Governor Hochul started previewing this week aspects of her “State of the State” speech before a joint session of the Legislature scheduled for next Tuesday.

It’s a century-old tradition with vestiges of the British monarchy—that the framers of New York’s constitution thought they eliminated over 200 years ago.

New York’s constitutional framers explicitly rejected the governor making an in-person address to the Legislature—a custom akin to a speech from the throne by the monarch—and put a provision in New York’s 1821 Constitution to have the governor provide only a written message.

Governor Alfred E. Smith started the modern practice in 1923. A New York Times report conveyed that in a “distinct innovation” Smith would read his message to the Legislature in-person, abandoning the “time-honored tradition of delivering his annual message to the Legislature in writing.” But Smith’s predecessors were not following tradition—they were following the Constitution. It has mandated for over 200 years that the governor present the annual message in writing.

New Yorkers adopted new wording in the 1821 Constitution. It provided that the governor “shall communicate by message to the legislature at every session, the condition of the state; and recommend such matters to them as he shall judge expedient.” Only some pronouns and punctuation have changed in the 200 years since. The 1777 Constitution made it the governor’s duty to “inform” the Legislature of the condition of the state that was changed in the 1821 Constitution to “communicate by message.”

To be sure, in its modern usage the word “message” can mean something other than written words. Callers leave voicemail messages. Television programs return after messages from sponsors. And the sermon or homily may be called the message in some contemporary churches. 

Yet Delegate Livingston to the 1821 Constitutional Convention, who proposed the provision, made clear—and the other delegates understood—what “message” meant. He suggested the wording “so as to make it the duty of the governor to address the legislature by message instead of speech.” Further, he sought to dispose of “a relic of monarchy, founded in the love of pomp, and splendour and show.”

Livingston proposed New Yorkers make part of their Constitution a practice started at the federal level by Thomas Jefferson two decades earlier. Jefferson sent the Speaker of the House a written message relaying the state of the union. Jefferson explained his reasoning in a cover letter accompanying it and distinguished a written message from a personal address to Congress. 

“The circumstances under which we find ourselves at this place rendering inconvenient the mode heretofore practised, of making, by personal Address, the first communications, between the legislative and Executive branches, I have adopted that by Message …”

Jefferson could change course because the federal constitution is ambiguous. Under Section 3 of Article 2 of the United States Constitution the President “shall from time to time give to the Congress information of the state of the union, and recommend to their consideration such measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient.” Presidents George Washington and John Adams understood “give…information” to mean by personal address.

New York governors do not have that flexibility.

Jefferson sought to accommodate the convenience of the legislature and the economy of their time, and to not put them on the spot to answer his proposals. His reasons were consistent with a president of a republic not wanting to impose on Congress the way a monarch might. Livingston had similar concerns in 1821, citing 11 days of debate that followed the governor’s speech in 1814, along with his goal of eliminating a relic of the monarchy. To be sure, Livingston’s lengthy debate-time concerns do not carry as much weight in the 21st century where the Legislature routinely passes budget bills containing major policy proscriptions like bail reform in the wee hours of the night.

To his credit, Smith read an annual message that ran only 35 pages and addressed 30 topics, which was consistent with the length and content of annual messages of his predecessors. He addressed first the state’s finances and then prioritized reducing executive departments (and consolidating administrative functions) and urged implementing an executive budget system to control the Legislature’s profligate spending.

Today, the State of the State is a multi-day process. Multiple press releases and public appearances precede and follow a speech presenting highlights of the governor’s written policy proposals. In 2023, Hochul proposed 147 initiatives in a 277-page State of the State Book. She did, however, save the state from some of the pomp and splendor of her predecessor by giving her address in the legislative chamber.

There’s nothing to stop the Legislature from inviting Hochul to read her written message in person. Editing the annual message down to a size that Hochul can read in one address could provide a more focused look first at the state’s financial condition and then at limited policy recommendations that address that condition.

About the Author

Cam Macdonald

Cameron J. “Cam” Macdonald is an Adjunct Fellow with the Empire Center and Executive Director and General Counsel for the Government Justice Center.

Read more by Cam Macdonald

You may also like

82 Questions Hochul’s Pandemic Report Should Answer

This is the month when New Yorkers are due to finally receive an official report on the state's response to the Covid-19 pandemic, one of the deadliest disasters in state history. T Read More

The Real Lack of Courage Driving NYC Congestion Pricing

Governor Hochul is taking heat after postponing the state’s years-old plan to charge drivers to enter lower Manhattan. As critics slam her for lacking “political courage,” it’s an appropriate time to examine some of the underlying issues that congestion pricing was meant to indirectly mitigate—because many if not most advocates were afraid to touch those issues themselves. And if congestion pricing proponents are to be taken at their word about their concern for MTA finances, or traffic, or air quality, they must show some of the same courage they’ve accused the governor of lacking. Read More

To Encourage Recycling, Pols Move To Trash The Legislature

New York state lawmakers in recent years have surrendered some of their policymaking and taxing powers to the executive branch. With the 2024 legislative session coming to close, they’re poised to go even further and turn those powers over to an organization outside of government entirely. Read More

Lawmakers Seek To Revive a $10 Fee for Prescriptions That Was Dropped by DFS

A plan to require a $10.18 "dispensing fee" for filling drug prescriptions is back on the table in Albany – this time in the form of legislation rather than regulation. The Read More

Running Over Taxpayers: Legislature Speeding to Protect Cadillac Benefits for NYC Retirees

Bills designed to block any change to retiree health coverage for state and local public employees have been introduced repeatedly by legislators in both parties over the past 30 years. But the latest statewide “anti-diminution” measure, inspired by an ongoing controversy in New York City, would be the broadest and most costly yet—and more than two-thirds of state lawmakers are supporting it. Read More

How a Medicaid ‘Cut’ Could Lead to More Unionization of Home Care Aides

A money-saving maneuver in the newly enacted Medicaid budget could end up increasing costs in the long term – by paving the way for more unionization of the state's burgeoning home health workforce. Read More

Eight in 10 New York towns and cities have lost population since 2020

Filling in more details of New York's ongoing demographic decline, the Census Bureau has just released updated local population estimates showing that 80 percent of the state's towns and cities have lost residents since 2020. In addition to New York Ci Read More

Sales tax receipts are signaling slow growth in most of New York State

After rising sharply with an extra push from the inflation surge of 2022, sales tax receipts in New York grew much more slowly during the first four months of this year, according to from state Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli's office. Statewide sales tax Read More