calculator-1455206430akk-300x225-7047497A federally mandated state takeover of local Medicaid costs – which some of New York’s representatives in Washington are continuing to push – would likely set up a three-way fiscal tug-of-war between upstate counties, the downstate suburbs, and New York City.

If lawmakers limit the takeover to counties outside the five boroughs, as the proposal provides, this would essentially force city taxpayers to cross-subsidize the rest of the state even more than they already do.

But if lawmakers opt instead for an all-inclusive takeover, New York City would stand to reap a significant windfall at the expense of taxpayers in its surrounding suburbs.

Most upstate taxpayers would save money either way, but their savings would be less if the city is included.

To illustrate the dynamics, the Empire Center crunched the numbers for a Medicaid takeover financed with proceeds of the personal income tax, which is the state’s primary source of revenue. (A takeover financed with sales tax revenue was previously analyzed here and here.)

Using tax data from 2014, we calculated the percentage of the PIT that comes from each of the 57 counties and New York City. We allocated the cost of a Medicaid takeover by those same percentages under two scenarios – with the city carved out and the city carved in – then compared each county’s share to what it currently pays for Medicaid through local taxes.

screen-shot-2017-04-07-at-5-51-03-pm-5478434The results – summarized in a spreadsheet here – show that the taxpayers of New York City would be lopsided losers if they were carved out, paying $936 million more while taxpayers in every other county pay less.

But it city taxpayers were included in the takeover, they would become even more lopsided winners, collectively saving $2.2 billion, while the taxpayers of Suffolk, Nassau, and Westchester pay hundreds of millions more. Also coming out behind, according to this analysis, would be Albany, Columbia, Dutchess, Ontario, Putnam, Rockland, Saratoga, and Tompkins counties.

Losing under either scenario are out-of-state commuters. As non-residents, they currently pay little or none of the local share of Medicaid, but would contribute $371 million under a takeover that excludes New York City, and $1.3 billion under a takeover that includes the city.

Driving these wild swings is New York City’s unique combination of concentrated wealth and concentrated poverty. With 43 percent of the state’s population, it contributes about 50 percent of the taxes collected from state residents. At the same time, it accounts for 70 percent of state Medicaid spending – and its local share of the Medicaid budget has been correspondingly high.

To be clear, this analysis looks at the gains and losses for taxpayers in each jurisdiction as a group. The Medicaid takeover would also create winners and losers within each county as local property taxes would presumably decline and state-imposed taxes would increase.

Supporters of the federal takeover legislation – which was conceived by Representative John Faso (R-Kinderhook) and cosponsored by most other Republicans in the New York delegation – argue that the takeover can and should be implemented by cutting spending rather than hiking taxes.

They note that the non-New York City local share, at $2.3 billion, represents 1.5 percent of the state budget. If the city were included, however, the cost of the takeover – and the challenge of finding offsetting savings in the state budget – would more than triple, to $7.6 billion.

 

About the Author

Bill Hammond

As the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy, Bill Hammond tracks fast-moving developments in New York’s massive health care industry, with a focus on how decisions made in Albany and Washington affect the well-being of patients, providers, taxpayers and the state’s economy.

Read more by Bill Hammond

You may also like

What a New Jersey “Millionaire Tax” Really Means for New York

Hoping to jumpstart a bandwagon effect, advocates of soak-the-rich tax hike proposals in New York State are hyping a tax increase in New Jersey as evidence that New York needs to do the same. Read More

Even After Aid Cut, New York Will Spend Most on Education

If New York was a country in 2016—the most recent year for global education spending data—it would have boasted the highest per pupil expenditure in the world, even after subtracting 20 percent of state aid. Read More

State’s Per-Recipient Medicaid Spending Rises to 3rd Highest in the U.S.

New York's per-recipient Medicaid spending has soared to the nation's third highest rate, a sign of fiscal trouble for one of the state's most important programs. Read More

New York Medicaid Spending Is Projected to Jump 6% in Fiscal Year 2021 (UPDATED)

Despite a round of cost-cutting this spring, New York's Medicaid spending is on track to jump by 6 percent this year thanks to a massive influx of federal aid. Read More

New York Has Widened Its Lead in Per-Capita Spending on Medicaid

New York's per-capita Medicaid spending soared to more than double the nationwide rate in 2018, widening its gap with the other 49 states. Read More

New York’s Medicaid Enrollment Surges to an All-Time High

New York's Medicaid program is growing at its fastest rate in six years, with a quarter-million additional enrollees landing in the safety-net health plan during the first three months of the coronavirus pandemic.  Read More

New York’s Medicaid Roller Coaster Takes an Unusual Turn

The state's Medicaid spending was significantly lower than projected in the first quarter, but that's not necessarily a positive sign for state finances. Read More

More fiscal turmoil for Medicaid

In a sign of pandemic-related strain on state finances, the Cuomo administration is postponing a series of multi-billion-dollar Medicaid payments over the next three months. Read More

Subscribe

Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130
E-Mail: info@empirecenter.org

About

The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.