to our largest localities.”

The team’s diagnosis is not quite correct, however.

In the states that face the biggest deficits, including New York and California, the main problem is that for years, unsustainable growth in tax revenues, much of it from the financial and real-estate sectors, fed unsustainable growth in operating spending, which far outpaced inflation.

The tax revenues have evaporated, yet the spending base remains.

This is an old story in New York and California.

In New York, the nation’s very largest locality — New York City — was happy to let spending keep pace with record tax revenues between 2003 and 2007. In the past eight years, city spending has outpaced inflation more than two-fold; adjusted for both inflation and population, it now surpasses Lindsay-era heights.

But even the traditionally low-tax, low-spending states that were home to the biggest real-estate bubbles ramped up their outlays during the boom years. They were flush with sales-tax revenues from tourists who had some money to spare after forking over their income taxes to California and New York.

To wit: Between 2000 and 2008, spending in Arizona grew by 41 percent after inflation, outpacing population growth by 12 percentage points.

In Nevada, spending grew by 70 percent, outpacing population growth by 40 percentage points.

Florida managed to keep general spending growth roughly in line with population, but only by using its state-guaranteed property-insurance program to subsidize torrid real-estate development in natural-disaster-prone areas, creating a huge, unfunded liability for the future.

Any new stimulus to plug state budget gaps would be dubious, because all it does is allow states (and cities) to maintain too-high spending levels that crowd out private-sector activity; New York has been sending its private-sector growth across its borders for years.

Further, if the next batch of state stimulus, like the last, mostly goes toward education and healthcare, it also would exacerbate existing imbalances that hurt the private sector, which badly needs better physical infrastructure rather than yet more spending in areas where the next dollar spent doesn’t equal a dollar’s worth of improvement.

Any suggestion for new stimulus money shouldn’t come unaccompanied by a strong suggestion that such stimulus come with real strings attached. The conditions for the money should be measurable, concrete, and permanent actions from state legislatures and local governments to rein in out-of-control pension, healthcare and other costs, the real culprits of many of the deficits.

In New York and California, such reform should also include efforts to make tax revenues less prone to severe swings, including lessening dependence on wealthy taxpayers’ highly volatile income.

California has at least made noise about such efforts; New York has not.

You may also like

Tracking the increased outflow of NY taxpayers in 2019-20

A record high number of federal income tax filers and their dependents moved from New York to other states from 2019 to 2020, and the average incomes of Empire State out-migrants topped $100,000 for the first time, according to newly released (IRS). Read More

Fuzzy Math: The Climate Action Council’s $260 Billion Mistake

Chief among a public servant’s responsibilities to their constituents is to be truthful about the policies they are enacting—but New York’s Climate Action Council is misleading the public about the benefits of the Clim Read More

NY’s pre-Covid tax base drain confirmed in new comptroller’s report

New York was a net loser of income tax filers to other states even in the five years leading up to the pandemic disruption of 2020 Read More

Charter Law Fix is Low-Hanging Fruit for Legislature

A floor amendment to lift the charter cap that limits the number of charters granted to operate such schools in New York City was rejected by the State Senate last week. Read More

Voters Reject a Pair of Tax Cap-Breaching School Budgets

New York school districts whose budgets were defeated yesterday can hold a re-vote in June on the same proposal or a modified one Read More

NY’s pandemic-punctuated school spending topped US average by 89%

In a school year whose last quarter was severely disrupted by the Covid-19 pandemic, New York once again led all states in spending on elementary and secondary education Read More

Renewable Energy, Open Space, and Agriculture – New York Can’t Have it All

New York faces the prospect of growing land use conflicts in coming years, due to the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act Read More

Can New York City Do Without the Greenpoint Energy Project?

National Grid is trying to expand its natural gas compression facility in Brooklyn, but New York’s Department of Environmental Conservation delayed making a decision to approve it Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries: Info@EmpireCenter.org

Press Inquiries: Press@EmpireCenter.org


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!