As state lawmakers debate the Medicaid budget during a public health crisis, here are seven things they should keep in mind:

(1) Categorically rejecting any cost-cutting measures because of the coronavirus crisis is unrealistic. The state has seen $10 billion to $15 billion in revenue evaporate almost overnight. Even if lawmakers raise taxes, substantial reductions in spending will be necessary. Allowing Medicaid to keep growing at its current pace would necessitate far deeper cuts to school aid and other programs.


This is an installment in a special series of #NYCoronaVirus chronicles by Empire Center analysts, focused on New York’s state and local policy response to the Coronavirus pandemic.


(2) The extra Medicaid funding from Washington does not come close to filling the gap. Although Senator Chuck Schumer and others have said it would be worth $6 billion per year or more to New York, other estimates (including my own) have put the number between $4 billion and $5 billion. Either way, it’s misleading to use that annualized figure because the aid will be provided on a quarter-to-quarter basis. When the president declares an end to the coronavirus emergency declaration – which everyone hopes will be less than a year from now – the money will quickly stop.

(3) Accepting the aid has downsides. First, it comes with strings attached that would inhibit the state from implementing the recommendations of the Medicaid Redesign Team or other cost-cutting reforms. Governor Cuomo may be overstating the obstacles, but his underlying complaint is valid. The state needs to be able to manage its Medicaid costs in a fiscal crisis, and decisions about the right way to do that should be made in Albany, not Washington.

(4) The second downside is that using temporary aid to paper over a long-term imbalance in Medicaid is dangerous, as Governor Cuomo knows from personal experience. The last time Washington provided extra Medicaid funding, in the aftermath of the Great Recession, it expired on December 31, 2010 – the day before Cuomo took office. The loss of that funding was a major cause of the $10 billion gap he had to close in his first budget.

(5) Although it’s commonly said that Cuomo is trying to “cut” Medicaid by $2.5 billion, it would be more accurate to say that he’s slowing the growth. Even if the full $2.5 billion in savings are enacted into law, state-share spending on Medicaid will still increase by about $1.5 billion, or 6 percent, compared to the budget as originally approved for this year.

(6) None of the measures proposed by the Medicaid Redesign Team would directly impair the coronavirus response, and most of them would not affect hospitals. One proposal, for example, reduces a state subsidy for doctors’ malpractice premiums, which should not be the taxpayers’ responsibility in the first place. The largest number of proposals seek to contain the rapidly rising costs of long-term care, especially non-medical “personal assistance” provided to recipients at home, in some cases by friends and family members. Controlling these costs would free up resources, making it easier for the state to finance its coronavirus response.

(7) In the absence of targeted reforms, the state would have little choice but to resort to across-the-board cuts in payments to providers and health plans – which hurts the efficient and lower-paid caregivers along with the wasteful and higher-paid ones. The Health Department formally warned of that possibility in a notice published in Wednesday’s New York State Register, declaring that it intends to make $2.5 billion in across-the-board cuts unless other savings are found. Paradoxically, this move likely would not jeopardize the state’s ability to draw down federal aid – putting Washington in the position of blocking smarter, more surgical changes in favor of the meat-ax approach.

 

About the Author

Bill Hammond

As the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy, Bill Hammond tracks fast-moving developments in New York’s massive health care industry, with a focus on how decisions made in Albany and Washington affect the well-being of patients, providers, taxpayers and the state’s economy.

Read more by Bill Hammond

You may also like

Medicaid’s Missing Million

The Health Department has been either unable or unwilling to document the eligibility status of almost one million Medicaid recipients, raising further concern about the possibility of large-scale over-enrollment. Read More

New York’s Medicaid Spiral Is Worse Than Hochul Admitted

Although Governor Hochul said last week that the current trajectory of Medicaid spending is "not sustainable," the upward trend is even steeper than she and her budget director have acknowledged. Read More

New York’s Proposed ‘MCO Tax’ Would Generate a Fraction of What Lawmakers Expected

The Hochul administration's proposed "MCO tax" would generate far less than the $4 billion in extra federal aid anticipated by state lawmakers when they approved the concept this spring, according to documents obtained by t Read More

Cuomo’s House Testimony Added New Misinformation about Covid in Nursing Homes

Throughout the scandal over former Governor Andrew Cuomo's handling of Covid-19 in nursing homes, Cuomo and his administration repeatedly spread bad information – misstating how its policies had worked, understating death Read More

Hochul Hides the Specifics of a Looming Tax on Health Insurance

The Hochul administration has requested federal approval for a multibillion-dollar "MCO tax" on health plans without announcing the move or providing details to the public. As by l Read More

Hochul’s CDPAP Overhaul Hands a Costly Win to 1199

Governor Hochul's overhaul of the Consumer Directed Personal Assistance Program reached a milestone Monday when she named a Georgia-based company as the winning bidder to be the program's statewide "fiscal intermediary" – Read More

What Paul Francis Got Wrong About the Empire Center’s Nursing Home Research

In February 2021, the Empire Center published the first independent analysis of the Cuomo's administration much-debated directive ordering Covid-positive patients into nursing homes. The report found that the directive was associated with a statistically significant increase in resident deaths in the homes that admitted the  infected patients. Read More

Internal Cuomo Administration Documents Showed Evidence of Harm from Nursing Home Order

State Health Department documents from June 2020, newly unearthed by congressional investigators, appear to show harmful effects from a controversial order requiring nursing homes to admit Covid-positive patients. Read More