Governor David Paterson has proposed legislation to implement a cap on school property tax levies in New York State. His original tax cap bill was passed by the state Senate in August 2008, but died in the state Assembly. Paterson’s latest tax cap proposal was submitted to the Legislature on July 30, 2010.

As recommended by the governor’s Commission on Real Property Tax Relief, the cap would limit the growth in school property tax levies to 4 percent or to 120 percent of the rate of inflation, whichever is less.

Key provisions of the new tax limitation would include the following:

  • Property taxes generated by new construction would be excluded from the cap, but there would be no other exclusions or loopholes.
  • District proposals to “override” the cap in any given year would require the approval of at least 55 percent of the district’s voters.
  • District residents also could petition school boards for a referendum to “underride the cap.”
  • Capital construction projects would continue to require voter approval, and debt service payments on voter-approved debt would not be subject to the cap.

The Commission’s preliminary report contains a number of other recommendations for curbing the growth in school expenses and for reforming New York’s property tax system — including a change in state Taylor Law provisions that now allow teachers to receive automatic pay increases even in the absence of a new union contract. However, Paterson and the Commission chairman, Nassau County Executive Thomas Suozzi, agreed that the cap needed to take precedence over all other reforms. “Enough is enough–we have to implement a property tax cap now,” Paterson said. The press release for the governor’s June 3 announcement can be found here.

Resources

The Empire Center submitted a white paper to the commission in support of a cap. For a two-page summary of the case for a tax cap, click here.

The need for a property tax cap, the best model for such a cap, and the flaws with other approaches to “property tax relief” in New York have been extensively discussed by E.J. McMahon, director of the Empire Center and senior fellow for tax and budgetary studies at the Manhattan Institute, in a series of articles, memos, presentations and legislative testimony over the past few years. Links to that material follow, in reverse chronological order:

An op-ed article in support of the cap by John J. Faso, the defeated 2006 Republican gubernatorial candidate, can be found here.

Both of the leading major-party candidates for governor have endorsed broad, low property tax caps. Attorney General Andrew Cuomo, the Democratic nominee, is calling for a 2 percent cap on all property tax levies.  Former U.S. Rep. Rick Lazio, the official Republican nominee, has proposed a 2.5 percent cap. Significantly, both Cuomo and Lazio say they would not allow for automatic exceptions to the cap other than new construction and voter-approved capital expenditures. Both would also permit voter override and under-ride of the cap.

Background

Governor Eliot Spitzer first came out for capping school taxes in his 2008 State of the State address. “A tax cap is a blunt instrument, but it forces hard choices and discipline when nothing else works,” Spitzer said — a remark repeated by Paterson when he endorsed the commission’s findings six months later.

Paterson’s endorsement of the Suozzi Commission recommendations has given new impetus to prospects for a property tax cap in New York. However, this is not the first time cap has been seriously floated by state officials.

Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver proposed a cap on all local property taxes in 1995, as announced in this press release issued by the speaker’s office on March 14 of that year. Known as the Real Property Tax Limitation Act, the bill (A.6171 of 1995-96) passed the Assembly but was never taken up by the Senate.

Governor Pataki subsequently proposed a cap on school tax levies as part of his original STAR (School Tax Relief) program in 1997. In the face of strong opposition from the state’s largest teachers’ union, Pataki agreed to remove the cap provision from the final STAR bill before it was enacted.

A school property tax cap similar to the one embraced by the Suozzi Commission was first proposed in legislation introduced in 2007 and reintroduced in 2009 by a group of Assembly Republicans. The lead sponsor of the measure is Assemblyman Michael J. Fitzpatrick (R-C-I, Smithtown).

About the Author

Tim Hoefer

Tim Hoefer is president & CEO of the Empire Center for Public Policy.

Read more by Tim Hoefer

You may also like

More Spending, Fewer Kids: Mapping NY School Budget Proposals

New York school districts are seeking voter approval of budgets that would raise their per-pupil spending by an average of more than four times the projected inflation rate. Most districts have proposed property tax hikes as high as the maximum allowed without supermajority overrides under the tax cap law. Read More

Benchmarking New York

New York State residents pay some of the highest local taxes in the nation. To help New Yorkers compare some of the basic fiscal measures for local governments, the Empire Center for Public Policy continues to calculate effective property tax rates and per-capita values for the spending, debt and tax levels of counties, cities, towns, villages and school districts throughout the state, excluding only New York City. Read More

What They Make 2018-19

Compare the average salaries and head-counts of county and municipal government employees across New York State. Read More

Tax cap offers strongest shield to NY’s poorest school districts

Over the past seven years, New York’s cap on local property tax levies has generated billions of dollars in savings for homeowners and businesses, compared to previous trends. The cap has been especially effective in restraining school property taxes, which have long been the largest and fastest-growing component of New York’s tax burden. Read More

Benchmarking New York

Compare the taxes, spending and debt of local governments across New York State. Read More

What They Make 2017-18

Local government is a labor-intensive business, and employee compensation is the single biggest element of most municipal budgets. Read More

Shifting Shares

This issue brief explores the financial considerations and policy challenges associated with eliminating the local Medicaid share and reviews the options for implementing a state takeover. Read More

Local New York Property Taxes Ranked by Empire Center

Benchmarking NY uses data from the state comptroller’s office to calculate effective tax rates–combined county, municipal and school taxes as a percent of market value–for thousands of localities across the state during 2017, excluding only New York City and Nassau County. Read More

Subscribe

Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130
E-Mail: info@empirecenter.org

About

The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.