New York’s state and local governments offer the nation’s second highest “pension replacement rate” — the percentage of preretirement income covered by an employee’s pension — according to a new study cited in today’s New York Times.
- New York Times graphic
The study is part of a broader report by Mary Williams Walsh on the increasing pension cost pressures faced by states. She reports that the pension replacement rate study by Sylvester J. Schieber, an economist and independent consultant, does not find a correlation between the generosity of pension benefits and union density in the public sector.
While Wisconsin’s public employees will now be forced to contribute more to their pensions, “other states will also probably find that Wisconsin’s idea of simply dividing pension contributions between labor and management is an illusory solution to their long-term financial woes,” Ms. Walsh reports. “That’s because several studies have shown that promises to workers are far more costly than routinely calculated by Wisconsin and most states.”
Colorado’s public retirement systems ranked first in Schieber’s study, with a pension replacement rate of 90.4 percent, while New York was second at 77 percent — although Colorado, unlike New York, has granted collective bargaining privileges to only one-quarter of its public-sector workers. Ranked right behind New York was Georgia, a right-to-work state with a very low rate of public sector unionization.
The lack of a strong union correlation should not be all that surprising, actually, since the basic structure of public pension benefits in many cases pre-dates the granting of collective bargaining privileges between the late 1950s and 1970s.
And, as the Times notes:
… Colorado’s pensions are unusually rich because its public workers are not permitted to participate in Social Security — the state pension is the only one they get.
The second-richest state is New York, which replaces 77 percent of a worker’s income, even though New York’s public work force earns Social Security benefits as well. A New Yorker’s public pension benefit, combined with Social Security, replaces more than 100 percent of his pay, Mr. Schieber found.
You may also like
Hochul’s Pushing Affordability. It Would Cost A Lot.
Governor Hochul is hammering an “affordability” theme in the leadup to Tuesday's 2025 State of the State address. But her campaign, dubbed "Money In Your Pockets," has so far featured little that would reduce the cost of providing, and therefore buying, goods or services in New York.
Instead, the biggest announced and expected elements reflect Albany's waning interest in growing the state economy—and a greater appetite to redistribute what it produces. Read More
Unions Reprogram NYS To Do Less With More
Governor Hochul on Saturday signed an innocuous-sounding bill to “regulate the use of automated decision-making systems and artificial intelligence techniques by state agencies.” But the “Legislative Oversight of Automated Decision-making in Government,” or LOADinG Act, wasn’t about protecting New York from self-aware computers trying to wipe out humanity. Instead, it was an early Christmas present for the state's public employee unions—and a lump of coal for New Yorkers hoping for more efficient state government. Read More
Former Utility Regulator Warns State Lawmakers They’re On the Naughty List
A legislative hearing into spending by the state’s sprawling energy agency featured a surprise guest who offered sober warnings about Albany’s energy policy. Read More
New York’s Public Employee Shortage Is Over
Public employee unions complained loudly when New York's state government workforce shrank during the coronavirus pandemic, using that decrease as pretext to press Governor Hochul and state lawmakers for more hiring and costly giveaways to benefit their members. But the latest data show nearly every state agency has more employees than it did a year ago, and that by at least one key measure, the state workforce is larger than it was before COVID. Read More
Upstate Insurance Customers Pay the Price for Medicare’s Hospital Rate Hike
A billion-dollar Medicare windfall for upstate hospitals has turned into a crisis for upstate health insurers that's threatening to disrupt coverage for millions of New Yorkers.
The Read More
Hochul Wants To Spend The Same Billions Twice
Governor Hochul’s plan to mail $500 checks to millions of households has a problem: the sales tax “surplus” she wants to dish out doesn't exist. Read More
How Will A Major Milk Plant Fit Under NY’s Climate Limits? It Won’t.
Plans to build a milk-processing facility in Monroe County were announced last year to great fanfare but with few details on how such an energy-intensive operation could fit within Albany’s strict climate rules poised to hit homes and businesses. The answer: it won’t have to. Read More
New York’s Proposed ‘MCO Tax’ Would Generate a Fraction of What Lawmakers Expected
The Hochul administration's proposed "MCO tax" would generate far less than the $4 billion in extra federal aid anticipated by state lawmakers when they approved the concept this spring, according to documents obtained by t Read More