With little advance notice or fanfare, a constitutional amendment (S.1) that would give the Legislature much more power to shape the state budget was reported out of the Senate Finance Committee today. The Assembly version (A.2) was approved back in February, so the measure is now a big step closer to a statewide voter referendum.

When it was first passed last year, proponents said the amendment would put an end to late state budgets by rewriting the state’s basic law to provide for an automatic “contingency” plan when a fiscal year starts without a new budget in place. But on closer inspection, the purported budget “reform” looks like more of a self-interested deform of a law that wasn’t broken to begin with. As explained in this FiscalWatch Memo:

“If enacted, the constitutional and statutory changes sought by the Senate and Assembly would mark a fundamental shift of power in the state Capitol. For the first time since the late 1920s, New York’s Legislature would ultimately have the upper hand in budget disputes with the governor. The result would be less fiscal discipline, higher spending and higher taxes — all without improving the efficiency, transparency or accountability of the state’s much-criticized budget process.”

Last year’s Court of Appeals decision in Silver v. Pataki strongly reaffirmed the Governor’s power, under Article 7 of the state Constitution, to shape appropriations language in a way that cannot be altered by the Legislature. This greatly annoyed legislative leaders, some of whom predicted (inaccurately, as it turned out) that the ruling would make it more difficult for them to pass a budget on time this year.

Since the Legislature just finished passing its first on-time budget in 20 years — proving it could, in fact, get the job done under the existing constitutional framework, despite (or, more likely, because of) the Silver v. Pataki decision — the Senate’s timing may seem strange. But consider this: if approved by the voters, the amendment would give either house of the Legislature the ability to unilaterally veto a governor’s budget merely by doing nothing until the clock ticks past midnight at the end of a fiscal year. That has to be an especially attractive option to a Republican-controlled body looking forward to the possible replacement of a Republican governor with a Democrat (such as Eliot Spitzer) in 2007.

The Finance Committee’s 31-2 vote in favor of the constitutional changes (with Senators Thomas Duane and Ada Smith, both Democrats, casting the only “nays”) advances the resolution to the Senate “first report” calendar. Under normal Senate procedures, it would be ready for floor action in two calendar days — which, for all practical purposes, means early May, after next week’s Passover recess.

About the Author

Tim Hoefer

Tim Hoefer is president & CEO of the Empire Center for Public Policy.

Read more by Tim Hoefer

You may also like

In Pandemic Recovery, New York’s Tax Base Is More Fragile Than Ever

New York's exceptionally wealthy state tax base is also exceptionally fragile, due to its heavy dependence on the highly volatile (and portable) investment-driven incomes of Wall Street workers and fund managers. Read More

Not a Moment Too Soon, Bill de Blasio Is Setting a Good Fiscal Example

After months of flailing, floundering and stalling on desperately needed cuts to New York City's pandemic-ravaged budget, Mayor de Blasio just made a smart and appropriate move to save money—in the process defying one of New York's most powerful government employee unions. Read More

A Federal Emergency Rule Is Inflating New York’s Medicaid Enrollment

Strings attached to federal coronavirus relief funding appear to be inflating New York's Medicaid enrollment – and costs – at a time when the state faces unprecedented deficits. Read More

What a New Jersey “Millionaire Tax” Really Means for New York

Hoping to jumpstart a bandwagon effect, advocates of soak-the-rich tax hike proposals in New York State are hyping a tax increase in New Jersey as evidence that New York needs to do the same. Read More

New York State Has Dug Itself Into Its Deepest Hole On Record

"State's Financial Hole Deepens" is the headline on Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli's press release accompanying the August cash flow report. Read More

On Measuring School Quality, Education Week Misses the Mark

Education Week’s rankings do not measure what counts. New York’s substandard achievement coupled with highest-in-the-nation spending and above-average wealth means that when it comes to school quality, New York fails to pass the mark. Read More

Even After Aid Cut, New York Will Spend Most on Education

If New York was a country in 2016—the most recent year for global education spending data—it would have boasted the highest per pupil expenditure in the world, even after subtracting 20 percent of state aid. Read More

State’s Per-Recipient Medicaid Spending Rises to 3rd Highest in the U.S.

New York's per-recipient Medicaid spending has soared to the nation's third highest rate, a sign of fiscal trouble for one of the state's most important programs. Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130
E-Mail: info@empirecenter.org


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.