The push in Albany to boost wages for home health aides is seemingly disconnected from the larger realities of the state’s long-term care system.

As they lobby for a big increase in Medicaid funding, officials in the home care industry are warning that the state faces an “extreme shortage” of in-home caregivers due to low pay.

What they don’t mention is that New York’s home care workforce is extraordinarily large and well-funded by national standards – and growing at an explosive rate.

Any labor shortages that still exist are a sign of deeper problems in the state’s home-care program that a wage hike alone could not fix.

At issue is the Fair Pay for Home Care Act (S. 5374 (May)/A. 6329 (Gottfried), , which would require that home health aides be paid at least 50 percent more than the minimum wage, plus an allotment for benefits.

The additional cost to the state’s Medicaid program, which finances most home care, has been estimated at $4 billion a year. That’s enough to cover a year’s tuition and living expenses for 154,000 SUNY students, buy health insurance for 488,000 individuals or pay the salaries of 50,000 schoolteachers.

The bill is a top priority of the health-care workers union 1199 SEIU, which is one of Albany’s most influential interest groups, and has broad, bipartisan support in both houses of the Legislature.

Before moving forward, lawmakers should consider the following context from the Bureau of Labor Statistics:

  • New York’s per capita employment of home health and personal care aides is 140 percent higher than the national average and 30 percent higher than that of any other state (see chart).
  • New York’s home health workforce grew by 230,000 over the past decade, almost doubling in size, making it one of the fastest-growing jobs in the state.
  • Unlike the state’s overall job count, home health employment has fully bounced back from its losses during the pandemic and stands almost 16,000 higher now than it was in March 2020.
  • Although wages are low, they have not been static. The average hourly pay of home health aides in New York was $15.45 in 2020, an increase of 43 percent since 2010.

New York’s spending on home care is also skyrocketing. Over the past decade, Medicaid expenditures on the services known as personal assistance, which are the bulk of home care, quadrupled from $3.2 billion to $12.8 billion. As of 2019, the last year for which national data are available, New York’s per capita spending on personal care was almost eight times higher than the national average and almost three times higher than any other state.

The growth rates of spending and employment far exceed the increase in the state’s over-65 population, which rose 30 percent from 2010 to 2020.

The state’s home care program is heavily concentrated in New York City. In the two relevant job categories, there are roughly three workers for every 10 city residents over age 65, which is almost four times the national average. Outside New York City, the employment rate is slightly lower than the national average (see chart).

Industry officials report that the minimum wage hike enacted in 2016 has made it harder for them to compete for workers with fast-food chains and retail stores. According to labor data, however, home care employment has continued growing at a robust pace since 2016, even as the number of fast-food and retail jobs has declined (see chart).

These trends suggest that any shortage of labor in the home care industry is driven not by low wages, but by a level of demand that is unusually high by national standards – especially in New York City – and continues to rise to unprecedented heights.

Rather than simply pouring more money into an extraordinarily expensive program, lawmakers should focus on what appears to be excessive utilization of home care services – by tightening eligibility rules and screening procedures, allocating resources more even-handedly around the state, and improving enforcement against abuse and fraud.

About the Author

Bill Hammond

As the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy, Bill Hammond tracks fast-moving developments in New York’s massive health care industry, with a focus on how decisions made in Albany and Washington affect the well-being of patients, providers, taxpayers and the state’s economy.

Read more by Bill Hammond

You may also like

What’s behind NY’s union membership slide?

The frequency with which New York workers are choosing to belong to a union last year continued its multi-year decline. Read More

The AG’s nursing home lawsuits are a wake-up call for the Health Department

Attorney General Letitia James' recent lawsuits against nursing homes have not only exposed dangerous conditions for the residents – but also dangerous blind spots at the Health Department. Read More

Hochul’s agenda mostly sidesteps health care

Governor Hochul gave health care surprisingly little attention in her State of the State speech on Tuesday – a sign that taking on dysfunction in one-sixth of the state's economy ranks low on her list of priorities. Read More

Federal omnibus deal has big implications for New York Medicaid

The big spending bill heading for a vote in Washington this week would scramble the outlook for Medicaid in next year's state budget, mostly for the better. The $1.7 trillion federa Read More

The AG’s Nursing Home Lawsuit Scratches the Surface of Widespread Issues

The attorney general's just-filed lawsuit against the Villages of Orleans nursing home has implications that reach far beyond a single facility in western New York. In addition to c Read More

The Essential Plan’s accumulated surplus balloons to $8 billion, with no fix in sight

The state's Essential Plan has generated billions in surpluses as the program automatically drew pandemic relief money that it did not need Read More

NY pandemic recovery update: climbing, but still far behind

Private employment in New York State remained more than 300,000 jobs short of the pre-pandemic level Read More

NY’s jobs recovery now strongest downstate

The Empire State's private-sector employment gains over the past year have been increasingly concentrated in New York City. Read More

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!