Just in time to further debunk claims that the wealthy don’t pay their “fair share” of New York State taxes, the Assembly Majority Ways and Means staff has issued a pessimistic new assessment of the economic outlook (“bleak”) and revenue forecast (sinking fast).  And right there on p. 80 of the Ways & Means Revenue Report is this passage:

New York, like the Federal government, utilizes a progressive personal income tax structure. This method of taxing naturally implies a higher weight on the contributions of the State’s most wealthy taxpayers. As a result, a progressive tax structure has a more elastic response to market volatility than a less progressive structure.

On the following page is this chart:


As shown, the highest-earning 10 percent of taxpayers generated 58 percent of the growth in adjusted growth income (AGI) but nearly 74 percent of the growth in income tax receipts in 2006.  The bottom 90 percent accounted for roughly 42 percent of AGI growth but only 26 percent of tax liability growth.

The headline news associated with the issuance of Ways & Means reports is the forecast that revenues will be $1 billion lower than the projection in Governor David Paterson’s budget.  “The Assembly is committed to working with the Executive and the Senate to craft a budget that fulfills our commitments to education, health, economic development and public protection, while ensuring that the burden of cuts does not fall disproportionately on poor and working class families,” Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver said.

Translation: Sure, there’s even less money than everyone thought.  But we still want to restore Paterson’s baseline spending reductions and raise income taxes on high-income households.

However, before rushing to reinflate disbursements and enact the so-called “millionaire tax” to finance them, Silver might want to dig a little more deeply into the Ways & Means report — particularly the section detailing how the budget gap got this big in the first place.

Since 2003-04, the Revenue Report notes, the state has experienced record increases in all major taxes, “especially the ones directly related to the booming Wall Street and real estate markets.”

The report continues:

During those years of unprecedented gains the State increased its reliance upon sources of revenue that are inherently unstable. However this mix of volatile tax receipts sources – such as the bonus component of wages and capital gains – has also proved to be unsustainable. The transformation in the financial markets – with the disappearance of investment banks and what promises to be new safeguards and oversight in lending practices – will have significant implications for the State’s future revenues. To the extent that incentive compensation in Wall Street changes, as most observers tend to think, with more internal restriction in bonus pools and allocations, it is doubtful that New York will experience going forward the same unprecedented growth in PIT receipts, especially from wealthier income groups.

So, to recap the analysis from the Ways & Means Revenue Report:

  • New York State has been heavily reliant on a “progressive” income tax, which “implies a higher weight on the contributions of the State’s most wealthy taxpayers,”  including investment-related income. (Page 80)
  • But that kind of revenue is “inherently unstable,” “volatile”and “unsustainable.” (Page 40)
  • “Stable revenue growth is the cornerstone of a sound financial plan.” (Ibid.)

And the implication of all this is … New York should raise taxes on its (remaining) wealthy taxpayers?  Sounds like a recipe for more instability in the future.  Not to mention further economic decline.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

New York’s Medicaid Spending Is Running Billions Over Budget

New York's Medicaid program ran billions of dollars over budget during the first half of the fiscal year, adding to signs of a brewing fiscal crisis in Albany. According to the fro Read More

As migrants flow to NY, so does red ink 

The influx of foreign migrants to New York could cost the state $4.5 billion more than expected next year, Governor Hochul today warned.  Read More

At mid-year, NY still far below most states in pandemic jobs recovery

New York has added private-sector jobs in all but three of the 38 months since the COVID-19 outbreak of March 2020—but the Empire State remains below its pre-pandemic employment level and continues to trail the national recovery. On a seasonally adju Read More

The Bill Arrives: NY Faces $9B Budget Gap Next Year 

New York’s outyear budget gaps, the shortfall between planned state expenses and state tax receipts over the next three years, has exploded to more than $36 billion, just-released documents show.  Read More

NY school spending again led US, hitting all-time high in 2020-21

Public elementary and secondary school spending in New York rose to $26,571 per pupil in 2020-21, according to the latest Census Bureau data Read More

A Tale of Two Levies

New York school districts are getting record levels of state aid. But how many are using it to cut taxes? Read More

Albany’s Belated Budget Binge 

State lawmakers have begun passing the bills necessary to implement the state budget for the fiscal year that began April 1. Read More

Hospital Lobby’s TV Campaign Spreads Misinformation About Medicaid

As New York's health-care industry agitates for more money from the state budget, two of its most influential lobbying groups are airing TV ads that make alarmist and inaccurate claims about Medicaid. Read More

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!