essential_plan-300x231-8843443New York’s Essential Plan, a very-low-cost government-funded health plan for the working poor, is taking a big bite out of the state’s market for direct-purchase private insurance, newly released data show.

As of Feb. 1, the Essential Plan had signed up 379,559 members for its first year of operation, according to a report released Friday by New York State of Health, the state’s Affordable Care Act exchange.

At the same time, the number of New Yorkers buying private coverage through the exchange plunged by 143,388, or more than one-third (see chart).

The reason is no mystery: The Essential Plan costs either $20 a month or nothing, depending on the member’s income, and comes with zero annual deductible. Private coverage, by contrast, can run hundreds of dollars a month, even with federal tax credits factored in, and often has steep deductibles. For consumers who are eligible for the Essential Plan–those with incomes up to 200 percent of the federal poverty level–it is an unbeatable bargain.

screen-shot-2016-08-17-at-10-23-15-am-6572360

The program also helps balance the state budget, thanks to the complexities of immigration policy. The state currently pays the full cost of Medicaid coverage for certain immigrants who are ineligible for federal matching funds (for instance, legal immigrants who arrived in the past five years). By switching some of those immigrants to the Essential Plan–with the feds picking up 85 percent of the cost–the Cuomo administration expects to save an estimated $645 million a year.

But the Essential Plan comes with a significant downside: Its taxpayer-subsidized low prices are luring customers away from the private market that Obamacare was supposed to bolster. Their exodus is likely to drive up premiums for those left behind–especially for the half who do not qualify for federal tax credits under the ACA–and prompt some to drop coverage. This could mark the return of a “death spiral” that all but destroyed New York’s direct-pay insurance business before the advent of national health reform.

Officials knew this might happen. A 2012 study commissioned by the Health Department projected that offering an Essential Plan would boost direct-pay premiums by $100 a year and cause 24,000 people to drop coverage. Health plans also cited the advent of the Essential Plan as one reason they wanted to raise rates by an average of 19.3 percent for 2017 (which the Department of Financial Services lowered to 16.6 percent).

For example, Fidelis Care noted in its rate application that customers eligible for the Essential Plan tend to make fewer insurance claims than average. Their expected departure “places an upward pressure on premiums,” Fidelis warned.

Friday’s report from New York State of Health confirms that those enrolling in the Essential Plan skew younger: 42 percent of its enrollees are older than 45, compared to 51 percent for those buying private coverage through the exchange.

The report also shows an increasingly lopsided split between the public- and private-sector options offered through the exchange.

In 2014, the first year the ACA was fully in effect, private coverage represented 39 percent of overall enrollment through New York’s exchange, while state-operated Medicaid and Child Health Plus accounted for 61 percent.

For 2016, however, the three public-sector options–Medicaid, Child Health Plus, and the Essential Plan–have mushroomed to 90 percent of enrollment, and private coverage is down to 10 percent.

The state’s track record measures poorly in another respect: According to an analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation, only 22 percent of the eligible population has signed up for a marketplace plan through the New York exchange, the second-lowest share of any state. This is undoubtedly related to the fact that New York has some of the highest insurance costs in the country, driven in part by state taxes and coverage mandates.

If the Cuomo administration hopes to turn this around, and have its exchange function as intended, it will have to rethink the design of the Essential Plan to avoid destabilizing the fledgling marketplace.

About the Author

Bill Hammond

As the Empire Center’s senior fellow for health policy, Bill Hammond tracks fast-moving developments in New York’s massive health care industry, with a focus on how decisions made in Albany and Washington affect the well-being of patients, providers, taxpayers and the state’s economy.

Read more by Bill Hammond

You may also like

Upstate Insurance Customers Pay the Price for Medicare’s Hospital Rate Hike

A billion-dollar Medicare windfall for upstate hospitals has turned into a crisis for upstate health insurers that's threatening to disrupt coverage for millions of New Yorkers. The Read More

New York’s Proposed ‘MCO Tax’ Would Generate a Fraction of What Lawmakers Expected

The Hochul administration's proposed "MCO tax" would generate far less than the $4 billion in extra federal aid anticipated by state lawmakers when they approved the concept this spring, according to documents obtained by t Read More

Hochul Hides the Specifics of a Looming Tax on Health Insurance

The Hochul administration has requested federal approval for a multibillion-dollar "MCO tax" on health plans without announcing the move or providing details to the public. As by l Read More

New Yorkers’ Health Costs Spiral as Officials Take Credit for ‘Savings’

The latest round of health insurance premium hikes announced by New York regulators adds to evidence that state policies are drowning consumers instead of helping them. Late last mo Read More

What Paul Francis Got Wrong About the Empire Center’s Nursing Home Research

In February 2021, the Empire Center published the first independent analysis of the Cuomo's administration much-debated directive ordering Covid-positive patients into nursing homes. The report found that the directive was associated with a statistically significant increase in resident deaths in the homes that admitted the  infected patients. Read More

Internal Cuomo Administration Documents Showed Evidence of Harm from Nursing Home Order

State Health Department documents from June 2020, newly unearthed by congressional investigators, appear to show harmful effects from a controversial order requiring nursing homes to admit Covid-positive patients. Read More

How 1199 Earns its Reputation as Albany’s No. 1 Labor Power Broker

For the fourth time in six years, the president of New York's largest health-care union, George Gresham of 1199SEIU, has won the top spot on the "Labor Power 100" list from City &am Read More

New York Runs Away from the Pack on Medicaid Spending

New York's per capita Medicaid spending jumped 14 percent in 2023, moving it further ahead of the rest of the country, recently released nationwide data show. In the federal fiscal year that ended last September, New York spent $94.6 billion Read More