The Mercatus Center at George Mason University has released its “Freedom in the 50 States” index. New York is dead last overall, and last, too, on economic and fiscal freedom.

The report, by William Ruger of Texas State University and Jason Sorens at the University of Buffalo (SUNY), cites the Empire State’s taxes — “the highest … in the country” — as well as high spending, high debt, strict gun and tobacco laws, tough homeschooling regulations, “highly regulated” motorists, market-killing criteria for individual health insurance, and “rampant and unchecked” eminent-domain abuse.

Mercatus nails it on eminent-domain, taxes, debt, health insurance, and spending. They’ve probably got a good point on home-schooling, too.

Some of the measures, though, are head-scratchers, particularly on transit and transportation, an important topic in a dense region.

Consider what Mercatus says on auto regulations:

Bicycle and motorcycle-helmet laws are … restrictions that impose undue costs (though any harm that comes to people from not wearing helmets should be fully internalized by the individuals in question). Mandatory automotive personal-injury and underinsured driver insurance are paternalistic restrictions on individual choice. Open-container bans are included as a minor nuisance (we support drunk driving laws, however), and cell-phone driving bans are also included.

Yeah, sure, in theory, people should be able to decide whether or not to wear a motorcycle helmet, as long as in deciding not to, they implicitly promise never to ask for a dime in state medical care, or safety-net payments for lost work hours, etc.

Problem is, though, that such a rule is impossible to enforce in a compassionate society. Once someone’s medical insurance and personal savings run out — as they do quickly with a severe brain injury — the rest of us end up paying.

Many freedom-loving voters, too, likely would prefer to err on the side of thinking that someone driving with an open bottle of vodka in her car while yammering on a cellphone poses a risk to other drivers and pedestrians — a risk that outweighs any freedom lost in curtailing such behaviors.

No, the laws that govern such behavior aren’t perfect, but in the case, perfection is the enemy of the good enough.

Mercatus’s New York policy recommendations are as follows:

  • “legalize same-sex partnerships of some kind”
  • “cut spending in all the areas mentioned above” (basically, everywhere)
  • “privatize (and rate-regulate) transit systems”
  • “cut taxes across the board”
  • “reduce the burdensome testing, notification, and recordkeeping requirements on homeschoolers.”

The transit suggestion is impractical. “Transit systems” presumably means the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), which provides service in and surrounding New York City. The MTA could surely do some experimentation with competitive contracting of bus services, station maintenance, and the like, and see if it can reduce costs. But “privatizing” subway and rail service would be a nightmare. No reputable private operator would take the risk of backstopping the condition of New York’s legacy subway and rail assets as well as the risk of committing to 24-hour service, something that New York demands. Privatizing rail has not worked well in Britain (at least twice).

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

MTA’s Casino Funding Takes Voters For A Ride

As the Legislature prepares to authorize new downstate casinos, some voters who supported the amendment are discovering they came up snake-eyes. Read More

New York’s Hospital Industry Ranks Near the Bottom of Two Quality Report Cards

New York's hospitals remain near the bottom of two quality report cards. The state's hospitals received the lowest rate of any state except Nevada and DC. Read More

MTA: Overtime down, take our word for it

Every year for over a decade, the Empire Center has submitted Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) requests to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority for the payrolls of MTA corporate subsidiaries. And in almost every one o Read More

As a Supreme Court Ruling Loomed, Cuomo Bent His Own Rules on COVID ‘Clusters’

In the midst of the constitutional showdown over his pandemic policies, Governor Cuomo made changes to a disputed Brooklyn 'cluster zone' that seemed to contradict his own declared guidelines. Read More

New York Has Widened Its Lead in Per-Capita Spending on Medicaid

New York's per-capita Medicaid spending soared to more than double the nationwide rate in 2018, widening its gap with the other 49 states. Read More

Essential Plan surplus hits $3B

As Governor Cuomo pleads for financial help from Washington, one of his state's programs is sitting on $3 billion in unspent federal aid: the Essential Plan. Read More

Upstate escapes the worst

With the coronavirus pandemic hitting some parts of New York much harder than others, Governor Cuomo has signaled that he will begin to relax shutdown restrictions in low-virus parts of the state. Here's a closer look at how infection and fatality rates vary from region to region. Read More

NY is shorted on virus relief

Although New York is taking the brunt of the coronavirus pandemic – with 43 percent of the nation's known cases and 40 percent of the deaths – the state is due to receive only 5 percent of the $150 billion Coronavirus Relief Fund just established by Congress. Read More