screen-shot-2014-07-21-at-9-07-48-am-150x150-1740692Most high-income New York City residents who left the city in 2012 moved to neighboring jurisdictions, according to a new analysis of federal Census data by the city Independent Budget Office (IBO).

Among households with incomes above $500,000, 42 percent moved to New York suburbs, 22 percent moved to New Jersey and 12 moved to CT in 2012, the IBO says. New York households with lower incomes were less likely to move to neighboring states and more likely to move to low-tax Florida.

An article in today’s New York Times cites the IBO numbers as evidence that (as the headline trumpets) “Wealthier New Yorkers Aren’t Fleeing the City for Tax Havens.”

That’s a real stretch. In fact, while New York State, New Jersey and Connecticut are not known for low taxes, they are tax havens compared to New York City, which imposes a 3.9 percent resident income tax on top of state income taxes.  Consider the following chart:

screen-shot-2014-07-21-at-8-14-58-am-3285664

A couple with income of $2 million a year can save roughly $70,000 a year in city income taxes by moving to a New York suburb, $80,000 by moving to New Jersey, and $100,000 by moving to Connecticut. While a chunk of those savings could be eaten up by higher suburban property taxes, many such families also move to save on private school tuitions they pay in the city.

The difference in income taxes is only part of the story. New York City also imposes a unique 4 percent tax on the profits of unincorporated businesses and professional partnerships. This effectively more than doubles the local tax on the incomes of many investment bankers, lawyers, accountants, physicians and other professionals living in the city. The unincorporated business tax is not based on an individual’s residence; it can only be avoided by moving an entire firm out of the city. This was another factor behind the proliferation of hedge funds in Connecticut, where property taxes are also somewhat lower than in New York State or New Jersey.

IBO’s analysis — the latest in a series of occasional “New York City by the Numbers” features on its website — also suggests that California was the third most popular destination for high-income households, drawing 9 percent of those who moved in 2012. California is the only state with a higher top income tax rate (13.3 percent) than New York City’s. Both tax and Census data have long reflected movements of high-income households between the two states, which surely includes more than a few well-paid actors and entertainment moguls who find it necessary to be in one place or the other.

The Times article touting the IBO analysis begins by citing Sean Hannity’s threat to move from Long Island to Florida, and actor Gerard Depardieu’s tax-avoidance move from France to Russia, and then notes (further down in the story) that former Mayor Michael Bloomberg was critical of Mayor Bill de Blasio’s unsuccessful proposal to raise the city income tax. Oddly, however, it doesn’t actually quote anyone making what it calls “the frequent assertion that wealthy people reflexively flee New York City …  for low-tax states.” 

In fact, the “frequent assertion” cited in the Times is not frequently made by serious critics of the city’s tax policies. No one familiar with tax or census data would claim there has been an exodus of high-income New Yorkers to ultra low-tax states. The main argument against New York’s higher income taxes is that they stifle growth and discourage investment in the city compared to competing jurisdictions that undeniably offer similar advantages at a lower cost.

The bottom line: any high-income New York City resident determined to save money on his or her  taxes can do so simply by stepping across the border in any direction.  The Times is hyping the IBO numbers to slay a straw man.

(By the way, the IBO bases its analysis on a Census Bureau microdata file that has very small sample sizes at the high end of the income scale. As a result, it is difficult to assess the statistical significance of a reported increase in migration by high-income households to neighboring suburbs between 2008 and 2012, or a decrease in migration to California during the same period, which is also shown by the analysis.)

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

The Looming Collapse of a Long-Term Care Insurer Raises Questions for DFS

As the Hochul administration presses for the creation of a "guaranty fund" to bail out failed health insurers, the state is quietly moving to seize a small company that could be the fund's first target. Read More

In Buffalo, One of Many Failing Schools is Held Accountable

The looming closure of a Buffalo school that failed to meet student achievement standards is a timely reminder of the high level of accountability New York demands from its charter schools. Read More

The Build Public Renewables Act Could Cut the Power 

The Build Public Renewables Act would require the New York Power Authority to shut down all fossil fuel energy production as of 2030. Read More

Albany’s Other Way to Defund the Police 

State lawmakers are showing renewed interest in legislation that would rattle municipal finances and crowd out local services such as police and fire protection.  Read More

While pleading for money in Albany, hospitals and nursing homes spend at the bargaining table

Friday's announcement of an amended labor contract for New York City-area hospitals and nursing homes sends a contradictory message about the financial condition of the state's health-care industry. Read More

NY gained more jobs in 2022—mostly downstate

New York State ended 2022 with nearly 105,000 more private-sector payroll jobs than previously estimated, according to by the state Department of Labor—which also point to a continuing regional imbalance in New York's post-pandemic employment recovery. Read More

Does NY Have Too Many State Workers?

Public employee unions are pressing Governor Hochul and the Legislature to undertake a massive hiring binge. Read More

Climate of Confusion Surrounds CLCPA

According to a new , nearly four years after passage of the (CLCPA), most New Yorkers still aren’t familiar with the law. And despite supporti Read More

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!