the-mta-fare-hikes-already-set-to-consume-much-of-obamas-stimulus-may-not-be-enough

The MTA: fare hikes, already set to consume much of Obama’s stimulus, may not be enough

As Albany seems to give up altogether over finding a new revenue source for the state-run Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the MTA released some numbers this morning showing that its budget situation is getting worse by the minute.

Through February, the MTA’s fare and toll revenues came in $5.1 million below expectations, or more than half a percent. Drop-offs at the Long Island Rail Road and Metro North, of nearly 2 percent apiece, are especially sobering. Subway ridership was a percent lower than expected, too.

These traffic drop-offs are terrible harbingers.

First, they’re more evidence of how job losses are hitting New York.

Second, they mean that the MTA’s 23 percent fare hikes may not be enough, as unbelievable as that may seem.

The MTA’s fare hikes depend on the idea that passenger traffic is fairly impervious to the higher fares — that is, that ridership won’t drop off significantly as fares and tolls go up.

But in this economy, customer behavior in response to any price increase is unpredictable. So is the level of future job losses in New York over the next year.

If more riders simply stop using transit, the massive fare hikes on which the MTA began to vote today will not be enough to overcome the authority’s $1.15 to $1.5 billion deficit for the upcoming year. (And no, lower traffic won’t help the MTA much in cutting costs, since its costs are largely fixed.)

Meanwhile, the gap that these huge fare hikes are supposed to cover continues to widen.

How? The MTA also said today that its real-estate related taxes, too, are falling off precipitously — more precipitously than it had expected.

The authority’s “mortgage recording tax” revenues for the year so far are 42 percent less than it had budgeted — significant because it had already budgeted for tremendous decreases here. Taxes on commercial property transactions in New York City are 67 percent lower than expected.

And the rate of drop-off is increasing. In March, the figures were 52 percent and 76 percent respectively.

These figures provide yet more evidence that Albany is being inexcusably negligent for not stepping in with some sort of solution for this crisis, including a sustainable new source of revenue and a sustainable fix for the authority’s fast-rising employee benefits costs.

No, there is nothing wrong with a small fare hike, along the lines of the 8 percent fare hike that the MTA would enact were it to get new money from Albany.

But playing around with 23 percent fare hikes is playing with the future of the city’s economy.

Obviously, the game gets more dangerous when fare hikes, inevitably, reach 30 percent or more.

Lastly, such massive fare hikes would go a long way toward undoing the local effect of the federal stimulus money that President Obama meant to go directly into people’s pockets.

Under the federal stimulus, the average person gets a $400 credit annually for the next two years — $33 a month.

But the MTA’s unlimited-ride card could go from $81 to $103 — taking back $22, or two-thirds, of that average stimulus.

Even with TransitChek and other programs that allow workers to pay for commutes with pre-tax dollars, the fare hikes still would consume half of the personal stimulus.

You may also like

Giving Families an Escape Hatch from NYC Public Schools

Zohran Mamdani's stunning election as mayor of New York City marks a watershed moment for the Empire State. As a self-described democratic socialist and member of the Democratic Socialists of America, Mamdani rode a wave of pr Read More

As Immigration Slowed, New York’s Population Hit a Wall in 2025

New York State added just 1,008 new residents last year as its post-pandemic recovery ground to a near standstill, newly released Census Bureau estimates show. The population increa Read More

Is Hochul Really Going to Shut Down the Essential Plan?

Governor Hochul is hingeing a big chunk of her budget – and the state's health-care system – on a politically fraught gambit: asking the Trump administration to help cover immigrants. Read More

State Delays Disclosing Emails About $1B Home Health Contract

For a third time the state Health Department has postponed releasing records related to a disputed $1 billion Medicaid contract, saying it needs another six weeks or more to locate and redact the materials in question. Read More

Email Confirms Early Contact Between NY Officials and CDPAP Contractor

State officials met with the ultimate winner of a $1 billion Medicaid contract two weeks before the Legislature authorized bidding on the job as part of the state's 2024-25 budget, an email obtained by the Empire Center sho Read More

From Promises to Vetoes: Hochul’s Actions Belie Her Commitment to Transparency

Governor Kathy Hochul made news this fall when she used her legislative veto power in a way that looked personal. That’s how Albany watchers and the target, Senator James Skoufis, w Read More

Budget Update Paints Less Alarming Picture of Federal Health Cuts

A new fiscal report from the state Budget Division suggests federal funding cuts will hit New York's health-care budget less severely than officials have previously warned. A relea Read More

Parsing the Impact of Mamdani’s Tax Hike Plans

The front-running candidate for New York City mayor, Zohran Mamdani, has said he can finance his costly campaign promises – including free buses and universal child care – by taxing only a sliver of the city's residents Read More