official-gottfried-211x300-2446356House Republicans took justifiable heat for passing their Obamacare replacement bill so hastily, without full public hearings or an up-to-date analysis by the Congressional Budget Office.

But that process looked like a model of cautious deliberation next to the Assembly’s handling of the New York Health Act, which would establish a statewide single-payer plan.

The bill, sponsored by longtime Assembly Health Chairman Richard Gottfried of Manhattan (photo), would seek to end the current health coverage of all 20 million New Yorkers and enroll everyone into a single plan managed by Albany and paid for by taxpayers – at a cost of tens, if not hundreds, of billions of dollars. The consequences within state borders would far outstrip anything being debated in Washington.

Yet the Assembly voted 94-46* to approve this massive legislation on Tuesday without having subjected to it to a public hearing since January 2015. And the closest thing to a CBO score available was a two-year-old paper from a University of Massachusetts economist who’s an unabashed promoter of single-payer.

It was hardly the kind of independent, nonpartisan analysis lawmakers should have before moving to upend one-sixth of the state’s economy.

Under Gottfried’s proposal, all New York residents would be automatically and fully covered to see any doctor, go to any hospital, and fill any prescription without paying a dime in premiums, copayments, or deductibles. There would be no more employer-provided benefits, Medicaid and Medicare would be absorbed into the state plan, and private health insurance would be effectively banned.

Despite the massive expansion of coverage, the 2015 paper by UMass economist Gerald Friedman argued that Gottfried’s proposal would result in even bigger savings – supposedly by eliminating insurance administration and negotiating lower drug prices, among other things. Ultimately, Friedman claimed, the state’s overall health spending would shrink by $45 billion.

A close look at those findings shows that they are based on highly dubious assumptions – including a gross overestimate of current administrative costs, and a gross underestimate of administrative costs under a single-payer system.

On Tuesday, though, single-payer supporters in the Assembly cited Friedman’s paper as evidence that they were doing the right thing.

Unfortunately, Albany has no independent, nonpartisan body like the Congressional Budget Office to provide dispassionate analysis and fact-check far-fetched claims.

Even by Friedman’s dubious estimates, the state would need a $92 billion tax hike – much more than doubling the current state tax burden – to offset the private insurance premiums that people would no longer be paying. The real price tag would almost certainly be far higher.

It’s true that other single-payer systems in other countries, such as the United Kingdom and Canada, manage to provide universal coverage at much lower costs than in the United States. However, they accomplish that not simply by cutting out paperwork and drug prices, but by paying far lower amounts to doctors, nurses and hospitals and by limiting expensive care – constraints that go unmentioned by single-payer supporters in Albany.

Gottfried’s bill is not likely to go anywhere in the Republican-led Senate this year. But the Senate version has 30 Democratic cosponsors, which is expected to grow to 31 after a special election this month. That puts it within a single vote – and a governor’s signature – of becoming the law of the state.

*Updated to reflect final vote



About the Author

Bill Hammond

As the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy, Bill Hammond tracks fast-moving developments in New York’s massive health care industry, with a focus on how decisions made in Albany and Washington affect the well-being of patients, providers, taxpayers and the state’s economy.

Read more by Bill Hammond

You may also like

New York Has Widened Its Lead in Per-Capita Spending on Medicaid

New York's per-capita Medicaid spending soared to more than double the nationwide rate in 2018, widening its gap with the other 49 states. Read More

New York’s Medicaid Enrollment Surges to an All-Time High

New York's Medicaid program is growing at its fastest rate in six years, with a quarter-million additional enrollees landing in the safety-net health plan during the first three months of the coronavirus pandemic.  Read More

New York’s Health Premiums Remain Among the Highest in the U.S.

The average cost of New Yorkers' health benefits increased by less than the national average in 2019 but remained among the highest in the U.S., according to recently published federal data. Read More

New York’s Medicaid Roller Coaster Takes an Unusual Turn

The state's Medicaid spending was significantly lower than projected in the first quarter, but that's not necessarily a positive sign for state finances. As shown the chart below, t Read More

Filling in the Blanks of New York’s Coronavirus Pandemic

Because New York was hit with the coronavirus early, before testing was widely available, its official count of infections – at just over 400,000 – vastly understates the scale of its outbreak. Read More

Cuomo Administration Ducks Important Questions on Nursing Homes

A new report from the state Health Department tries to deflect blame for thousands of coronavirus deaths in the state's nursing homes—but undermines its own case by withholding data and engaging in tendentious analysis. Read More

Nursing Home Vacancy Rate Soars, Hinting at a Higher Coronavirus Toll

The vacancy rate in New York's nursing homes has more than doubled since the start of the coronavirus pandemic, suggesting that the death toll among residents may be thousands higher than officially reported. Read More

Unsure of COVID Impact, NY Insurers Roll Dice on Rate Hikes

The health insurance industry's rate applications for 2021, , reveal deep uncertainty about the long-term impact of the coronavirus pandemic on medical costs. Some companies anticip Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.