troy-150x150-8174373The raw politics behind giveaways to building trade unions were on display last week in Troy, a city outside Albany.

The Troy City Council on October 3 voted unanimously to require contractors bidding on projects priced at more than $100,000 to have “apprenticeship agreements” with a state-approved apprenticeship program covering the trades involved on the project. That state approval requires the program sponsors to have a “permanent facility located in New York State,” among other things, at which workers get structured training. The resolution now heads to Troy Mayor Patrick Madden for his signature or veto.

Local governments and school districts can require apprenticeship agreements under a 2001 law (Labor Law section 816-b)—which was passed after state courts struck down local apprenticeship laws on the basis that they undermined the public interest served by competitive bidding. Troy in 2014 enacted a similar albeit looser requirement, but let it sunset two years later.

Proponents of the new measure (page 197), nearly all from local trade unions, argued ahead of last Thursday’s meeting that apprenticeship programs create “middle-class career opportunities for local residents” and “stimulate local economies and grow communities.”

Both trade unions and non-union contractors maintain apprenticeship programs, but apprenticeship mandates are a thinly-veiled mechanism for steering work to local building trade unions. The mandates play to the differences in business models at work in union and non-union construction companies. Union contractors tend to hire workers through area union halls as needed for each job, while non-union contractors tend to have a permanent workforce of their own employees. Under apprenticeship laws, out-of-state contractors (scorned by at least one speaker during public comments) can’t bring their own workers to jobs unless they make an agreement with someone who operates a local apprenticeship program—like a local trade union—and in exchange hire part of their workforce from their union hall.

Apprenticeship mandates aren’t new. What makes Troy’s noteworthy is just how transactional it was.

For one thing, the process was questionable. Troy City Council rules adopted last year say the city’s corporation counsel shall draft “all proposed local laws, ordinances and resolutions,” and that such requests must be submitted “no later than four weeks” before the meeting at which the measure is to be voted on. The text of the apprenticeship law, however, didn’t reach council members until about a week before.

Why the rush?

The measure was sponsored by Republican Council President Carmella Mantello and Democratic Councilmember David Bissember, who are facing off for the council presidency in next month’s general election. The October 3 meeting, as it happens, was the last scheduled council meeting before Election Day.

And the resolution text wasn’t written by the city’s Mantello, who presided over the meeting and placed the measure on the agenda, acknowledged that the Greater Capital Region Building & Construction Trades Council, an umbrella group of 14 trade unions, wrote the resolution—and the memorandum of support that was sent to council members.

And on Monday, just four days after the vote, Mantello posted on Twitter that she had won the group’s endorsement.

Learning nothing

Artificially reducing the pool of eligible bidders on a project tends to increase the cost.

But Jeff Stark, president of the Greater Capital Region Building & Construction Trades Council, told council members the measure is “not going to cost you money.”

That’s a difficult claim to make when a policy is designed to disqualify bidders. But he was also forthright about why his group made Troy’s apprenticeship law a priority.

Stark said building trade leaders are always concerned about “having a good supply of work,” and noted how apprenticeship requirements and project labor agreements steer work to union halls.

“We’re always looking for help,” he said.

Unfortunately for taxpayers, so are political candidates.

You may also like

Thanks to Unions, NYC’s School Reopening Deal Was Costly and Educationally Hazardous

New York City schools reopened this fall under terms dictated by the city's teacher and principal unions. Now, as city schools close -- once more at the unions' behest -- the city is left with thousands of extra teachers hi Read More

De Blasio’s (Apparent) Good Move Dissolves Into Phony “Savings”

Late Thursday, as hailed in this space, Mayor de Blasio finally made a decisive move—or at least seemed to make a move—in the direction of actually saving some money on labor costs by getting tough with a powerful (and powerfully self-entitled) municipal union. Read More

Cahill Charges Are An Indictment Of Cuomo’s Policies

Yesterday’s indictment of the state’s top construction union official on federal corruption charges raises a big question: if private companies are paying bribes to avoid having to work with certain construction unions, why is Governor Cuomo insisting that the state keep doing it? Read More

Cuomo’s ‘Reinvent Policing’ Order Dodges Confrontation with Police Unions

Governor Cuomo has ordered local governments to “reinvent” their police departments or risk losing state and federal funding, but the back-up guidance from Cuomo's office sets up an arduous process that likely will conflict with other parts of state law. To put it plainly, the guidance shows the state’s “New York Tough” governor won’t take on its police unions. Read More

Lawmakers Look To Dump More Public Cash On Teamsters

State lawmakers this week moved to make public construction more expensive in a bid to steer work to one of New York’s struggling construction unions. Read More

Big Apple Pols Have Played Both Sides in NYPD Fight

New York City’s police department has come under criticism in recent days, with some city officials saying NYPD funding should be reduced. But many of the same New York City Council members parroting calls to “defund” the NYPD were just a year ago pushing Mayor Bill de Blasio to give city cops a big pay hike. It’s a reminder that New York’s elected officials, no matter how principled, routinely don’t want to say “no” to public-sector unions. Read More

New York lawmakers have sought to weaken police discipline

In the wake of George Floyd's death under a kneeling Minneapolis police officer, some New York State lawmakers are renewing calls for legislation designed to uncover police disciplinary records. But less than a year ago, state senators in both parties voted in favor of union-backed legislation that would make it harder to fire New York police officers credibly accused of using excessive force or other offenses. Read More

Union pay remains non-“prevailing”

Barely one in five private construction workers in New York State was covered by a union contract last year, according to newly released statistics that call into question a state public works "prevailing wage" mandate that assumes 30 percent union coverage of building trades occupations across New York. Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100

General Inquiries:

Press Inquiries:


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!