A newly published study of COVID-19 in nursing homes links larger numbers of employees to higher rates of infection and death for residents – raising fresh doubts about New York’s recently enacted “safe staffing” law.

The nationwide study from Health Affairs, drawing data from more than 7,000 nursing homes from June through September 2020, compared the rates of COVID-19 infection and death to the numbers of employees entering each facility on a daily basis.

Residents in the quarter of homes with the largest number of employees had 92 percent higher infection rates and 133 percent higher mortality rates than homes in the bottom quartile.

The authors said this finding “conforms to expectations from basic principles of epidemiology.”

“In the absence of a robust and rapid testing system to prevent asymptomatic COVID-19-infected staff from coming to work, increases in the number of unique individuals entering a nursing home increase the probability of [skilled nursing facility] residents being exposed to the virus and subsequent outbreaks.”

These findings are being published two months after the state Legislature passed a minimum staffing law that will force most nursing homes to add more employees.

Supporters of the measure pointed to a January report from the office of Attorney General Letitia James, which found a correlation between low staffing and high death rates during the coronavirus pandemic of the previous year.

However, that analysis relied on flawed data. As the report itself showed, the Cuomo administration’s method of counting nursing home deaths – which omitted residents who died after being transferred to hospitals for treatment – left out approximately one-third of the victims. The report also limited its examination to the period before mid-November 2020, and therefore missed thousands more deaths that occurred during a winter wave.

In March, an Empire Center analysis – drawing on more complete data obtained through its successful Freedom of Information lawsuit against the Health Department – cast doubt on the attorney general’s findings.

It found no clear correlation between staff and death rates: homes with a one-star federal rating for staffing had lower death rates than homes with two or three stars, but higher rates than those with four or five stars.

The Empire Center’s report said there was “no basis to believe that regulating staffing levels … would have protected residents from the coronavirus pandemic.”

The Health Affairs study – using more granular data from a larger pool of nursing homes in multiple states – did find a correlation, but in the opposite direction of the one postulated by the attorney general’s office. Its findings suggest that increased staffing might actually be counterproductive, by putting residents in contact with larger numbers of potentially infected individuals.

The authors, recognizing that higher staffing can be beneficial in other ways, argue for a nuanced approach that, for example, limits the use of part-time personnel.

“Our findings do not imply that nursing homes should have lower staffing ratios per resident,” the authors write. “Rather, our findings suggest that when facilities with the same staffing ratios are being compared, nursing homes that can provide those staff hours with fewer unique staff members will be better able to protect their residents from COVID-19.”

Under the new state law, facilities must provide an average of at least 3.5 hours of caregiver time per day resident, including at least 1.1 hours of attention from licensed nurses and 2.2 hours from certified nursing aides.

Industry officials have predicted this policy will increase the use of part-time and temporary personnel – as facilities scramble to backfill for permanent employees who call in sick or go on leave.

This isn’t the only potential unintended consequence. The law could also put pressure on homes to replace higher-trained nurses with lower-trained and less expensive nursing aides.

This is an example of why transparency matters: The Cuomo administration refused to share accurate data on nursing home deaths, which caused the attorney general to produce a flawed analysis, which led the Legislature to pass a problematic statute – and New York’s nursing home residents will face the consequences.

 

About the Author

Bill Hammond

As the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy, Bill Hammond tracks fast-moving developments in New York’s massive health care industry, with a focus on how decisions made in Albany and Washington affect the well-being of patients, providers, taxpayers and the state’s economy.

Read more by Bill Hammond

You may also like

The Health Department takes a big step toward COVID transparency

The state Health Department released a flurry of 20 COVID-related data sets this week, taking its biggest step yet toward full transparency about the state's pandemic response. Read More

When COVID-19 struck, a lot of the state’s pandemic stockpile was out of date

Much of the material in the state's pandemic stockpile had passed its expiration date when the coronavirus crisis struck in March 2020, according to newly released Health Department records. Read More

Sluggish in September: NY job growth still trails U.S.

New York's employment recovery slowed to a near halt in the crucial month of September, falling further behind the national growth rate in the 18th full month since the pandemic hit in March 2020, according to and federal monthly job reports. Read More

The Health Department’s response to a FOIL request for nursing home data triggers 2020 déjà vu

Despite Governor Hochul's promise of transparency, the Health Department keeps responding to requests for COVID data with tactics from the Cuomo administration Read More

Hochul’s Emergency Order Imposes Insurer Restrictions Sought by Hospital Group

Buried in Governor Hochul's emergency order on health-care staffing is a temporary bar against insurance companies challenging claims submitted by hospitals–and an influential hospital association is taking credit. Read More

Home Care Agencies Project Widespread Staffing Shortages in the Next Phase of New York’s Vaccine Mandate

Agencies providing home-based care to elderly and disabled New Yorkers face a large-scale loss of employees when the next phase of the state's vaccine mandate takes effect on Oct. 7, according to a newly released industry s Read More

Remembering the scandal that brought down Health Commissioner Howard Zucker

The resignation of Dr. Howard Zucker as state health commissioner marks the end of a term marred by scandal over his role in managing the coronavirus pandemic. The much-debated compelling nursing homes to admit COVID-positive patients, though it origi Read More

As leaves turn, NY’s post-pandemic recovery still has very far to go

New York was the national epicenter of the pandemic, and Governor Cuomo's "New York State on PAUSE" business shutdowns and other restrictions led, in short order, to the loss of nearly 2 million jobs in the first full month after the infection began spreading in the New York City area. Read More

Subscribe

Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries: Info@EmpireCenter.org

Press Inquiries: Press@EmpireCenter.org

About

The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!