New York’s newly enacted state budget for fiscal 2017 included an exceptionally large school aid increase of $1.5 billion—6.5 percent over the previous year, more than triple the projected inflation rate. This brings the state-funded share of K-12 public school expenses to an all-time record of nearly $25 billion, despite steadily declining enrollment. Given recent spending trends, demands for ever-larger increases are likely to persist.1

Since 2008-09, when the recession hit bottom, New York’s school staffing has receded from peak levels—yet school expenses have continued rising at a healthy pace. The latest State Education Department (SED) datahighlight two important trends that help explain school budget increases:

  • From 2008-09 to 2014-15, the statewide median teacher salary rose by 13 percent, with much larger increases in downstate suburbs and Western New York. Salaries were driven up in large part by automatic “step” raises locked into place by the state Triborough Amendment.3
  • Schools in 2014-15 employed only 3 percent fewer K-12 professional staffers than they did in 2000-01—although enrollment in the meantime had dropped about 10 percent.

The variations in school staffing since 2000-01—and the steady downward tumble of enrollment in the same period—are shown in Figure 1, below.

k12-2016-fig1-8633498

Between 2000-01 and 2008-09, New York schools added 14,746 teachers and 8,655 non-teaching professionals such as administrators and guidance counselors, an increase of 10 percent, even as enrollment dropped by 6 percent, or 168,057 pupils. Since 2008-09, schools have eliminated 29,922 net positions—but enrollment also has dropped, by 111,999.

As shown in Table 1, the greatest disparity between student enrollment and staffing trends has been in New York City. The city’s student enrollment has decreased by more than 8 percent since 2000-01, but professional staffing levels were 3 percent higher in 2014-15. Schools on Long Island also had more professional staff and fewer pupils in 2014-15 than in 2000-01.

As shown below, upstate schools experienced much larger enrollment decreases—and also shed staff. But even upstate, the number of professional staffers decreased at just over half the rate at which the number of pupils decreased.

There is also a sharp difference in trends between teachers and other professionals. The number of teachers in downstate districts is down only slightly over 2000-01 levels, and has dropped sharply upstate—yet the number of non-teachers has increased at double-digit rates in every region.

What is the right ratio of teachers and non-teaching professionals to students? The data do not immediately suggest a correct answer—but it’s one that should be answered as lawmakers try to understand the true nature of the funding crisis claimed by many school leaders.

k12-2016-table1-4485617

As student enrollment declined and school staffing rose and fell between 2000-01 and 2014-15, median salaries for classroom teachers increased by more than 40 percent. The growth continued even after school finances were hit by shockwaves of the Great Recession, which officially began in late 2007, and the global financial crisis, which set off a near panic on Wall Street in the fall of 2008.

From 2008-09 to 2014-15, the statewide median teacher salary rose 13 percent to $75,115.

k12-2016-fig2-6836813

Salaries vary by region, reflecting disparities in wealth and living costs between upstate and downstate. As shown below, the medians for teachers on Long Island and in the Mid-Hudson Region have reached the six-figure level.

k12-2016-fig3-1938728

All regions saw their median salaries increase since 2008-09, when staffing levels began declining. The smallest increase was observed in New York City, where the median salary increased 9 percent during the six-year period. At the same time, Long Island’s median teacher salary grew by 24 percent, the highest rate of any region.

Schools reduced headcounts through attrition by not hiring replacements for teachers who retired or left for other reasons, and by conducting layoffs subject to union “last in, first out” rules that effectively targeted younger teachers. As a result, SED data show, the median experience level of teachers statewide rose after the recession began to strain budgets. Under most teacher contracts, a few added years of experience automatically translate into a significant salary boost, even when contracts have expired and base salaries are frozen. The extent of those increases is illustrated in Table 2, below.

k12-2016-table2-3581948

The growth in pay added further to the rising cost of pensions for public educators. From 2008-09 to 2014-15, taxpayer-funded employer contributions to the New York State Teachers Retirement System (TRS) more than doubled, to $2.6 billion from $1.1 billion, while contributions to the New York City TRS rose to $3.3 billion from $2.3 billion.4

Conclusion

The full extent of the continuing rise in school spending since the recession was not inevitable or unavoidable. It was the result of (a) increasing teacher compensation costs driven largely by automatic pay raises, and (b) continued relatively high levels of staffing, relative to enrollment, especially in non-teaching titles. State law clearly is a major factor in the first trend, while the second needs to be more closely examined.

Endnotes

  1. “Board of Regents Recommends $2.4 Billion School Aid Increase to Provide Additional Funding for Districts and Board Priorities,” http://www.nysed.gov/news/2016/board-regents-recommends-24-billion-school-aid-increase-provide-additional-funding
  2. The data are reported to SED by each school district.
  3. E.J. McMahon and Terry O’Neil, Triborough Trouble, Empire Center for Public Policy, January 2012
  4. While the two retirement systems also cover some college faculty, their costs mainly reflect pensions for teachers and other K-12 professional employees.

About the Author

Ken Girardin

Ken Girardin is the Empire Center’s Director of Strategic Initiatives.

Read more by Ken Girardin

You may also like

What Happens If Teachers Go On Strike?

New York’s largest teachers union this summer threatened to go on strike rather than allow schools to reopen for in-person classes—despite months of preparation by officials and a state law that prohibits union work stoppages. Read More

More Spending, Fewer Kids: Mapping NY School Budget Proposals

New York school districts are seeking voter approval of budgets that would raise their per-pupil spending by an average of more than four times the projected inflation rate. Most districts have proposed property tax hikes as high as the maximum allowed without supermajority overrides under the tax cap law. Read More

Excelsior Illusion

NY's Excelsior Scholarship program is regressive and wasteful Read More

New York public school enrollment: back to early 1990s, and still falling

When public schools across the Empire State open their doors for school year 2019-20, pupil enrollment will be at its lowest level in at least 30 years. Read More

Tax cap offers strongest shield to NY’s poorest school districts

Over the past seven years, New York’s cap on local property tax levies has generated billions of dollars in savings for homeowners and businesses, compared to previous trends. The cap has been especially effective in restraining school property taxes, which have long been the largest and fastest-growing component of New York’s tax burden. Read More

New York public school enrollment: back to 1989-90 levels, and still falling

When public schools across the Empire State open their doors for 2018-19, pupil enrollment will be at its lowest level in nearly 30 years. Read More

School Districts Pushing the Limit, 2018-19

Nearly half of the 669 school districts seeking voter approval for budgets on Tuesday, May 15 are presenting spending plans that would increase property taxes as high as the 2011 property tax cap law allows, according to an analysis released today by the Empire Center for Public Policy. Read More

Rebooting Smart Schools

The Smart Schools grant-making process has been sluggish and haphazard, reflecting the program’s overly broad standards and goals. Read More

Subscribe

Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130
E-Mail: info@empirecenter.org

About

The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.