The U.S. Supreme Court today kept alive federal litigation that could cost New York a big chunk of the billions of dollars in taxes it collects from nonresidents working for New York-based employers.

The state of New Hampshire had asked the Supreme Court to review a policy under which the neighboring state of Massachusetts has collected income tax from New Hampshire residents who formerly commuted to jobs in Massachusetts, but who have been required to work from home during the pandemic.

As a legal matter, the Court was being asked to take the highly unusual step of asserting “original jurisdiction” in a dispute between two states, skipping all of the usual intermediate steps in federal litigation. New Hampshire cited its “fundamental sovereign interests” in asking the court for leave to file a complaint against its neighboring state.

The case has huge implications for New York, which has long asserted the right to tax the earnings of nonresidents working for New York-based employers in other states. Since the pandemic began in March, this cohort has expanded to include hundreds of thousands of New Jersey and Connecticut residents who had been regular commuters to New York City.

After discussing the New Hampshire filing in their conference on Friday, the nine justices might have simply refused to hear the case. On the other extreme, they might have agreed to take the case right away. Instead, the justices chose a third route, summed up in a single sentence in today’s order list:

The Acting Solicitor General is invited to file a brief in this case expressing the views of the United States.

The Solicitor General of the United States works for the President—so, in effect, the justices want to know if Joe Biden thinks they should take up this case.

As a legal matter, this is a significant step, encouraging to backers of New Hampshire’s case—including the 14 states that filed two different amicus briefs supporting the motion. One of those amicus briefs—arguing that the New Hampshire motion presented an issue of “nationwide and pressing importance”—was filed by four states, including New Jersey and Connecticut, whose residents paid more than $5 billion of New York State personal incomes taxes in 2018.

As a political matter, the case creates an interesting conflict of interest for President Biden. New Hampshire is a political swing state that Biden carried in last November’s election. Massachusetts has long been one of the nation’s most thoroughly Democratic states, although it has a Republican governor. If New Hampshire wins, other beneficiaries would include low-tax red states such as Texas, which signed on to a brief supporting New Hampshire that was also supported by the states of Ohio, Arkansas, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Missouri, Nebraska, Oklahoma, and Utah.

Other than Massachusetts itself, the state with the greatest interest in squashing the New Hampshire motion is New York.  So far, however, the Cuomo administration has not (yet) bothered to submit a brief in the New Hampshire case.

 

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

The Pandemic Could Take Away Some NY Cash Cows

The Empire State has long asserted the right to tax nonresidents commuting to work in New York—even when their work is done at home. The payoff for Albany is huge: as of 2018, newly released state data show, nonresidents generated $7.4 billion in New York State personal income taxes, 15 percent of the total. Most of that came from people who were regular commuters before COVID-19 hit. Read More

As a Supreme Court Ruling Loomed, Cuomo Bent His Own Rules on COVID ‘Clusters’

In the midst of the constitutional showdown over his pandemic policies, Governor Cuomo made changes to a disputed Brooklyn 'cluster zone' that seemed to contradict his own declared guidelines. Read More

In Pandemic Recovery, New York’s Tax Base Is More Fragile Than Ever

New York's exceptionally wealthy state tax base is also exceptionally fragile, due to its heavy dependence on the highly volatile (and portable) investment-driven incomes of Wall Street workers and fund managers. Read More

New Yorkers Paid Less in Federal Taxes in First Year of New Federal Tax Law

Federal income taxes paid by New Yorkers decreased by nearly $3.4 billion in 2018, the first year of the new federal Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), according to newly released Internal Revenue Service data. Read More

SALT suit swept aside

In what could rank among the least surprising federal court rulings of this or any year, a U.S. District Court judge in Manhattan has rejected New York's constitutional challenge to the state and local tax (SALT) deduction cap in the new federal tax law. Read More

Gillibrand’s shifting Medicare math

Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand has apparently doubled the price tag of her Medicare buy-in proposal, from 4 percent of income to 8 percent – but the math still does not add up. Read More

Soaking the rich—or not

New York State's so-called millionaire tax, temporarily raising the state's top income tax rate to 8.82 percent from the permanent law limit of 6.85 percent, is next scheduled to expire at the end of 2019. The added tax generates roughly $4.5 billion a year, about 9 percent of net personal income tax revenues, making New York more dependent than ever on the highest-earning one percent of its taxpayers. The future of the tax has now emerged as an issue in the gubernatorial campaign. Read More

Sizing up tax reform

Seemingly stalled on health care and Medicaid, congressional Republicans and the Trump administration will soon turn their attention to taxes—another area in which federal reform offers mixed prospects for New York State. Read More

Subscribe

Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130
E-Mail: info@empirecenter.org

About

The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo "Readers will recall that the Empire Center is the think tank that spent months trying to pry Covid data out of Mr. Cuomo’s government, which offered a series of unbelievable excuses for its refusal to disclose...five months after it sued the government, and one week after a state court ruled that the Cuomo administration had violated the law and ordered it to come clean—Team Cuomo finally started coughing up some of the records."   -Wall Street Journal, February 19, 2021

SIGN UP TO STAY UP TO DATE ON THIS AND THOSE OTHER ISSUES THAT IMPACT NEW YORKERS.