At a Crain’s breakfast this morning, City Comptroller (and 2009 mayoral candidate) Bill Thompson acknowledged a vital truth. “Budget growth has lately been out of balance with the growth of our local economy. Had we started to tie city spending to [gross city product] growth 10 years ago, my office estimates that the city would have spent roughly $8.5 billion less last year.”

It’s not a good idea to tie spending to gross city product, a highly volatile measure that, on average during the Bloomberg era, has exceeded inflation by about 2 percentage points.

However, Thompson’s basic point seems to be that New York City spends way too much money — more than 10 percent too much annually, in fact, on a $60 billion budget. He’s certainly right. During the Bloomberg era, city-funded spending has far eclipsed inflation, as the below graph shows.

NYC inflation-adjusted spending, 1984 – present

It would be nice to hear the comptroller pledge, if elected mayor, to keep future spending to inflation and population growth.

But how to do that?

Practically speaking, the only way to do it is to start reforming the long-term structural problems in the budget: public-sector pensions and health benefits, Medicaid, and debt service, all of which now account for 40 percent of spending.

Even modest state-city reforms here — like asking all public employees to pay just 10 percent of their health-care premiums, increasing retirement ages for new public employees, or paring just 10 percent from bloated, patronage-rich, inefficient Medicaid costs — would save hundreds of millions of dollars a year, every year, starting in just a few years.

While Thompson did say that he wants to “continue to work in collaboration with our partners in the labor movement to achieve greater productivity gains,” he did not mention these specific costs or goals.

Further, Thompson acknowledged that “while the financial industry will always be a critical part of our city’s growth and prosperity, we are experiencing a seismic shift in our local economy.” It’s good to hear that Thompson does not think Wall Street’s turmoil is a short-term cyclical blip. Recognizing the scope of the problem — that the financial industry may shrink indefinitely — is the first step to solving it.

Thompson rightly notes that New York’s economy must diversify.

But it would be wonderful to hear an elected city official acknowledge that the private-sector economy can’t diversify because business and income taxes in both the city and state are just too darned high, the highest in the nation and in the region.

Start-up firms, small firms, and even big firms in industries that don’t make billions of dollars making up pretend mortgage-backed securities simply can’t afford to locate here.

Thompson should acknowledge that cutting taxes across the board — or, at the very least in this fiscal crisis, not raising them — would go a long way to attract non-financial firms and people. New businesses may already be attracted in the coming years by falling residential and commercial real-estate prices, and lower taxes would be a strong signal that we want them.

Thompson could also apply such broad-based cuts to the 4 percent unincorporated business tax (UBT), which he flagged in his speech, correctly, as confusing and too far-reaching. This tax, as Thompson noted, falls on independent workers and small firms, which could be the future of New York as we move away from huge investment banks.

Still, though, Thompson’s comment about “excess spending” was a breakthrough, and something almost never, if ever, heard from elected officials in New York City. And as the comptroller’s only mention of a tax was to criticize one — the UBT — the speech was an improvement over City Council Speaker Chris Quinn’s recent remarks.

You may also like

Hochul’s ‘Straight Talk’ on Medicaid Isn’t Straight Enough

Arguably the biggest Medicaid news in Governor Hochul's budget presentation was about the current fiscal year, not the next one: The state-run health plan is running substantially over budget. Read More

New York’s Medicaid Spending Is Running Billions Over Budget

New York's Medicaid program ran billions of dollars over budget during the first half of the fiscal year, adding to signs of a brewing fiscal crisis in Albany. According to the fro Read More

As migrants flow to NY, so does red ink 

The influx of foreign migrants to New York could cost the state $4.5 billion more than expected next year, Governor Hochul today warned.  Read More

At mid-year, NY still far below most states in pandemic jobs recovery

New York has added private-sector jobs in all but three of the 38 months since the COVID-19 outbreak of March 2020—but the Empire State remains below its pre-pandemic employment level and continues to trail the national recovery. On a seasonally adju Read More

The Bill Arrives: NY Faces $9B Budget Gap Next Year 

New York’s outyear budget gaps, the shortfall between planned state expenses and state tax receipts over the next three years, has exploded to more than $36 billion, just-released documents show.  Read More

NY school spending again led US, hitting all-time high in 2020-21

Public elementary and secondary school spending in New York rose to $26,571 per pupil in 2020-21, according to the latest Census Bureau data Read More

A Tale of Two Levies

New York school districts are getting record levels of state aid. But how many are using it to cut taxes? Read More

Albany’s Belated Budget Binge 

State lawmakers have begun passing the bills necessary to implement the state budget for the fiscal year that began April 1. Read More