A state court judge at a hearing this morning will consider whether to interfere with New York City authority over its own budget by ordering a preliminary injunction that ices a portion of Gotham’s recently enacted FY 23 city budget. In issuing a temporary restraining order (TRO) last week, Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Lyle Frank forestalled $215 million in education spending reductions scheduled to occur under the $101.1 billion budget agreement between Mayor Eric Adams and the City Council, which adopted the measure in a 44-6 vote on June 13 

In lieu of the cuts, the Court decreed that the education funding levels for all city schools this Fall temporarily remain at the levels set under last year’s budget. 

 The reductions in dispute represent less than one percent of the city’s total education spending. They are derived from a formula-driven, enrollment-based calculation. Gotham’s public-school student population has fallen at least eight percent since the pandemic’s onset — and the city projects a further decline this fall. The past few budget cycles, city schools that lost students were spared the reductions the city’s Fair Student Funding formula would otherwise yield. With no enrollment reversal in sight, Mayor Adams put attenuated cuts in his February blueprint and continued advocating for them in the ensuing months. 

The proposed cuts were a paramount issue in the weeks and days preceding the budget vote, with the United Federation of Teachers (UFT), which represents Gotham educators, publicizing specific projections of the funding reductions that would occur at individual city schools. 

Nevertheless, Adams prevailed upon the Council to swallow cuts within a final budget package that spent more overall than his original offer. 

In the aftermath, progressive Council members began to express voter’s remorse. On July 18, in an act of self-flagellation, several members publicly expressed great regret for voting in favor of the budget, due to the education funding cuts.   

Shortly thereafter, Justice Frank’s TRO was handed down, in response to a plea from a small group of plaintiffs petitioning on behalf of parents and teachers.  

The slim legal reed the TRO relies on is a provision within Section 2590(g) of the state Education Law requiring the City’s Panel for Education Policy (PEP), i.e., the city board of education, to adopt the Education Department’s estimated budget before it goes to the City Council. The ministerial nature of the PEP vote is best evidenced by the fact that it is routinely dispensed with; in seven of the past nine prior budget cycles, the PEP failed to approve the education budget in advance of the Council vote. In each instance, the Education Chancellor issued an emergency declaration waiving its necessity. He did so again this year. 

Where were the challenges to the city education budget during all those prior years of PEP noncompliance? There were none, in part because there’s nothing in law attaching any consequences to the PEP’s failure to bless the education proposal.  

For better or worse, few of the numerous budget process procedural requirements written into state law carry any sort of penalty for noncompliance. It’s not surprising then, that they aren’t always followed to the letter.  

That shouldn’t be a pretext for judges to rewrite budgets adopted by elected representatives. 

You may also like

Don’t Tell The Grownups: NY Still Hiding State Test Scores

State education officials are refusing to release the results of federally required assessments in grades 3 through 8, deliberately keeping parents and taxpayers in the dark—not only about how New York’s public schools performed, but also about how that performance was measured. Read More

What You Should Know: NY’s changing graduation requirements

Months after lowering the scores to pass state assessment exams, New York education officials are considering eliminating the Regents diploma. Read More

State Drags Out Test Mess

The New York State Education Department (SED) was proud to announce this week that they have lifted the embargo on last year’s state test scores in reading and math. Does this mean the public gets to see them now?  Read More

Hochul Signals Tough Budget Ahead

Governor Hochul’s administration this week urged agency heads to keep their budgets flat next year. It's the most serious acknowledgement yet of state government’s looming financial shortfall. Read More

Back to School: New York Style

Class is in session across the state, and things are messy (especially in New York City).  Read More

Where are New York’s Test Results?

For the second year in a row, New York parents will receive their back-to-school shopping lists before their students' results on state assessments. and Read More

Migrants, Medicaid, and More: NY’s Widening Budget Gap

The multi-billion-dollar gap Governor Hochul and the Legislature must confront in next year’s state budget appears to be growing larger.  Read More

School’s Out and Session’s Out – What Happened this Year?

The 2022-23 school year and legislative session have come to a close—what happened? The following summary outlines key legislative changes affecting education in New York.   New York ranks #1 in spending. Read More