Back in 2005, a Suffolk County grand jury was convened to investigate waste, fraud and fiscal mismanagement in Suffolk’s public schools. Among its key findings was “an abject lack of transparency” regarding the area where school districts spend the vast bulk of their funds: salaries and benefits.

“Abject” the lack of transparency was — and is. But school districts are hardly unique in this. Long Island‘s county and municipal governments, like their counterparts across New York, also routinely hide from the public important details of employee compensation and tentative labor contracts.

Latest case in point: Suffolk County’s proposed contract with the Police Benevolent Association.

County Executive Steve Bellone first announced the deal on Aug. 2, yet it was only last Friday, five weeks later, that he got around to making public his memorandum of agreement with the union, whose members are the biggest locally funded cost center in a deficit-ridden county budget.

Why the delay? In a prepared statement, Bellone’s office said the memo and a financial impact statement “were released when everything had been reviewed by legal departments to ensure that all provisions in the [agreement] were characterized appropriately and accurately,” and that “edits” had been made “to accurately reflect negotiated terms.”

Huh? The original agreement was initialed on July 31 by Bellone’s acting director of labor relations, Paul J. Margiotta — who also happens to be chief deputy county attorney. It still needed a monthlong legal review? And if a financial impact analysis wasn’t done until last week, why did Bellone’s Aug. 2 news release claim the deal made “historic progress in saving hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars”?

While the original tentative contract stretched to 2020, the final version guarantees current cops an average raise of 3 percent a year through 2018. It also includes one more late-breaking concession to the union: a provision letting the PBA reopen wage talks if inflation in any year tops 5 percent.

The cops also won a broad no-layoff guarantee and a “unit work” provision assuring them that no additional jobs assigned to PBA members will be shifted to less expensive employees. The cops will not only regain their coveted highway patrol slots from the county’s cheaper sheriff’s deputies — in the future, any helicopter pilots hired by the county must be PBA members.

As I first noted in a column last month, the proposed agreement also stipulates that the no-layoff pledge and unit work provision must be treated as “mandatory subjects” of negotiation in future. This would have the effect of giving the PBA virtually ironclad job security for generations to come.

Although the contract will add at least $200 million to the county’s costs by 2018, the executive can point to a two-and-a-half-year wage freeze, to a less expensive pay scale for new hires, and to the union’s agreement to require new officers to kick in a token 15 percent of their health insurance premiums. Bellone can argue that these gains, unlikely had the pact gone to arbitration, were worth the concessions he made to the PBA.

Even now, the information released by the county executive falls short of demonstrating conclusively that this is a good deal. But if he thinks he isn’t getting enough credit for the positives, he has only himself to blame. By withholding crucial details for more than a month, then trying to rush the pact to a vote in the county legislature, he has given the impression that he had something to hide.

Bellone should dig out that old grand jury report and take to heart its recommendations for improving government transparency. It’s never too late to let the sun shine in.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

NY officials covered up more than just nursing-home deaths

Gov. Cuomo’s coverup of nursing-home deaths revealed the stunning lengths to which he and his staff go to keep damning information from the public. But few New Yorkers may realize that such behavior is actually standard operating procedure throughout mu Read More

Cuomo’s Buffalo Billion was beyond corrupt

The overarching scandal here wasn’t bid-rigging or the pay-to-play pattern in the developers’ contributions to the governor’s reelection campaign. At the root was a simply awful public policy — corporate welfare on steroids — that neither Cuomo nor most of his critics have definitively renounced, even now. Read More

Bad state policy drives bad behavior

The newly revealed federal probe of Crystal Run Healthcare, a large doctors group in the Hudson Valley, fits a common pattern with Albany scandals: It's not just about bad behavior but also bad policy. Read More

Corruption cauldron: To fix Albany — term limits

The corruption case against Speaker Sheldon Silver has prompted more calls for reform of the Legislature. Read More

Sticking New York with unaffordable debt

Skyrocketing public-pension obligations have generated concern across the country, especially in the wake of high-profile bankruptcies of Detroit and Stockton, Calif. In New York, an even larger burden looms in the form of lifetime health-insurance coverage promised to state and local government employees. Yet at least one house of the Legislature is considering a bill that would effectively prevent any effort to reduce this unaffordable debt. Read More

Freedom of Information Law needs to catch up to technology advances

In total, the state's multiple levels of government burn through more than $190 billion a year from their own revenue sources, mainly taxes. Another $60 billion comes the federal government - which has its own claim on our wallets. But where does it all go? Thanks to the digital revolution, anyone with access to the Internet can begin to find some answers to that question. Read More

The ‘death tax’ hurts state’s edge

New York is now one of only 14 states still imposing any tax on estates — the cash, land, houses, financial assets and other property left by deceased residents. The state estate tax, also called the "death tax," is triggered once assets exceed $1 million. By contrast, the federal government only taxes estates worth more than $5.34 million, a figure that will rise with inflation every year. Read More

End unnecessary barriers to state growth

Major residential, commercial and industrial developments throughout the country are subject to an array of federal and state laws designed to protect the environment. They're buttressed nearly everywhere by local land-use regulations addressing the community impacts of such projects. Read More