ALBANY — A job-creation program highly touted by Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s administration created just 408 new jobs in its first two full years, despite an advertising campaign that cost state taxpayers tens of millions of dollars.

Businesses participating in the state’s Start-Up NY program created 332 jobs in 2015 after creating 76 in 2014, according to a new state report.

The report from Empire State Development, the Cuomo administration’s economic-development branch, was released Friday evening ahead of the holiday weekend, a time notorious for government agencies to release unflattering news.

It was more than 90 days late: By law, the report was due March 31.

Leslie Whatley, executive vice president for Start-Up NY, said the report shows the program has “momentum.” She said the report was late in part because some companies submitted inaccurate or late data.

“The first year of the program, we were building it,” said Whatley, who is leaving the program next week. “Now we’ve got momentum and there’s going to be a lot more jobs coming in this year. I mean, we’re building up steam.”

Start-Up NY allows new and growing businesses to avoid paying state and local taxes for 10 years if they locate in specific zones in New York at various public and private college campuses and properties.

The Rochester region gained 69 jobs in 2015 through the controversial program.

In the Finger Lakes, startups occupy space at places such as the University of Rochester, Finger Lakes Community College, Rochester Institute of Technology, Keuka College and The College at Brockport.

In the Finger Lakes region, 12 companies occupy Start-Up NY spaces — including Datto, Darkwind Media and PharmAdva. According to Friday’s report, Start-Up NY companies around Rochester received almost $131,000 in tax breaks in 2015 from the state.

For job growth, Datto led the way for local startups, creating 39 jobs last year. Behind Datto, ClearCove Systems created 10 in 2015. ClearCove Systems is slated to receive a state investment of $3.89 million.

Three local startups, however, did not create jobs in 2015 — Dogways, Temida and Darkwind Media.

In some regions, the report showed few results in the first two years, including the Southern Tier, which saw nine companies in the Start-Up program create seven jobs. The six Start-Up companies at Binghamton University combined to create a single job in 2015.

In the mid-Hudson region, which stretches from Westchester County north to Sullivan County, Start-Up businesses created five jobs last year — all in Kingston.

The state has spent tens of millions of dollars promoting the program, including $53 million from late 2013 to early 2015. The bulk of that cost was spent on seemingly ubiquitous television advertisements.

After two full years, the program has created more tax-free areas across the state (441) than jobs, according to the report.

So far, 159 companies have been approved for the program, including 102 that are new businesses. Together, they invested $11.4 million in New York in 2015 and received $1.2 million in tax benefits.

The report does little to tout the Start-Up program’s current job-creation results, putting the number of jobs created last year into a footnote while choosing instead to tout the companies’ five-year projections. The companies have “committed to creating over 4,100 jobs” in their first five years, according to the report.

Empire State Development also chose to mix the Start-Up report — which is mandated by law — into a broader report examining several state economic-development programs, including the Buffalo Billion and the Excelsior Jobs Program.

Ken Girardin, communications manager for the Empire Center, a fiscally conservative think tank, said the figures in the Start-Up report are the “clearest evidence to date that the state’s business climate isn’t only being hindered by high taxes.”

“Start-Up NY was supposed to be a silver bullet, but instead it’s just been a shiny object that’s distracted state lawmakers from making the necessary changes to make the state truly attractive to business,” Girardin said.

Whatley said next year’s report will show significant growth in the Southern Tier and mid-Hudson regions, particularly at Binghamton University and in Rockland County.

© 2016 Gannett News Service

You may also like

‘Nano-fantasy’: Experts weigh in on Marcy Nano

Edmund McMahon, found and research director, the Empire Center, “At the end of the day, you’re still talking about a site that’s remote, to put it kindly. Right now, for all the marketing spin, this still feels more like a nano-fantasy." Read More

EDITORIAL: When Albany plays Santa, hold on to your wallet

As the Empire Center’s Ken Girardin reported last week, new SMFP cash “was noticeably missing from the budget bills adopted on April 1, raising the suspicion that a fresh infusion” will be part of the Big Ugly legislation rushed through in the end-of-session crush. Read More

Economic inequality continues rising in Capital Region, U.S.

Opponents of a higher minimum wage, like the Empire Center for Public Policy, have argued that a gradual minimum wage increase would increase employer overhead and cost the state up to 200,000 jobs — and at least 11,000 in the Capital Region alone. Read More

Expanding prevailing wage: a help to region’s fortunes, or hindrance?

But an Empire Center for Public Policy study estimated that the state's prevailing wage mandate would drive up the cost of publicly funded projects by at least 20 percent in the Buffalo area, compared to median private-sector construction wages. The study estimated the mandate led to increases of anywhere from 13 percent to 25 percent in the state, depending on the region. Read More

Should New York re-think its economic development approach?

We also reached out to the experts to see what they have to say. In our latest “Ask the Experts” feature, we reached out to Donnie Charleston, diirector of state and local fiscal engagement at the Urban Institute; David Friedfel, director of state studies at the Citizens Budget Commission; Bruce Gyory, a senior advisor at Manatt, Phelps & Phillips and a Democratic political consultant; Jim Heaney, the founder, editor and executive director of Investigative Post; and E.J. McMahon, research director at the Empire Center for Public Policy. Read More

EDITORIAL: New York’s real problem is weak leadership

The Empire Center, an Albany think tank, released a report in May 2018 that took note of New York surpassing all other states with per-pupil elementary and secondary school spending of $22,366 per pupil as of 2016. The report noted that the Empire State spent 90 percent more than the U.S. average of $11,762, up from 86 percent above average in 2015. The education spending gap between New York and the national average has grown dramatically over the past 20 years, the Empire Center noted. Read More

Cuomo has utterly failed the people of upstate New York

To those who don’t get north of the city’s suburbs, Cuomo’s talk of an “even” economic recovery across the state may sound fine. But a new report from the Empire Center’s E.J. McMahon highlights the ugly facts. Read More

Critics: Problems with Cuomo’s economic development programs go beyond corruption

Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s economic development programs have been the subject of two federal corruption trials that ended with convictions for two of Cuomo’s former associates. But some say problems with the $9 billion programs go beyond corruption and that the structure of the programs is flawed. Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries:

Press Inquiries:


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!